• Foundation
  • About 12 min
  • 5 practice questions

Circulation in other animals: open and closed systems

Compare open and closed circulation, and the hearts of fish, amphibians, reptiles, birds and mammals, with simple reasoning about why they differ.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Humans are not the only animals with a circulatory system. A simple sponge has none, an insect has a different kind, and a fish has a simpler heart than ours. Comparing them shows how the system became more efficient as animals became larger and more active.

Open and closed systems

In an open circulatory system the heart pumps blood into spaces around the organs, and the blood bathes the tissues directly before returning to the heart. Insects, most molluscs and other arthropods have this system. In insects the blood does not carry oxygen; air reaches the cells through a network of small air tubes. In a closed circulatory system the blood stays inside vessels. This is found in the earthworm and in all vertebrates. Closed systems can push blood faster and to where it is needed.

Hearts of vertebrates

Vertebrate hearts
Animal groupHeart chambersCirculationBlood mixing
Fishes2 (one atrium, one ventricle)Single: heart, gills, body, heartNone; the heart pumps oxygen-poor blood
Amphibians3 (two atria, one ventricle)Double, incompleteSome mixing in the ventricle
Most reptiles3 (partly divided ventricle)Double, incompleteLimited mixing
Crocodiles4Double, completeNone
Birds and mammals4Double, completeNone

In single circulation blood passes through the heart once in a complete circuit. In double circulation it passes through twice: once on its way to the lungs and once on its way to the body. Birds and mammals are warm-blooded, with high energy needs; complete separation of oxygen-rich and oxygen-poor blood gives their tissues blood with the most oxygen possible.

Worked example 1: times through the heart

Question: How many times does blood pass through the heart in one complete circuit in a fish and in a human? Working: In a fish, blood goes from the heart to the gills, then to the body and back, so it passes once. In a human, blood goes from the heart to the lungs and back, then to the body and back, so it passes twice.

Worked example 2: why an insect has no need for oxygen carriers

Question: Why can an insect do without red blood cells? Working: An insect's body is supplied with air through tubes (tracheae) that open to the outside and branch to every part. Oxygen reaches the cells directly through these tubes, so the blood is not needed to carry it.

Worked example 3: compare

Question: Give two reasons why a frog's heart is less efficient than a bird's. Working: First, the frog heart has three chambers with a single ventricle, so oxygenated and deoxygenated blood mix. Second, because of the mixing the blood going to the body has less oxygen than in a bird, which has a four-chambered heart with complete separation. A frog also takes in oxygen through the skin, which partly makes up for this.

Fish 2 chambers, single circulation. Amphibians 3. Birds and mammals 4, complete double circulation. Insects: open system.

Key takeaways

  • Open system: blood bathes the organs (insects, most molluscs). Closed: blood stays in vessels (earthworm, vertebrates).
  • Chambers: fishes 2, amphibians and most reptiles 3, crocodiles, birds and mammals 4.
  • Fish have single circulation; the rest have double.
  • Complete separation of blood suits warm-blooded, active animals.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which animal has a closed circulatory system?

    1. Cockroach
    2. Earthworm
    3. Grasshopper
    4. Housefly
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The earthworm's blood stays in vessels. The insects listed have open systems.

  2. 2. How many chambers does a frog's heart have?

    1. Two
    2. Three
    3. Four
    4. One
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A frog heart has two atria and one ventricle.

  3. 3. In which animals is blood pumped by the heart only once in a full circuit?

    1. Fishes
    2. Birds
    3. Mammals
    4. Crocodiles
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Fish have single circulation: heart, gills, body, heart.

  4. 4. Why is complete separation of oxygen-rich and oxygen-poor blood useful to birds and mammals?

    1. It reduces the heartbeat rate
    2. It prevents the blood clotting
    3. It saves water in the body
    4. It keeps oxygen-rich blood pure
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Separation keeps oxygen-rich blood from mixing with oxygen-poor blood, supporting the high energy needs of warm-blooded animals.

  5. 5. In insects, oxygen reaches the tissues mainly through:

    1. Haemoglobin in blood
    2. Tracheae
    3. Gills
    4. Red blood cells
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Insects have a network of air tubes called tracheae.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery