- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Biotechnology in farming, and the questions it raises
Explain how Bt crops kill insect pests, how RNA interference protects plants from nematodes, and what biopiracy and biosafety mean.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Farmers lose a large share of their crops to insects, worms and poor soil. Genetically modified (GM) crops are one answer. This lesson explains how two famous examples work, what other benefits GM crops can give, and the important questions about safety and fairness that come with them.
What GM crops can do
- Resist pests, so that less chemical pesticide is needed.
- Tolerate stresses such as cold, drought or salty soil.
- Reduce losses after harvest.
- Use minerals more efficiently, so that soil is not exhausted quickly.
- Carry extra nutrients; for example, Golden rice was made to contain beta-carotene, from which the body makes vitamin A.
Bt crops: a toxin that waits for the right gut
The soil bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt for short) makes proteins that kill certain insects. These are called Cry proteins, made by cry genes. In the bacterium the protein is in an inactive form, called a protoxin, so the bacterium is not harmed. When an insect larva eats it, the alkaline conditions in its gut turn the protoxin into the active toxin. The toxin attaches to the cells lining the insect's midgut and makes pores in them; the cells swell and burst, and the larva dies.
Scientists put the cry genes into crop plants. Bt cotton carries genes such as cryIAc and cryIIAb, whose proteins control cotton bollworms, while cryIAb protects corn against the corn borer. The plant itself now makes the toxin, so the insects that eat it die.
RNA interference against nematodes
A tiny worm, the nematode Meloidogyne incognita, attacks the roots of tobacco plants and lowers the yield. Scientists used RNA interference (RNAi) to protect the plant. Genes from the nematode were put into the plant (using the bacterium Agrobacterium as the vector) so that the plant made both the normal (sense) and the opposite (antisense) RNA. These two strands pair to form double-stranded RNA, which switches off a matching messenger RNA in the nematode. The nematode cannot make an essential protein and cannot survive in the transgenic plant.
Questions of fairness and safety
Biopiracy is the use of biological resources or traditional knowledge of a country or community by others without proper permission or fair payment. Many plant varieties, such as traditional varieties of rice, were developed over generations by farmers, so patents on them raise questions of fairness. Biosafety means checking that GM organisms are safe for people and the environment before they are released, and this testing is done before approval.
Worked example 1: following the Bt toxin
A bollworm eats a leaf of Bt cotton. Trace what happens. Step 1: the leaf contains Cry protein in its inactive protoxin form. Step 2: in the alkaline gut of the larva, the protoxin becomes active. Step 3: the active toxin binds to the midgut cells and makes pores. Step 4: the cells swell and burst. Step 5: the larva cannot feed and dies. The bacterium that originally made the protein is safe because in its own cell the protein stays inactive.
Worked example 2: why RNAi silences the pest
Why does making both sense and antisense RNA in the plant stop the nematode? Step 1: the two RNA strands are complementary, so they pair into double-stranded RNA. Step 2: when the nematode feeds, this double-stranded RNA matches one of its own messenger RNAs. Step 3: the matching messenger RNA is silenced, so the nematode cannot make the protein it needs. Step 4: the nematode dies, while the plant grows normally.
Bt toxin: inactive protoxin in the bacterium, activated in the alkaline gut of the insect, makes pores in midgut cells. RNAi: sense + antisense RNA form double-stranded RNA that silences the pest's matching mRNA.
Key takeaways
GM crops can resist pests, stresses and losses and can carry extra nutrients. Bt crops make an insect-killing protein that is activated only in the insect gut; RNAi protects tobacco from nematodes. Biopiracy and biosafety are the main fairness and safety issues.
Check your understanding
-
1. Bt cotton gets its pest resistance from genes of
- Escherichia coli
- Agrobacterium tumefaciens
- Saccharomyces cerevisiae
- Bacillus thuringiensis
Show answer
Answer: D. Bt stands for Bacillus thuringiensis, the soil bacterium whose cry genes make insect-killing Cry proteins.
-
2. Why does the Bt toxin not kill the bacterium that makes it?
- The bacterium has no gut cells for it to act on
- In the bacterium it is in an inactive protoxin form
- The bacterium makes an antidote that blocks the toxin
- The toxin is made only in winter when it is cold
Show answer
Answer: B. The protein is stored as an inactive protoxin and becomes active only in the alkaline gut of the insect.
-
3. In which part of the insect does the activated Bt toxin act?
- The wings and their muscles
- The eyes and the antennae
- The cells lining the midgut
- The outer skin or cuticle
Show answer
Answer: C. The active toxin binds to midgut epithelial cells and makes pores, so the cells swell and burst.
-
4. RNA interference was used to protect tobacco plants from
- the nematode Meloidogyne incognita
- cotton bollworms
- the corn borer
- bacterial wilt caused by E. coli
Show answer
Answer: A. Double-stranded RNA made by the transgenic tobacco silenced a gene of the root nematode Meloidogyne incognita.
-
5. Using a community's traditional knowledge of a plant without permission or fair payment is called
- biosafety
- bioprocess engineering
- biopiracy
- transformation
Show answer
Answer: C. Biopiracy is unauthorised, uncompensated use of biological resources or traditional knowledge.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.