• Advanced
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Tracing a case through every stage

Read a long complaint story, locate the stage it has reached, name the correct next step and keep a running account of the amount still in dispute.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Advanced questions rarely ask for the ladder itself. They tell a long story with several events, some relevant and some not, and ask where the case stands, what the next lawful step is, or how much is still in dispute. The skill is to build a timeline and strip away noise. All rupee figures are invented and marked "suppose". Waiting periods, limits and other operating details belong to the schemes themselves and can change, so this course says "within the time the scheme allows" and never quotes them.

Build a stage table

Write the events as rows: what happened, who acted, and what amount was affected. Then mark each row with its stage: bank (branch, complaint channel, grievance cell, nodal officer, internal ombudsman), ombudsman (complaint, settlement attempt, award or rejection), appeal (appellate authority) or side door (consumer commission, civil court). The last completed row tells you the stage; the gates tell you whether the next stage is open.

Last completed eventStage reachedUsual next step
Written complaint, awaiting replyBankWait within the time the scheme allows; escalate inside the bank
Bank rejected or replied unsatisfactorilyBank, exhaustedRBI's ombudsman, within the time the scheme allows
Ombudsman settlement reachedClosed by agreementNone on the same grounds
Ombudsman award or rejectionOmbudsman decidedAppeal on the grounds the scheme allows
Case filed in a consumer commissionSide doorCommission proceeds; ombudsman closed for that matter

Noise to ignore

Stories add details that do not change the stage: the customer phoned a call centre, posted on social media, or spoke to a relative who works at another bank. A phone call may start the bank stage, but a written complaint with a reference is what can be proved later. A social media post is not a complaint to the ombudsman. Who owns the ATM does not change which bank the customer complains to: the customer's own bank holds the account and the contract.

Keep a running amount

Each stage may return some money. Track: amount wrongly taken, minus amounts properly due, minus amounts returned at each stage. What is left is what the next stage is about. An option that quotes the original amount after a partial refund is a standard distractor.

Timeline, stage, gates, running amount. The last completed event fixes the stage; the gates decide whether the next stage is open; the running amount is what the next stage is about.

Worked example 1: a noisy story

Suppose Vikram tries to withdraw ₹4,000 at another bank's ATM; no cash comes out but his account is debited. The same week a cheque he deposited is wrongly returned and his bank charges a ₹350 return fee, though the cheque was in order. He phones the call centre, tweets about it, and then writes to his bank with both issues. The bank reverses nothing and rejects the complaint in writing. Stage: bank exhausted. Gates: bank first (written complaint), bank failed (rejection), nothing pending elsewhere, both are service deficiencies. Running amount: 4,000 + 350 = ₹4,350. Next step: the RBI's ombudsman within the time the scheme allows. The tweet and the ATM's owner are noise.

Worked example 2: after the ombudsman

Continue. The ombudsman's office facilitates a settlement in which the bank agrees to refund the ₹4,000 but disputes the ₹350, and Vikram accepts the ₹4,000 as settlement of the ATM issue only. The cheque-fee issue is not settled; the ombudsman decides it by award in Vikram's favour. Stage for the ATM issue: closed by agreement. Stage for the fee: decided by award in his favour. Running amount: 4,350 − 4,000 − 350 = nil. There is nothing left for Vikram to appeal. A distractor will say he should appeal for ₹350; but the award already granted it.

Key takeaways

Turn every story into a stage table. Ignore noise that does not change the stage. Treat each issue in a multi-issue complaint as its own thread, because they can end at different stages. Keep the running amount and check whether anything is actually left before proposing a next step.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Gita complained in writing to her bank about a wrong debit; the bank has acknowledged it and the time the scheme allows for a reply has not yet passed. What stage is the case at, and what is the next step?

    1. Ombudsman stage; wait for the award
    2. Bank stage; wait for the reply or escalate inside the bank
    3. Appeal stage; approach the appellate authority
    4. Closed; nothing more can be done
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The bank has not failed yet. The ombudsman route opens only after rejection, an unsatisfactory reply or no reply within the time allowed.

  2. 2. A customer's ATM withdrawal failed at another bank's machine and her account was debited. She tweeted about it, phoned the ATM owner and has written to no one. Which statement is correct?

    1. Her tweet counts as a complaint to the ombudsman
    2. She must complain first to the bank that owns the ATM
    3. She can go straight to the appellate authority
    4. She has not yet made a written complaint to her own bank, which is the step to take now
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Her contract is with her own bank. A tweet and a call to the ATM owner are not a written complaint to her bank.

  3. 3. Suppose a customer was wrongly debited ₹5,000; the branch refunded ₹2,000 and the bank then rejected the rest. How much should the ombudsman complaint claim?

    1. ₹3,000
    2. ₹5,000
    3. ₹2,000
    4. ₹7,000
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 5,000 − 2,000 = ₹3,000 remains in dispute.

  4. 4. A complaint with two issues ends with issue A settled by agreement and issue B rejected by the ombudsman. What may the complainant consider next?

    1. An appeal on both issues
    2. A fresh complaint to the ombudsman on issue A on the same grounds
    3. An appeal on issue B on the grounds the scheme allows
    4. Nothing, because one issue was settled
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Each issue is its own thread. A settled issue is closed; a rejected issue can be appealed on the grounds the scheme allows.

  5. 5. Suppose a customer claimed ₹4,350; ₹4,000 was settled by agreement and the remaining ₹350 was granted by award. How much is left to appeal?

    1. ₹350
    2. ₹4,000
    3. Nil
    4. ₹4,350
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 4,350 − 4,000 − 350 = 0. Nothing remains, so no appeal is needed.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Maintainability edge cases

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery