- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
The legislature at work: bills, money and powers of the Houses
Compare the powers of the Vidhan Sabha and the Vidhan Parishad on ordinary and money bills and recall the rules on sessions, quorum and presiding officers.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Because Bihar has two Houses, examiners love to ask which House can do what. The rule is simple: the Vidhan Sabha is stronger. This lesson turns that rule into precise facts, adds the procedure of a bill, and finishes with traps.
Journey of a bill
How an ordinary bill becomes law
- Introduction In either House
- Three readings Discussion and voting
- Other House Passes, amends or delays
- Governor Assent, return or reserve
- Law Published and in force
Ordinary bill versus money bill
| Point | Ordinary bill | Money bill |
|---|---|---|
| Where it starts | Either House | Only the Vidhan Sabha (Article 198) |
| Governor's recommendation | Not needed | Needed before introduction |
| Vidhan Parishad's power | May delay up to three months the first time; the Assembly may pass it again and override | May only make recommendations; must return it within 14 days |
| Who certifies it | - | The Speaker (Article 199) |
If the Council rejects or delays a bill the Assembly has passed, the Assembly may pass it a second time and send it again; if the Council still does not pass it, it is deemed passed after one month. The Assembly has the final say. A money bill, once the 14 days end, is deemed passed in the form the Assembly passed it.
Presiding officers, quorum and sessions
- The Speaker is elected by the members of the Vidhan Sabha from among themselves; the Chairman is elected by the members of the Vidhan Parishad.
- The Speaker resigns by writing to the Deputy Speaker; the Chairman writes to the Deputy Chairman.
- Quorum is one-tenth of the total members of the House or ten, whichever is greater (Article 189).
- The gap between two sessions cannot be more than six months (Article 174).
The Governor summons and prorogues the Houses and may dissolve the Assembly. The Council cannot be dissolved.
Other powers worth knowing
Besides making laws, the Vidhan Sabha controls the executive. Members ask questions, move motions and can pass a vote of no-confidence, which the Vidhan Parishad cannot do to the Council of Ministers. The annual budget, called the annual financial statement under Article 202, is laid before both Houses, but only the Vidhan Sabha votes on the demands for grants. Members enjoy privileges such as freedom of speech in the House (Article 194), so that they can speak without fear of a court case for what they say there. A member may be disqualified under Article 191, for example for holding an office of profit or for being of unsound mind or an undischarged insolvent.
Worked example 1: quorum of the Council
Question: the Vidhan Parishad has 75 members. What is its quorum? Working: one-tenth of 75 is 7.5; the other figure is 10; the greater is 10. Answer: 10 members.
Worked example 2: where can a bill start?
Question: a bill to impose a tax is moved first in the Vidhan Parishad. Is the procedure valid? Working: a tax bill is a money bill, which may be introduced only in the Vidhan Sabha. So the procedure is not valid.
Worked example 3: sessions
Question: the last sitting of the Assembly was on 5 January. By which date must it meet again? Working: the gap cannot exceed six months; 5 January plus six months is 5 July. Answer: by 5 July.
Money bill: only Assembly, Speaker certifies, Council 14 days, recommends only. Ordinary bill: either House, Council can delay, Assembly prevails. Quorum: one-tenth or ten. Gap between sessions: six months.
Key takeaways: an ordinary bill may start in either House but the Assembly has the last word; money bills are the Assembly's alone; the Council has 14 days; quorum is ten or one-tenth, whichever is greater.
Check your understanding
-
1. A money bill in Bihar can be introduced only in the:
- Vidhan Parishad
- Either House
- Vidhan Sabha
- Joint sitting
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 198 limits introduction to the Assembly.
-
2. How many days does the Vidhan Parishad have to return a money bill?
- 30
- 60
- 7
- 14
Show answer
Answer: D. The Council may only recommend changes, within 14 days.
-
3. The Speaker of the Bihar Vidhan Sabha is chosen by:
- the Governor
- the members of the Vidhan Sabha
- the Chief Minister
- the Chief Justice
Show answer
Answer: B. Members elect the Speaker from among themselves.
-
4. The quorum of the Vidhan Parishad of 75 members is:
- 8
- 25
- 10
- 38
Show answer
Answer: C. One-tenth is 7.5, which is less than 10, so ten is the quorum.
-
5. The maximum gap between two sessions of a state legislature is:
- six months
- three months
- one year
- two months
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 174 sets six months.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.