• Advanced
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Multi-event NAV problems: price moves, flows, expenses and payouts together

Work out a fund's NAV through a sequence of events, find a missing holding from a known NAV, and calculate the daily effect of the expense ratio on net assets and on each unit.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The foundation course defined NAV, and the practice course used it one event at a time: a price move, a purchase, a redemption or a payout. Advanced questions string several of these together in a single problem, or give you the NAV and ask you to work backwards to something that is missing. The skill tested is discipline: taking events in order and knowing which ones move the NAV. All figures in this course are invented and labelled 'suppose'; they are not the actual NAVs, returns, charges or limits of any fund, and nothing here is a recommendation to buy, sell or switch anything.

Put the events in time order

Write the events down in the order they happen and carry two running figures: net assets and units. A change in the market value of holdings changes net assets but not units, so the NAV moves. A purchase or redemption at the day's NAV changes net assets and units in the same proportion, so the NAV does not move, although the new units must be counted for every later step. A payout to unit holders takes cash out of net assets without changing units, so the NAV falls by the amount paid per unit. Expenses accrue gradually and also reduce net assets without changing units.

The commonest error in a long problem is applying a percentage move to the wrong base. If holdings fall 2% after new money has come in, the 2% applies to the larger pool, which includes the new money now invested. If a payout happens before a price rise, the rise applies to the smaller NAV left after the payout. Order matters whenever percentages and fixed amounts are mixed.

Shortcut: work per unit when units do not change

Between flows, the number of units is fixed, so you can work with the NAV directly instead of net assets. A 10% rise in holdings that make up the whole fund raises the NAV by 10%; a payout of ₹4 per unit lowers it by ₹4. Because a purchase or redemption at NAV leaves the NAV unchanged, you can often skip the flows entirely when the question asks only for the final NAV. You need the flows only when the question asks for net assets, units or an investor's share.

Working backwards to a missing figure

If you know the NAV and the units, you know net assets: NAV × units. Subtract every holding you know, add back the liabilities, and what is left is the value of the missing holding. Divide that by the number of shares held to get the missing price.

Daily accrual of expenses

A fund does not deduct a whole year's expenses on one day. A simple model used in questions spreads them evenly: daily expense ≈ net assets × annual expense ratio ÷ 365. Dividing that by the number of units gives the tiny amount by which the NAV is reduced each day, other things being equal.

Worked example 1: three events in a row

Suppose a fund has net assets of ₹200 crore and 10 crore units, so its NAV is ₹20. On day 1 its holdings rise in value by ₹6 crore. On day 2 investors put in ₹41.2 crore. On day 3 all its holdings fall 2%. Working: after day 1, net assets = ₹206 crore and NAV = 206 ÷ 10 = ₹20.60. On day 2 the new money buys 41.2 ÷ 20.60 = 2 crore units, so net assets = ₹247.2 crore, units = 12 crore, and the NAV is still ₹20.60. On day 3 the fall is 2% of 247.2 = ₹4.944 crore, so net assets = ₹242.256 crore and NAV = 242.256 ÷ 12 = ₹20.188. Per-unit check: 20.60 × 0.98 = 20.188, the same answer, because the purchase at NAV did not change the NAV.

Worked example 2: the missing holding

Suppose a fund's NAV is ₹32 and it has 6 crore units. It holds shares of company X worth ₹90 crore, bonds worth ₹55 crore, cash of ₹20 crore and 40 lakh shares of company Y, and it owes ₹5 crore. Working: net assets = 32 × 6 = ₹192 crore. Known items = 90 + 55 + 20 − 5 = ₹160 crore. So the Y shares are worth 192 − 160 = ₹32 crore, and the price of one Y share = ₹32 crore ÷ 40 lakh = 3,20,00,000 ÷ 40,00,000 = ₹80.

Worked example 3: a day's expenses

Suppose a fund has net assets of ₹365 crore, an annual expense ratio of 1.46% and 36.5 crore units (NAV ₹10). Working: daily expense = 365 × 0.0146 ÷ 365 = ₹0.0146 crore = ₹1.46 lakh. Per unit = 1,46,000 ÷ 36,50,00,000 = ₹0.0004. Over a year this adds up to 1.46% of the NAV, which is the whole point of the expense ratio.

Prices, expenses and payouts move the NAV; purchases and redemptions at NAV do not. Apply events in time order, apply each percentage to the pool as it stands at that moment, and use net assets = NAV × units to work backwards.

Key takeaways: carry net assets and units together through a sequence; count the new units after a purchase but do not expect them to move the NAV; a payout lowers the NAV by the amount per unit; work per unit when units are fixed; to find a missing holding, start from NAV × units; and a day's expenses are about one 365th of the annual expense ratio applied to net assets.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Suppose a fund has net assets of ₹150 crore and 6 crore units. Its holdings rise in value by ₹3 crore, and then investors put in ₹25.5 crore at the new NAV. What is the NAV after both events?

    1. ₹29.75
    2. ₹25.50
    3. ₹25.00
    4. ₹22.31
    Show answer

    Answer: B. After the rise, net assets = ₹153 crore and NAV = 153 ÷ 6 = ₹25.50. The ₹25.5 crore buys 25.5 ÷ 25.50 = 1 crore units, so net assets = ₹178.5 crore over 7 crore units = ₹25.50. ₹29.75 forgets the new units; ₹25 ignores the price rise.

  2. 2. Suppose a fund's NAV is ₹15 with 8 crore units. It holds shares worth ₹70 crore, bonds worth ₹30 crore, cash of ₹12 crore and 25 lakh shares of company Z, and owes ₹2 crore. What is the price of one Z share?

    1. ₹40
    2. ₹400
    3. ₹4
    4. ₹48
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Net assets = 15 × 8 = ₹120 crore. Known items = 70 + 30 + 12 − 2 = ₹110 crore. Z shares are worth ₹10 crore, so one share = 10,00,00,000 ÷ 25,00,000 = ₹40.

  3. 3. Suppose a fund has net assets of ₹730 crore and an annual expense ratio of 1%. Using the simple daily model, about how much expense accrues in one day?

    1. ₹7.3 crore
    2. ₹2 lakh
    3. ₹20 lakh
    4. ₹73 lakh
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Daily expense = 730 × 0.01 ÷ 365 = ₹0.02 crore = ₹2 lakh. ₹7.3 crore is the whole year's expense.

  4. 4. Taken on its own, which of these changes a fund's NAV?

    1. Investors buying new units at the day's NAV
    2. Investors redeeming units at the day's NAV
    3. An increase in the number of investors with the same total units
    4. A fall in the market price of bonds the fund holds
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A price fall reduces net assets while units stay the same, so the NAV falls. Purchases and redemptions at NAV change net assets and units in the same proportion, and the number of investors does not enter the formula.

  5. 5. Suppose a fund's NAV is ₹40. Its holdings then rise 10%, it pays out ₹4 per unit, and its holdings then fall 5%. What is the NAV at the end?

    1. ₹38
    2. ₹41.80
    3. ₹40
    4. ₹36
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Per unit: 40 × 1.10 = ₹44; after the payout 44 − 4 = ₹40; after the fall 40 × 0.95 = ₹38. ₹41.80 ignores the payout; the fall applies to the NAV left after the payout.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery