• Foundation
  • About 12 min
  • 5 practice questions

Presumptions in favour of an instrument, and the effect of alteration

State what the law presumes about a negotiable instrument until the contrary is proved, and explain the effect of altering an instrument and who may still benefit.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

A person who holds a negotiable instrument should not have to prove every step of its history in court. The Negotiable Instruments Act therefore gives the holder some helpful presumptions, and it sets rules for what happens when someone tampers with an instrument. This lesson covers both. They are exam favourites because they are short rules with a clear one-line answer.

What is presumed

A presumption is something the court takes to be true until the contrary is proved. The person who denies it carries the burden of proof. Until the contrary is proved, the Act presumes that:

  • every negotiable instrument was made or drawn for consideration, and every transfer or endorsement was made for consideration;
  • it bears the date it shows;
  • an accepted bill was accepted within a reasonable time after its date and before maturity;
  • it was transferred before its maturity;
  • the endorsements appear on it in the order in which they are written;
  • a lost instrument was duly stamped;
  • the holder is a holder in due course.

The last presumption is the most useful to a holder: he need not first prove that he gave value in good faith. But the presumption in favour of a holder is rebutted if the instrument was obtained by fraud, unlawful means or for an unlawful consideration. Then the holder must prove that he is a holder in due course.

Material alteration

A material alteration is a change that affects the legal rights of the parties, for example a change in the amount, the date, the time of payment, the rate of interest, the place of payment, or the payee. Under the Act, a material alteration makes the instrument void against every party who was a party at the time of the alteration and did not consent, unless it was made to carry out the original common intention of the parties. Changing the spelling of a name or correcting an obvious slip is not material.

If an endorsee alters the instrument, his own endorser is discharged from liability to him. Separately, a banker who pays a cheque in due course, when the alteration does not appear on its face, is protected, because he could not see the change.

Worked examples

Example 1. Nina sues Mohan on a promissory note, and Mohan says he never received anything in return. Because consideration is presumed, Mohan must prove there was none. Nina need not prove it first. If Mohan proves it, the presumption falls.

Example 2. A cheque for ₹6,000 is altered by the payee, without the drawer's consent, to read ₹16,000. The change in amount is material, so the cheque is void against the drawer, who did not consent. The drawer cannot be made to pay either figure on that cheque.

Example 3. An accepted bill is endorsed in this order: Anil, Bela, Chetan. The holder, Chetan, shows the bill with these endorsements. The Act presumes that the endorsements were made in the order shown. A person who disputes it must prove the contrary.

Example 4. A clerk corrects a payee's name from 'Raman' to 'Ramana' to match the account record, with the drawer's agreement. This carries out the parties' intention and is not a material alteration affecting liability. (That is the position in law; for a cheque cleared under CTS-2010, though, a bank would ask for a fresh cheque, since only a date correction is allowed on its face.)

The law starts on the holder's side: consideration, date, order of endorsements and holder in due course are presumed until disproved. A material alteration without consent voids the instrument against non-consenting parties.

Key takeaways. Presumptions are rebuttable: the party who denies them must prove the contrary. A material alteration changes legal rights, and without consent it voids the instrument against the parties who did not agree. A banker who pays an altered cheque in due course is protected when the alteration is not apparent.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Until the contrary is proved, a negotiable instrument is presumed to have been made:

    1. Without consideration
    2. For consideration
    3. Only for charity
    4. After its maturity
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Act presumes consideration for the making and transfer of every negotiable instrument. The party denying it must prove otherwise.

  2. 2. Who must prove that there was no consideration, when the presumption applies?

    1. The holder who sues him
    2. The bank of the drawer
    3. The party who denies it
    4. The court hearing the case
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The presumption favours the holder, so the burden of proof is on the party who denies it.

  3. 3. Which of these is a material alteration of a cheque?

    1. Correcting the spelling of the bank's name
    2. Changing the amount from ₹6,000 to ₹16,000
    3. Writing the date more neatly
    4. Underlining the payee's name
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A change in the amount alters the rights of the parties, so it is material. The others do not change who owes what.

  4. 4. What is the effect of a material alteration made without a party's consent?

    1. The instrument is void against that party
    2. The instrument is cancelled against everyone, including the alterer
    3. The instrument is valid but its amount is halved
    4. The party must pay the original amount
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A material alteration voids the instrument against a party who was a party at the time and did not consent.

  5. 5. Which is presumed in favour of the holder of a negotiable instrument?

    1. That he is a holder in due course
    2. That he is the drawer
    3. That he is a banker
    4. That the instrument is post-dated
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Act presumes that the holder is a holder in due course, until the contrary is proved.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery