• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Settlement drills: gross against net, liquidity needed and shortfalls

Compute each bank's net position from a table of payments, the amount that must move, the saving over gross settlement and the shortfall when an account is too small.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Settlement questions give a table of payments between several banks and ask who pays whom and how much. The method is mechanical, and the marks go to the person who keeps the columns straight. Every figure here is invented, in rupees crore.

The method

  • List every payment as from → to: amount.
  • For each bank, add up what it receives and what it pays. Net position = receives − pays.
  • Check that the net positions of all banks add up to zero.
  • The amount that must move under net settlement = the sum of the positive positions (equal to the sum of the negative ones).
  • The gross total = the sum of all the payments.

Net position = receipts − payments. The positions always add to zero. Amount to move = sum of positive positions.

Liquidity and shortfall

Under net settlement the paying banks need funds equal only to their net deficits. A bank with a net deficit must have enough balance in its account with the central bank. If its balance is smaller than its deficit, it has a shortfall equal to the difference, and must borrow or the settlement cannot be completed. Under gross settlement each bank needs enough funds to meet every payment as it falls due, which can be much more.

Worked example 1: four banks

In one batch the payments are: A→B 80, A→C 30, B→C 60, B→D 20, C→A 50, C→D 40, D→A 25, D→B 35. Find each net position, the gross total, the amount that must move and the saving. Working: A receives 50 + 25 = 75 and pays 80 + 30 = 110, so its net is −35. B receives 80 + 35 = 115 and pays 60 + 20 = 80, net +35. C receives 30 + 60 = 90 and pays 50 + 40 = 90, net 0. D receives 20 + 40 = 60 and pays 25 + 35 = 60, net 0. Check: −35 + 35 + 0 + 0 = 0. Gross total = 80 + 30 + 60 + 20 + 50 + 40 + 25 + 35 = ₹340 crore. Under net settlement only A pays B ₹35 crore, which is 35 ÷ 340 ≈ 10.3% of the gross amount. The saving is 340 − 35 = ₹305 crore of funds that need not be found.

Worked example 2: a shortfall

In the example above, Bank A's account holds ₹20 crore before settlement. What is its shortfall, and what are its options? Working: A's deficit is ₹35 crore and its balance is ₹20 crore, so the shortfall = 35 − 20 = ₹15 crore. A can borrow ₹15 crore from another bank, or borrow from the central bank under a facility against securities, or receive funds from a payment it is waiting for. If A cannot find the money, settlement of the batch cannot be completed in the ordinary way. The central bank then decides on its response, since a failure to settle can trouble other banks that are waiting to be paid.

Worked example 3: three banks, quickly

P→Q 60, Q→R 40, R→P 30. Find the net positions and the amount that moves. Working: P receives 30 and pays 60: −30. Q receives 60 and pays 40: +20. R receives 40 and pays 30: +10. The positions add to −30 + 20 + 10 = 0. The amount that moves is 30 (P pays 20 to Q and 10 to R), against a gross total of 60 + 40 + 30 = 130.

Gross against net: which risk?

Net settlement saves funds but a payment is not final until the batch is settled. If one bank cannot settle, the whole batch may have to be recalculated, which can pass the problem to others. Gross settlement removes that risk, because each payment is final when settled, but it needs more funds. Which is better depends on the amounts: large-value payments are usually settled gross because the risk of waiting is high.

Key takeaways: net position = receipts − payments; the positions always sum to zero; the amount that moves is the sum of positive positions; a shortfall = deficit − balance; net settlement saves funds, gross settlement gives immediate finality.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Bank M receives ₹90 crore and pays ₹70 crore in one batch (invented). What is its net position?

    1. −₹20 crore
    2. +₹160 crore
    3. +₹20 crore
    4. −₹90 crore
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Net = receipts − payments = 90 − 70 = +₹20 crore.

  2. 2. Three banks have net positions of +30, −50 and one other. What is the third?

    1. −20
    2. +50
    3. +20
    4. 0
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The positions must add to zero: 30 − 50 + x = 0, so x = +20.

  3. 3. P→Q 60, Q→R 40, R→P 30 (in ₹ crore). What amount must move under net settlement?

    1. ₹30 crore
    2. ₹130 crore
    3. ₹60 crore
    4. ₹40 crore
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Net positions: P = −30, Q = +20, R = +10. The positive positions sum to 30, so ₹30 crore moves.

  4. 4. A bank has a net deficit of ₹35 crore and an account balance of ₹20 crore. What is its shortfall?

    1. ₹55 crore
    2. ₹20 crore
    3. ₹35 crore
    4. ₹15 crore
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Shortfall = 35 − 20 = ₹15 crore.

  5. 5. What is the main advantage of gross settlement over net settlement?

    1. It needs far less money in accounts
    2. Each payment is final when settled
    3. It is always cheaper for the banks
    4. It ignores the central bank's accounts
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Gross settlement makes each payment final when it is settled, at the cost of needing more funds. Net settlement needs less money.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery