| Situation | Governor acts on | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Appointing ministers other than the Chief Minister | Advice of the Chief Minister | Article 164(1) |
| Summoning the Houses | Advice of the Council | Normal rule |
| Appointing a Chief Minister when no party has a clear majority | Own judgement | No Council yet exists to advise |
| Reporting that the state government cannot be carried on under the Constitution | Own judgement | Basis of Article 356 |
| Asking the Chief Minister for information about the administration | Governor's own right | Article 167 makes it the Chief Minister's duty to supply it |
Path to President's rule
- Governor's report Government cannot be carried on under the Constitution
- President's proclamation Article 356
- Parliament's approval Within two months
- Extension In steps of six months, normally up to one year
Advice is the rule (163(1)); discretion is the exception, and the Governor decides what is discretion (163(2)). Article 361 protects the person, not the decision (Bommai, 1994).
Key takeaways: treat advice as the default; identify the few discretionary acts; separate the Governor's immunity from the reviewability of decisions; and test any claim by asking whether it confuses the person with the act.