• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Governor, Chief Minister and ministers: who does what

Practise the questions on appointments, advice, responsibility and the Governor's special role under Article 371H.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

A favourite exam pattern is 'Who appoints X?' and 'To whom is Y answerable?'. This lesson sets out the chain of appointment as a table, so that you can answer such questions at speed and see through the trap options.

By the end of this lesson you can:

  • Answer who appoints and who answers to whom
  • Recall the key articles on the Governor and the Chief Minister
  • Avoid the confusion between the Governor's two kinds of powers

The chain of appointment

Who appoints and who answers
OfficeAppointed byAnswerable toArticle
GovernorPresidentThe Constitution; holds office during the President's pleasure155 and 156
Chief MinisterGovernorLegislative Assembly164
Other ministersGovernor, on the Chief Minister's adviceLegislative Assembly, collectively164
SpeakerElected by the Assembly's membersThe Assembly178
Advocate GeneralGovernorHolds office during the Governor's pleasure165

Chain of appointment

  1. President appoints the Governor
  2. Governor appoints the Chief Minister
  3. Chief Minister advises on other ministers
  4. Ministers answer to the Assembly
Appointment runs down; answerability runs back up to the Assembly.

Aid and advice, and the exceptions

Article 163 says that the Governor acts on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers headed by the Chief Minister. The exception is where the Constitution requires the Governor to act in personal judgement. For Arunachal Pradesh, Article 371H is such a case: the Governor has a special responsibility for law and order and, after consulting the ministers, decides in his or her own judgement.

Two kinds of power

It helps to think of the Governor as having two kinds of powers. Most are used on the advice of the ministers, such as issuing orders in the government's name and summoning the Assembly. A few are used in the Governor's own judgement. In Arunachal Pradesh, law and order under Article 371H is one of these special responsibilities. Exam questions often turn on this split, so read 'on whose advice' carefully.

Traps

  • Who appoints the Chief Minister: the Governor, not the President.
  • Who removes the Chief Minister: loss of the Assembly's majority; the Governor does not dismiss at will.
  • Governor's term: five years normally, but at the President's pleasure; not fixed like an Assembly term.
  • 371H is not about the capital or the language: it is about law and order.
  • Speaker versus Governor: the Speaker is elected by the Assembly, the Governor is appointed by the President.

Worked example 1. Question: 'The Governor is appointed under which article?' Working: Article 155 provides for the appointment by the President. Answer: Article 155.

Worked example 2. Question: 'A Chief Minister loses a vote of confidence in the Assembly. What follows?' Working: the Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Assembly, so the council must resign. Answer: the whole council must go.

Worked example 3. Question: 'Who gives personal judgement on law and order in Arunachal Pradesh?' Working: under Article 371H the Governor holds that responsibility after consulting the ministers. Answer: the Governor.

Practice drill: read the verb

Most wrong answers in this topic come from reading the verb badly. 'Appoints', 'elects', 'advises' and 'removes' point to different people. The President appoints the Governor. The Governor appoints the Chief Minister. The members of the Assembly elect the Speaker. The Chief Minister advises the Governor on the other ministers. Before you look at the options, say the verb and the person in your head, then pick the option that matches. This takes three seconds and removes most careless errors.

A second habit is to watch for the word 'collectively'. When a question says the ministers are collectively responsible, the answer is the Legislative Assembly. When it says an individual minister is dismissed, the Chief Minister's advice to the Governor is the usual route. Keep both ideas clear and the options stop looking alike.

Governor: appointed by the President (Art 155). Chief Minister: appointed by the Governor (Art 164). Aid and advice: Art 163. 371H: law and order.

Key takeaways: Learn the table. Appointment runs down the chain; responsibility runs up to the Assembly.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who appoints the Chief Minister?

    1. President
    2. Speaker
    3. Governor
    4. Chief Justice
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 164: the Chief Minister is appointed by the Governor.

  2. 2. Which article says the Governor acts on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers?

    1. 163
    2. 155
    3. 171
    4. 356
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 163 lays down aid and advice.

  3. 3. Who elects the Speaker?

    1. The President
    2. The Governor
    3. The voters directly
    4. Members of the Assembly
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Speaker is elected by the Assembly's members from among themselves.

  4. 4. If the Assembly passes a no-confidence vote, the Council of Ministers must:

    1. Continue for one year
    2. Resign collectively
    3. Be dismissed by the Speaker
    4. Appeal to the High Court
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Collective responsibility means the whole council must go.

  5. 5. Article 371H gives the Governor a special responsibility for:

    1. Law and order
    2. Land revenue
    3. Trade
    4. School education
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Special responsibility for law and order in Arunachal Pradesh.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery