- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Elimination, statements and the rules of responsible tourism
Use elimination and statement-checking methods on tourism questions, and apply the rules about reserves and permits without stating rules that may have changed.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Many tourism questions are not about a single fact. They give four statements and ask which is correct, or they ask what a responsible visitor should do. This lesson shows how to use elimination and how to reason about rules.
By the end of this lesson you can:
- Check statements one at a time against the tables of this course
- Apply the rules about reserves, permits and respect for the tribal peoples
- Choose the safest answer when a rule may change
Method for 'which statement is correct' questions
Check each statement
- Read all statements first Do not stop at the first one that looks right
- Test each against one fact Date, place, name or number
- Cross out the wrong ones One wrong word makes a statement false
- Pick the remaining one Re-read it once
A statement is false if even one word is wrong. Examiners often change a single word: 'seven wings stand today', 'Neil Island is Swaraj Dweep', 'Narcondam is active'. Watch for words such as only, always and all.
Rules and reserves
| Situation | Right reasoning |
|---|---|
| Tourist wants to enter a tribal reserve | Not allowed; the 1956 Regulation protects the reserves |
| Tourist wants to photograph the Jarawa | Forbidden |
| Visit to North Sentinel Island | Completely off limits |
| Doubt about a permit or restricted area | Check the current rules |
| Collecting shells or coral as souvenirs | Protected species may not be collected |
Why 'check the current rules' is a correct answer
Permits, restricted areas, ferry timings and park entry arrangements can change. A statement that 'no permit is ever needed' or 'a permit is needed for every island' is therefore dangerous. When a question asks what a traveller should do about rules, the best option is usually to check the current rules with the authorities of the Union Territory. This is not a way of avoiding the question; it is the true answer. Also note that the legal position of the Union Territory, for example its administration, may change over time, so questions that depend on it should be answered from the latest official sources.
Worked examples
Worked example 1. Question: 'Which statement is correct? (a) Tourists may enter the Jarawa reserve; (b) Viper Island has gallows; (c) The Chatham Saw Mill was set up in 1789; (d) Ross Island is now Shaheed Dweep.' Working: (a) is false because reserves are closed; (c) is false because the mill is 1883; (d) is false because Ross is Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose Dweep. Answer: (b).
Worked example 2. Question: 'A tour company offers a visit to a village inside a tribal reserve. What is the correct response?' Working: the 1956 Regulation closes reserves to outsiders without permission, and tourism is not a reason for permission. Answer: refuse; entry is not allowed and could harm the community.
Worked example 3. Question: 'A traveller wants to dive at a marine park. Which behaviour is responsible?' Working: coral is alive and protects the coast, so it must not be touched or broken. Answer: look but do not touch or collect coral.
Worked example 4. Question: 'A book says the Cellular Jail has seven wings and a student writes that seven stand today. Is that right?' Working: seven were built, only three stand. Answer: No; three stand today.
One wrong word makes a statement wrong. When rules may change, check the current rules.
Key takeaways: read every option, test each statement, protect reserves and reefs in your answers, and say 'check the current rules' where permits or restricted areas may change.
Check your understanding
-
1. A statement says 'Tourists are allowed in all tribal reserves'. It is:
- True
- True only in winter
- False
- True for sea visits
Show answer
Answer: C. The 1956 Regulation closes reserves to outsiders without permission, and tourists are not allowed.
-
2. A traveller is unsure about a permit for an island. The best step is to:
- Assume no permit is needed
- Check the current rules
- Rely on a friend's old trip
- Land and ask later
Show answer
Answer: B. Permits and restricted areas can change, so the current rules must be checked.
-
3. Which statement is correct?
- Neil Island is Swaraj Dweep
- The Chatham Saw Mill dates from 1979
- Viper Island has gallows
- Narcondam is the active volcano
Show answer
Answer: C. Viper Island has gallows. Neil is Shaheed, the saw mill is 1883 and Narcondam is dormant.
-
4. A diver should:
- Break coral for souvenirs
- Look without touching coral
- Feed the dugong
- Collect protected shells
Show answer
Answer: B. Coral is living; it must not be touched or broken.
-
5. 'Seven wings of the Cellular Jail stand today.' This is:
- False; three stand today
- True; all stand
- True; four stand
- False; only one stands
Show answer
Answer: A. Seven were built, but only three stand today.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.