- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Customer liability and digital lending: reasoning through scenarios
Decide, as a concept, who should bear a loss from an unauthorised transaction, and apply the basic principles of safe digital lending to exam scenarios.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Two topics finish this course. The first is customer liability: when money leaves an account without the customer's authority, who should bear the loss? The second is digital lending: loans sanctioned and disbursed through apps and websites. Both are tested through scenarios. This lesson treats them as concepts; the exact time windows and caps are set by the regulator and by each bank's board-approved policy, so they are not given here and should be read from the current rules.
Customer liability: where did the fault lie?
The concept rests on one question: whose failure allowed the fraud? If the loss came from the bank's own failure, such as a weak system, the customer should not bear it. If the failure lay with neither the bank nor the customer but somewhere else in the system, such as a breach at a third party, the customer's protection depends heavily on reporting promptly once they learn of the transaction. If the customer's own negligence caused it, such as sharing a PIN or OTP, the customer bears the loss up to the time of reporting, and losses after the report fall on the bank. The general idea is that the burden of showing the customer's negligence lies with the bank. Two principles therefore stand out for exams: the fault decides the starting position, and speed of reporting can only help the customer.
Worked example 1: who bears the loss?
Three customers lose money. Asha's bank had a flaw in its app that let an attacker approve transfers. Bharat read his OTP to a caller. Chitra's card data leaked in a breach at an online merchant, and she reported the unknown transactions the same day she saw them. Rank them from the strongest to the weakest claim to be protected. Working: Asha's loss came from the bank's own failure, the strongest claim. Chitra's came from a third-party breach and she reported at once, a strong claim. Bharat shared a possession factor, which is customer negligence, so he bears the loss until he reports, the weakest claim. Answer: Asha, Chitra, Bharat.
Digital lending: who is the lender?
In digital lending the customer sees an app, but the app is not necessarily the lender. The lender is a regulated entity, such as a bank or a non-banking financial company, whose money is lent and which carries the loan on its books. A lending service provider is an agent that helps the lender find borrowers, run the app or collect repayments. The safe pattern is that the loan is disbursed from the regulated lender into the borrower's own account, the borrower repays the lender, the full cost including all fees is disclosed before the loan is taken, and the app asks only for data needed for the loan with the borrower's consent. Warning signs of an illegal lender include no named regulated lender, demands for access to contacts or photos, hidden fees deducted at disbursement, and threats during recovery.
Worked example 2: the all-in cost
Suppose an app offers a loan of ₹20,000. It deducts a processing fee of ₹800 at the start and asks for interest of ₹1,200 at repayment. What is the total cost of the loan, and how much does the borrower actually receive? Working: total cost = fee + interest = 800 + 1,200 = ₹2,000, which is 2,000 ÷ 20,000 = 10% of the stated loan. Amount received = 20,000 − 800 = ₹19,200. Measured against the money actually received, the cost is 2,000 ÷ 19,200 ≈ 10.42%. The trap is to quote only the interest of ₹1,200, which is 6% of the loan, and ignore the fee. This is why an all-in cost matters.
Liability follows the fault: the bank's failure is the bank's loss; a third-party breach protects the customer who reports promptly; the customer's negligence is the customer's loss until it is reported. In a digital loan, find the regulated lender and add every fee to the interest.
Key takeaways: start every liability question by locating the fault; prompt reporting always helps the customer; the bank must show the customer's negligence; the app is not necessarily the lender; money should flow between the regulated lender and the borrower's own account; and the true cost of a loan adds fees to interest.
Check your understanding
-
1. A bank's app has a security flaw that lets an attacker move money out of customers' accounts. As a concept, who should bear the loss?
- The customer, because it was the customer's account
- The customer and the attacker equally
- Nobody, as no one shared an OTP
- The bank, because the failure was its own
Show answer
Answer: D. Liability follows the fault. A loss caused by the bank's own failure should not fall on the customer.
-
2. Which action can only help a customer who notices an unauthorised transaction?
- Waiting for the next statement to confirm it
- Reporting it to the bank at once
- Replying to the fraudster's message
- Sharing the OTP with the bank's caller
Show answer
Answer: B. Prompt reporting stops further losses and strengthens the customer's position; the other actions either delay or worsen matters.
-
3. Suppose a digital loan of ₹10,000 carries a ₹500 fee deducted at the start and ₹700 of interest at repayment. What is the total cost of the loan?
- ₹1,200
- ₹700
- ₹500
- ₹10,500
Show answer
Answer: A. Total cost = fee + interest = 500 + 700 = ₹1,200. Quoting ₹700 ignores the fee; ₹10,500 is the stated loan plus the fee and is not a cost figure.
-
4. In digital lending, which statement is accurate?
- Every lending app is itself a bank
- The loan should be paid into the app's own pool account
- The lender is the regulated entity whose money is lent, which may differ from the app the borrower sees
- Fees need not be disclosed if the interest is shown
Show answer
Answer: C. A lending service provider may run the app for a regulated lender. The safe pattern has money flowing between the lender and the borrower's own account, with the full cost disclosed.
-
5. Which is a warning sign of an illegal lending app?
- It names the regulated lender
- It shows the total cost before the loan is taken
- It demands access to the borrower's contacts and photos
- It pays the loan into the borrower's own bank account
Show answer
Answer: C. Demanding access to contacts and photos is a classic warning sign, often linked to harassment during recovery. The other three are features of the safe pattern.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.