- Advanced
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
The Governor's powers and discretion: hard questions
Separate the Governor's acts on advice from the few acts done in discretion, and judge statements on assent, dissolution, President's rule and immunity.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The hard questions on the Governor of Bihar are not about the Articles one by one but about their limits: what the Governor must do on advice, what may be done on personal judgement, and what the courts may examine. This lesson builds a framework for those questions and then tests it on statement and assertion-reason problems.
The general rule and the exception
Article 163(1) says there shall be a Council of Ministers with the Chief Minister at the head to aid and advise the Governor except in so far as the Governor is, by or under the Constitution, required to act in his or her discretion. So advice is the rule and discretion is the exception. Article 163(2) adds that if a question arises whether a matter is one for discretion, the Governor's decision is final, and the validity of what the Governor does cannot be questioned on the ground that the Governor ought or ought not to have acted in discretion.
| Situation | Governor acts on | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Appointing ministers other than the Chief Minister | Advice of the Chief Minister | Article 164(1) |
| Summoning the Houses | Advice of the Council | Normal rule |
| Appointing a Chief Minister when no party has a clear majority | Own judgement | No Council yet exists to advise |
| Reporting that the state government cannot be carried on under the Constitution | Own judgement | Basis of Article 356 |
| Asking the Chief Minister for information about the administration | Governor's own right | Article 167 makes it the Chief Minister's duty to supply it |
Path to President's rule
- Governor's report Government cannot be carried on under the Constitution
- President's proclamation Article 356
- Parliament's approval Within two months
- Extension In steps of six months, normally up to one year
Immunity and judicial review
Article 361 protects the Governor from being answerable to any court for the exercise of official powers, and bars criminal proceedings against the Governor during the term of office. This does not mean that the action cannot be reviewed: in S. R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994) the Supreme Court held that a proclamation under Article 356 is open to judicial review. Remember the difference: the person is protected; the decision can be examined.
Dissolution and the Chief Minister
The Governor may dissolve the Vidhan Sabha under Article 174(2)(b). The Governor ordinarily does so on the advice of a Chief Minister who enjoys a majority. Where the Chief Minister's majority is doubtful, the safe method of settling the question is a test on the floor of the House, because the Council of Ministers is answerable to the Assembly under Article 164(2), not to the Governor's private opinion.
Worked example 1: advice or discretion?
Question: the Governor appoints a minister named by the Chief Minister. Is this an act of discretion? Working: Article 164(1) says the other ministers are appointed on the Chief Minister's advice. So the act is on advice. Answer: not discretion.
Worked example 2: the months of President's rule
Question: a proclamation is issued on 1 January and approved by Parliament in time. What is the earliest date by which a further approval is needed if each approval lasts six months from the start? Working: a proclamation lasts two months unless approved; once approved it continues for six months from the date of the proclamation. 1 January plus six months is 1 July. Answer: about 1 July.
Worked example 3: judging a statement
Statement: 'Because Article 361 protects the Governor, the Supreme Court cannot examine a proclamation under Article 356.' Working: the protection is for the person; the Bommai judgment allows review of the proclamation itself. The statement is false.
Advice is the rule (163(1)); discretion is the exception, and the Governor decides what is discretion (163(2)). Article 361 protects the person, not the decision (Bommai, 1994).
Key takeaways: treat advice as the default; identify the few discretionary acts; separate the Governor's immunity from the reviewability of decisions; and test any claim by asking whether it confuses the person with the act.
Check your understanding
-
1. Consider the statements. Statement 1: The Governor appoints ministers other than the Chief Minister on the Chief Minister's advice. Statement 2: The Governor's decision that a matter is one of discretion can be challenged in court merely because the court thinks it was not. Which is correct?
- Statement 1 only
- Statement 2 only
- Both statements
- Neither statement
Show answer
Answer: A. Statement 1 follows Article 164(1). Statement 2 is false: Article 163(2) makes the Governor's decision on that question final in the stated sense.
-
2. Assertion: The Supreme Court can examine a proclamation of President's rule in a state. Reason: Article 361 protects the Governor from answering to any court for official acts. Which is correct?
- Both the assertion and the reason are true, and the reason is the correct explanation
- The assertion is true but the reason is false
- Both the assertion and the reason are true, but the reason is not the correct explanation
- The assertion is false but the reason is true
Show answer
Answer: C. Both are true, but the reason does not explain the assertion: Bommai allowed review of the proclamation, while Article 361 only protects the person.
-
3. A Chief Minister's majority is doubtful. The method most consistent with Article 164(2) is:
- the Governor's private assessment of the members' loyalty
- an opinion of the Chief Secretary
- a decision of the Patna High Court
- a test of the majority on the floor of the Vidhan Sabha
Show answer
Answer: D. The Council is collectively responsible to the Assembly, so the Assembly is the place to test it.
-
4. A proclamation under Article 356 lapses in two months if it is not approved by:
- the Vidhan Sabha of the state
- both Houses of Parliament
- the Governor
- the Supreme Court
Show answer
Answer: B. Parliament must approve within two months.
-
5. Assertion: The Governor is not answerable to the Vidhan Sabha. Reason: The Council of Ministers, and not the Governor, is collectively responsible to the Assembly. Which is correct?
- Both the assertion and the reason are true, but the reason is not the correct explanation
- The assertion is true but the reason is false
- Both the assertion and the reason are true, and the reason is the correct explanation
- The assertion is false but the reason is true
Show answer
Answer: C. Under Article 164(2) collective responsibility to the Assembly rests on the Council, so the Governor is not answerable to it; the reason explains the assertion.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.