• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Shares and debentures: equity and debt

Tell shares from debentures, understand equity as ownership and debt as borrowing, and see how dividends, interest and the order of repayment differ.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Lesson 1 said the capital market raises long-term money through shares and debentures. These are the two great families of securities, and many exam questions test the difference between them. In one word: a shareholder is an owner; a debenture holder is a lender. Everything else follows from that. All figures here are invented and labelled 'suppose'.

Shares: equity, ownership

A company's capital is divided into small, equal units called shares. A person who buys shares becomes a part-owner (a shareholder) of the company. Ordinary shares are also called equity shares, and money raised this way is equity capital. Shareholders usually have voting rights at general meetings. They may receive a dividend, a share of profits declared by the company, but a dividend is not guaranteed: in a bad year there may be none. Shareholders bear the most risk, and in return they share in the company's growth.

Debentures: debt, borrowing

A debenture (or bond) is a document by which a company acknowledges that it has borrowed money. The debenture holder is a creditor, not an owner. He receives interest at an agreed rate, whether or not the company makes a profit, and is repaid the principal on an agreed date. Money raised this way is debt capital. Debenture holders normally have no voting rights in running the company.

Who is paid first?

If a company is closed down (wound up) and its assets sold, creditors, including debenture holders, must be paid before shareholders. Equity shareholders come last and receive only what is left. This is why equity is riskier than debt for the investor.

Equity versus debt
FeatureEquity sharesDebentures
Status of holderOwnerCreditor (lender)
ReturnDividend, not guaranteedInterest at an agreed rate
Voting rightsUsually yesUsually no
RepaymentNot repaid while the company runsRepaid on an agreed date
Order on winding upLastBefore shareholders
Risk to investorHigherLower

Between the two sits the preference share. A preference shareholder is still an owner, but gets a fixed rate of dividend that must be paid before any dividend on equity shares, and on winding up is repaid before equity shareholders (though after creditors). Preference shareholders usually have limited voting rights.

Worked example 1: dividend or interest?

Suppose Meera holds 500 equity shares of Surya Ltd with a face value of ₹10 each, and debentures of Surya Ltd with a face value of ₹50,000 at 8% interest a year. Surya declares a dividend of ₹2 per share this year. What does Meera receive? Working: Dividend = 500 × ₹2 = ₹1,000. Interest = 8% × ₹50,000 = ₹4,000. Total = ₹5,000. Answer: ₹1,000 as a shareholder and ₹4,000 as a debenture holder. If Surya made a loss next year, it could decide to pay no dividend, but it would still owe the ₹4,000 interest.

Worked example 2: share of ownership

Suppose a company has 10,00,000 equity shares in all, and Tarun owns 25,000 of them. What fraction of the company does he own, and what share of the votes on a resolution, assuming one vote per share? Working: 25,000 ÷ 10,00,000 = 1/40 = 2.5%. Answer: 2.5% of the ownership and 2.5% of the votes. A debenture holder with ₹25,00,000 of debentures in the same company would own none of it and have no vote, however large the loan.

Shareholder = owner: dividend not guaranteed, voting rights, paid last. Debenture holder = lender: fixed interest, repaid on a date, paid before shareholders.

Key takeaways: shares make you an owner and debentures make you a lender; equity capital earns uncertain dividends and carries votes, while debt earns agreed interest and must be repaid; on winding up creditors are paid before preference shareholders, who are paid before equity shareholders; equity carries more risk for the investor, and more chance of sharing in growth.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A debenture holder of a company is its:

    1. Owner
    2. Director
    3. Creditor
    4. Auditor
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A debenture is a loan to the company, so the holder is a creditor, not an owner.

  2. 2. Which is true of a dividend on equity shares?

    1. It must be paid every year whatever happens
    2. It is the same as interest on a debenture
    3. It is paid before interest to creditors
    4. It is paid out of profits and is not guaranteed
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Dividends depend on profits and the company's decision; they are not guaranteed. Interest on debt is a fixed obligation.

  3. 3. If a company is wound up, who is paid first among these?

    1. Equity shareholders
    2. Debenture holders
    3. Preference shareholders
    4. All are paid equally at the same time
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Creditors such as debenture holders come before preference shareholders, who come before equity shareholders.

  4. 4. Suppose Ravi holds debentures of face value ₹40,000 at 9% interest a year. How much interest does he receive in a year?

    1. ₹3,600
    2. ₹360
    3. ₹4,000
    4. ₹9,000
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Interest = 9% × ₹40,000 = ₹3,600.

  5. 5. Suppose a company has 5,00,000 equity shares and Asha owns 20,000. What percentage of the company does she own?

    1. 2.5%
    2. 20%
    3. 0.4%
    4. 4%
    Show answer

    Answer: D. 20,000 ÷ 5,00,000 = 0.04 = 4%.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery