- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
When the ombudsman cannot help, and the appeal stage
Recognise complaints the ombudsman scheme does not take, and understand the appellate authority as the next step after an ombudsman decision.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Not every unhappy customer has a case the ombudsman can hear. The scheme lists kinds of complaint it does not take, and it also provides a further step for those who disagree with the ombudsman's decision. Knowing both ends of the scheme stops you from choosing the wrong door. Any rupee figure in this course is invented and marked "suppose"; the rules of real schemes, including how long you must wait at each step, are set by the schemes themselves and can change, so this course describes the idea and says "within the time the scheme allows" instead of giving numbers.
Complaints the scheme does not take
The details are in the scheme itself, but the main ideas are stable and sensible. The ombudsman generally does not take a complaint when:
- The customer did not complain to the bank first.
- The same matter is already pending before, or has been decided by, a court, tribunal, arbitrator or consumer forum.
- The same complaint has already been dealt with by the ombudsman on the same grounds.
- It is about the bank's commercial judgement, such as its decision, after its own credit assessment, not to give a loan.
- It is a dispute between the bank and its own employee about employment.
- It is brought after the time the scheme allows.
Two of these deserve thought. Commercial judgement means business decisions the bank is entitled to make, such as whether to lend to a particular borrower. The ombudsman checks service, not business choices. But if the bank failed to follow its own rules while deciding, for example by never replying to a loan application, that failure is a service matter. Parallel cases are excluded so that two bodies do not decide the same dispute and reach different answers.
The appellate authority
If a complainant is not satisfied with the ombudsman's decision, the scheme provides an appellate authority within the Reserve Bank. An appeal is a request to a higher authority to look again at a decision. It must be made on the grounds the scheme allows and within the time the scheme allows. The appellate authority is the step after the ombudsman; nobody can go to it directly from the bank.
Not taken by the ombudsman: not first raised with the bank, already before a court or forum, already decided, commercial judgement, employee disputes. After the ombudsman's decision comes the appellate authority.
Worked example 1: three complaints
Suppose the ombudsman receives three complaints. (1) Kiran's bank refused her a business loan after assessing her repayment capacity; she says the refusal was unfair. This is the bank's commercial judgement, so the ombudsman would not take it. (2) Arjun, a bank clerk, says the bank denied him a promotion. This is an employment dispute, outside the scheme. (3) Sunita complained to her bank that ₹1,200 of charges were applied without notice; the bank replied refusing to reverse them. She complained to the bank first and the issue is a service deficiency, so the ombudsman can take it.
Worked example 2: the order of steps after an award
Suppose the ombudsman passes an award asking the bank to refund ₹700 of Sunita's ₹1,200, finding that one ₹500 charge had been properly notified. Sunita believes the whole ₹1,200 was charged without notice. Her next step within the scheme is the appellate authority, on the grounds and within the time the scheme allows. If she wins entirely, the remaining amount in dispute is 1,200 − 700 = ₹500. She does not go back to the branch, and she does not start a fresh ombudsman complaint on the same grounds.
Key takeaways
The ombudsman checks deficiency in service, not the bank's business decisions or employment disputes, and does not take matters already before another forum. A decision of the ombudsman can be taken to the appellate authority within the RBI on the grounds the scheme allows.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which complaint would the ombudsman generally not take?
- A bank refused a loan after assessing the borrower's repayment capacity
- Charges were applied without notice and the bank refused to reverse them
- An ATM debited the account but gave no cash, and the bank did not fix it
- A loan was repaid but the bank did not return the property papers
Show answer
Answer: A. Refusing a loan after a credit assessment is the bank's commercial judgement. The other three are deficiencies in service.
-
2. A customer's dispute with the bank is already pending before a consumer commission. Can the ombudsman take the same complaint?
- Yes, the ombudsman always takes priority
- No, because the same matter is already before another forum
- Yes, if the customer asks the ombudsman politely
- No, because ombudsmen hear only employee disputes
Show answer
Answer: B. The scheme excludes matters pending before or decided by a court, tribunal, arbitrator or consumer forum, so two bodies do not decide the same dispute.
-
3. What is the appellate authority in the ombudsman scheme?
- The first place to complain about a bank
- The bank's branch manager
- A court that hears all banking cases first
- A higher authority within the RBI that hears appeals against the ombudsman's decisions
Show answer
Answer: D. The appellate authority comes after the ombudsman and looks again at its decision on grounds the scheme allows.
-
4. Suppose an award gives a customer ₹700 of a ₹1,200 claim. How much remains in dispute if she appeals for the full amount?
- ₹500
- ₹700
- ₹1,200
- ₹1,900
Show answer
Answer: A. 1,200 − 700 = ₹500 remains in dispute.
-
5. A bank employee complains to the ombudsman that he was transferred unfairly. Why will the scheme not take it?
- Employees are never allowed to bank anywhere
- The ombudsman deals only with loan refusals
- It is an employment dispute between the bank and its employee
- Transfers are decided by consumer commissions
Show answer
Answer: C. Disputes between a bank and its own staff about employment are outside the scheme, which deals with deficiency in service to customers.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.