- Advanced
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Membrane transport and osmosis in depth
Predict the direction of water and solute movement across a membrane, and tell passive transport from active transport in exam-style problems.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on the cell membrane rarely ask for definitions alone. They give a situation, such as a cell placed in a salt solution, and ask what happens. This lesson trains you to reason about direction of movement quickly and without confusion.
Passive versus active transport
In passive transport a substance moves down its concentration gradient, from higher to lower concentration, and the cell spends no ATP. Simple diffusion, facilitated diffusion and osmosis are passive. In active transport a substance is pushed against its gradient, from lower to higher concentration, and ATP is used. A protein carrier does the work.
| Type | Direction | Energy (ATP) | Needs protein? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Simple diffusion | High to low | No | No (small non-polar molecules such as oxygen) |
| Facilitated diffusion | High to low | No | Yes (channel or carrier) |
| Osmosis | Water: low solute to high solute side | No | Through the lipid layer or aquaporins |
| Active transport | Low to high | Yes | Yes (pump or carrier) |
Osmosis and tonicity
Osmosis is the movement of water across a selectively permeable membrane from a region of lower solute concentration to a region of higher solute concentration. Compare the solution outside the cell with the cell's own contents.
- Hypotonic outside solution (less solute than the cell): water enters, the cell swells. An animal cell may burst; a plant cell becomes turgid because the cell wall resists.
- Isotonic outside solution (same solute level): no net movement of water.
- Hypertonic outside solution (more solute than the cell): water leaves, the cell shrinks. In a plant cell the membrane pulls away from the wall, called plasmolysis.
Water always follows the solute: it moves toward the side with MORE dissolved solute. Hypotonic outside = swell; hypertonic outside = shrink.
Worked example 1
A red blood cell is placed in a solution that has a higher solute concentration than its cytoplasm. Step 1: compare outside with inside. The outside has more solute, so it is hypertonic. Step 2: water moves toward more solute, that is, out of the cell. Step 3: the cell shrinks and looks crenated. No ATP is used because osmosis is passive.
Worked example 2
A root hair cell takes up mineral ions from soil water even though the ions are already more concentrated inside the cell. Step 1: movement is from low to high concentration, so it is against the gradient. Step 2: this cannot be diffusion. Step 3: it is active transport, needing carrier proteins and ATP. If the root is deprived of oxygen, respiration falls, ATP falls, and ion uptake falls.
Key takeaways
- Passive means down the gradient, no ATP; active means against the gradient, with ATP.
- Judge tonicity by comparing the outside solution with the cell.
- Plant cells become turgid in hypotonic solutions and plasmolyse in hypertonic ones.
- Uptake of a substance that is already more concentrated inside points to active transport.
Check your understanding
-
1. A plant cell in a hypertonic solution shows its membrane pulling away from the wall. This is called
- Plasmolysis
- Turgor
- Lysis
- Endocytosis
Show answer
Answer: A. Water leaves the vacuole and cytoplasm by osmosis, so the protoplast shrinks from the wall.
-
2. Which of these needs ATP?
- Osmosis
- The sodium-potassium pump
- Facilitated diffusion
- Diffusion of oxygen
Show answer
Answer: B. The sodium-potassium pump moves ions against their gradients using ATP; the other three are passive.
-
3. An animal cell is placed in pure water. What is most likely?
- It shrinks
- It stays the same
- It swells and may burst
- It divides
Show answer
Answer: C. Pure water is hypotonic to the cell; water enters and, with no wall to resist, the cell may burst.
-
4. Which transport shows saturation, where adding more substance stops raising the rate once all carriers are busy?
- Simple diffusion
- Osmosis through the lipid layer
- Diffusion of oxygen
- Carrier-mediated transport
Show answer
Answer: D. Carrier proteins are limited in number, so the rate levels off when all are in use.
-
5. Facilitated diffusion
- Moves substances down their gradient through channel or carrier proteins without ATP
- Uses ATP to move substances against their gradient
- Moves only water through the lipid layer
- Needs no protein at all
Show answer
Answer: A. Facilitated diffusion is passive (high to low, no ATP) but needs a channel or carrier protein.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.