• Advanced
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Governor's choices: assent, discretion and President's Rule

Solve hard problems on the Governor's four options on a bill, discretionary power, and the rules of President's Rule.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

At the advanced level, the question is rarely 'Who is the Governor?' It is 'What can the Governor do when a bill arrives, when no party has a majority, or when the state machinery fails?' The answers rest on a small set of articles, but the wording of an option can hide a trap. Work through the three situations below.

Situation 1: a bill reaches the Governor

Under Article 200, when a bill passed by the legislature is presented, the Governor has four choices: give assent, withhold assent, return the bill (if it is not a money bill) for reconsideration with a message, or reserve it for the President. If the legislature passes it again with or without changes, after a return, the Governor cannot withhold assent the second time. A money bill cannot be returned. Certain bills, such as those that would take away powers the Constitution gives to the High Court, must be reserved.

The four choices under Article 200
ChoiceEffect
AssentBill becomes an Act
Withhold assentBill fails (not for a bill passed again after return)
Return for reconsiderationAllowed for non-money bills only
Reserve for the PresidentPresident may give or withhold assent (Article 201)

Situation 2: when discretion applies

Article 163 says the Governor acts on ministerial advice except in matters in which the Constitution requires the Governor to act in his or her discretion. Examples often cited include the report to the President under Article 356, and in the states with Scheduled Areas under the Fifth Schedule, the Governor's special role in tribal administration. In all other matters, the Governor is bound by the advice of the Council of Ministers. Questions on a hung Assembly test the idea that the Governor invites the person who is most likely to command a majority, which is then tested on the floor of the Assembly.

Situation 3: President's Rule

Article 356 allows the President to take over the government of a state if satisfied that it cannot be carried on according to the Constitution. This can follow a report from the Governor or otherwise. A proclamation must be approved by both houses of Parliament within two months. It lasts six months at a time, and cannot go beyond three years, with conditions for any extension beyond one year. During President's Rule the Governor administers the state on behalf of the President, the Assembly is suspended or dissolved and Parliament makes laws for the state.

President's Rule step by step

  1. Failure Governor reports, or the President is otherwise satisfied
  2. Proclamation The President acts under Article 356
  3. Parliament Both houses approve within two months
  4. Duration Six months at a time; limited in total
  5. Ends The proclamation is revoked and the government is restored
Article 356

Notice how the three situations differ in who holds the final say. In the first, the Governor acts alone but within clear limits. In the second, the Governor is bound by ministerial advice in most things. In the third, the decision belongs to the President and Parliament, and the Governor only reports. A question that swaps these three roles is a typical trap.

Worked examples

Example 1. Question: 'A Governor returns an ordinary bill; the legislature passes it again unchanged. Can the Governor withhold assent?' Working: after a return, the Governor cannot withhold assent the second time. Answer: No.

Example 2. Question: 'Within what time must Parliament approve a proclamation of President's Rule?' Working: the Constitution requires approval of both houses within two months. Answer: two months.

Example 3. Question: 'Can the Governor return a money bill?' Working: the power to return applies only to a bill that is not a money bill. Answer: No.

Article 200: assent, withhold, return (not money bills), reserve. Article 356: two months for approval, six months at a time.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: the Governor has four choices on a bill, acts on ministerial advice except in a few discretionary matters, and reports on failure of the state machinery. President's Rule needs Parliament's approval in two months.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which of these can the Governor NOT do with a money bill?

    1. Give assent
    2. Withhold assent
    3. Return it for reconsideration
    4. Reserve it for the President
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The power to return a bill with a message applies only to bills that are not money bills.

  2. 2. After a bill is returned and passed again, the Governor:

    1. Cannot withhold assent
    2. May withhold assent again
    3. Must reserve it for the Assembly
    4. Must dissolve the Assembly
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 200 says the Governor shall not withhold assent from the bill when it is presented again.

  3. 3. Parliament must approve a proclamation under Article 356 within:

    1. Two weeks
    2. Six months
    3. One year
    4. Two months
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Both houses must approve within two months, or it ceases to operate.

  4. 4. Which statement about the Governor's advice is correct?

    1. The Governor never needs advice
    2. The Governor generally acts on ministerial advice except where the Constitution gives discretion
    3. The Governor always acts at discretion
    4. The Governor acts only on the Speaker's advice
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 163 states the rule and the exception.

  5. 5. When a Governor reserves a bill for the President, assent is dealt with under Article:

    1. 200
    2. 201
    3. 213
    4. 361
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 201 deals with bills reserved for the President's consideration.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery