Advice and discretion
SituationGovernor acts onWhy
Appointing ministers other than the Chief MinisterAdvice of the Chief MinisterArticle 164(1)
Summoning the HousesAdvice of the CouncilNormal rule
Appointing a Chief Minister when no party has a clear majorityOwn judgementNo Council yet exists to advise
Reporting that the state government cannot be carried on under the ConstitutionOwn judgementBasis of Article 356
Asking the Chief Minister for information about the administrationGovernor's own rightArticle 167 makes it the Chief Minister's duty to supply it

Path to President's rule

  1. Governor's report Government cannot be carried on under the Constitution
  2. President's proclamation Article 356
  3. Parliament's approval Within two months
  4. Extension In steps of six months, normally up to one year
Article 356 in outline

Advice is the rule (163(1)); discretion is the exception, and the Governor decides what is discretion (163(2)). Article 361 protects the person, not the decision (Bommai, 1994).

Key takeaways: treat advice as the default; identify the few discretionary acts; separate the Governor's immunity from the reviewability of decisions; and test any claim by asking whether it confuses the person with the act.