- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Hard validity cases: interest, instalments, description and time
Decide quickly whether wording with interest, instalments, a described payee or a time for payment still makes a valid note, bill or cheque, and tell a cheque from a bill drawn on a bank.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The foundation course listed the essential features of a negotiable instrument, and the practice course turned them into a five-gate check: writing and signature, a promise or an order, no condition, a certain sum of money only, and a certain payee. Advanced questions are built the other way round. They give wording that looks as if it breaks a gate but does not, and mix it with wording that really does. This lesson collects the tricky cases that sections 4 and 5 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 settle, and adds the time test that separates a cheque from other bills. All names and amounts are invented.
Wording that does not make the sum uncertain
The gate 'a certain sum of money' asks whether the amount can be worked out from the document itself. The Act explains that three common additions do not spoil it. First, future interest: 'I promise to pay ₹40,000 with interest at 9% a year' is certain, because anyone can calculate the amount due on any date. Second, instalments: a promise to pay ₹40,000 in four equal quarterly instalments is certain, and stays certain even if it adds that on default of any instalment the whole unpaid balance becomes due at once. Third, payment at an indicated rate of exchange is certain. What does spoil the sum is anything that makes the amount depend on facts outside the document, such as other debts, deductions or set-offs, or anything that adds something other than money.
Wording that does not make the payee uncertain
The payee must be a certain person, but he need not be named correctly. The Act accepts a payee who is misnamed or designated by description only, as long as it is clear to whom payment is to be made. 'Pay the Treasurer of the Ramnagar Youth Club or order' is valid, because only one person holds that office. A spelling mistake in a name ('Pay Suresh Kumarr') does not destroy the instrument either. The test is whether the person can be identified, not whether the name is perfect.
Time for payment: the cheque test
Section 6 makes a cheque a bill of exchange drawn on a specified banker and not expressed to be payable otherwise than on demand. So two questions decide whether an order is a cheque: is the drawee a banker, and is it payable on demand? An order that states no time is payable on demand. But 'Pay Rahul or order ₹6,000 thirty days after sight', even when addressed to a bank, is expressed to be payable otherwise than on demand. It is still a bill of exchange, but not a cheque. Equally, an order on demand addressed to a private person is a bill, never a cheque, because the drawee is not a banker.
| Wording added | Effect on validity | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| 'with interest at 10% a year' | Still valid | Interest at a stated rate keeps the sum certain |
| 'in five equal monthly instalments' | Still valid | Instalments are allowed |
| 'balance due at once if any instalment is missed' | Still valid | The default clause is allowed |
| 'after deducting what you owe me' | Invalid | The final amount depends on another debt |
| 'and deliver ten bags of rice' | Invalid | Not money only |
| 'to the Secretary of the Lakeview Housing Society' | Still valid | A payee designated by description is certain |
Worked example 1: four documents
Which of these signed documents are valid promissory notes? (a) 'I promise to pay Kavya or order ₹30,000 with interest at 8% a year.' (b) 'I promise to pay Kavya ₹30,000 in three equal monthly instalments; if any instalment is not paid, the whole balance shall become due.' (c) 'I promise to pay Kavya ₹30,000 less any amount she owes me on the date of payment.' (d) 'I promise to pay the Principal of Sunrise Public School, Nagpur, ₹30,000.' Working: (a) future interest at a stated rate: sum certain, valid. (b) instalments with a default clause: sum certain, valid. (c) the amount depends on another debt: sum uncertain, invalid. (d) a payee by description who can be identified: valid. Answer: (a), (b) and (d).
Worked example 2: cheque or not?
Classify each signed order, if valid. (a) To City Bank: 'Pay Ritu or order ₹12,000.' (b) To City Bank: 'Pay Ritu or order ₹12,000 fifteen days after sight.' (c) To Mr Joshi: 'Pay Ritu or order ₹12,000 on demand.' (d) To City Bank: 'Pay Ritu or order ₹12,000 on demand.' Working: (a) banker, no time stated, so on demand: cheque. (b) banker, but payable after sight, not on demand: a bill of exchange that is not a cheque. (c) on demand, but the drawee is a private person: bill of exchange, not a cheque. (d) banker and expressly on demand: cheque. Answer: (a) and (d) are cheques; (b) and (c) are bills of exchange that are not cheques. The same words 'or order ₹12,000' appear in all four; only the drawee and the time decide.
Speed method
When a question gives several documents, scan for the dangerous words first: 'if', 'unless', 'when I marry', 'less', 'deducting', 'and deliver', 'I.O.U.'. Then scan for the harmless ones the examiner hopes will scare you: 'with interest at', 'by instalments', 'balance becomes due', a payee described by office, and an event certain to happen such as a death. Finally, for any order, ask the two cheque questions: banker? on demand? This three-pass scan settles most questions in under a minute.
Interest at a stated rate, instalments, a default clause and a payee described by office do not spoil an instrument. An order is a cheque only if it is drawn on a specified banker AND payable on demand.
Key takeaways: the sum is certain if it can be calculated from the document, so interest and instalments are allowed while deductions are not; a misnamed or described payee is fine if identifiable; and a bill drawn on a bank becomes a cheque only when it is payable on demand. Lesson 2 moves from validity to the people on an instrument and who is liable to whom.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which addition makes a promise to pay ₹20,000 invalid as a promissory note?
- 'with interest at 7% a year'
- 'in four equal instalments'
- 'after deducting the rent you owe me'
- 'the whole balance due if an instalment is missed'
Show answer
Answer: C. Deducting another debt makes the final sum depend on facts outside the document, so it is uncertain. Interest, instalments and a default clause keep the sum certain.
-
2. An order signed by Neha and addressed to her bank reads 'Pay Amit or order ₹9,000 twenty days after sight.' What is it?
- A cheque
- A bill of exchange that is not a cheque
- A promissory note
- Not a negotiable instrument at all
Show answer
Answer: B. It is an order on a banker, but it is expressed to be payable otherwise than on demand, so it is a bill of exchange but not a cheque.
-
3. 'I promise to pay the Secretary of the Green Park Residents Association ₹15,000 or order', signed. Is the payee certain?
- No, because no personal name is given
- No, because an association cannot be paid
- Yes, but only if the secretary's name is added later
- Yes, a payee designated by description is certain if identifiable
Show answer
Answer: D. The Act accepts a payee designated by description only, as long as it is clear who is to be paid.
-
4. Which order is a cheque?
- 'Pay Sara or order ₹5,000', addressed to Mr Iyer
- 'Pay Sara or order ₹5,000 on demand', addressed to Mr Iyer
- 'Pay Sara or order ₹5,000', addressed to Star Bank
- 'Pay Sara or order ₹5,000 sixty days after date', addressed to Star Bank
Show answer
Answer: C. A cheque must be drawn on a specified banker and be payable on demand. Only the order addressed to Star Bank with no time stated meets both tests.
-
5. Consider: (1) A promise to pay ₹50,000 with interest at a stated rate is a valid note. (2) A note payable by instalments is invalid. (3) Misspelling the payee's name always makes a note invalid. Which are correct?
- 1 only
- 1 and 2 only
- 2 and 3 only
- 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Answer: A. Only 1 is correct. Instalments are allowed, and a misnamed payee is acceptable if he can be identified.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.