- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Energy flow, the 10 per cent law and productivity
Calculate energy at any trophic level, separate gross and net productivity, and judge how fast detritus decomposes.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Advanced ecology questions rarely ask you to define a food chain. They give you a few numbers about energy and expect you to move up or down the trophic levels in seconds, or they test whether you can tell a rate from an amount. This lesson builds the arithmetic and the vocabulary together, so that every later lesson in this course can rest on it.
Trophic levels and one-way energy flow
Producers (green plants, phytoplankton) form the first trophic level, T1. Herbivores are primary consumers (T2), animals that eat herbivores are secondary consumers (T3), and so on. Energy enters as sunlight, is fixed by photosynthesis and then passes up the chain. At every transfer most of it is lost as heat through respiration, and none of it comes back to the producers. That is why ecologists say energy flows in one direction, while nutrients cycle. Decomposers return nutrients to the soil, not energy to the plants.
Lindeman's 10 per cent law summarises the loss: on average only about 10 per cent of the energy at one trophic level is available to the next. Ninety per cent is used or lost on the way. The law is an average, not an exact constant, so a question may state a different efficiency for one step; always use the figure the question gives.
Productivity: a rate, not an amount
Primary productivity is the rate at which producers make organic matter, measured as mass or energy per unit area per unit time (for example kJ per square metre per year). Gross primary productivity (GPP) is the total rate of photosynthesis. Plants use part of it in their own respiration (R). What remains is net primary productivity: NPP = GPP − R. Only NPP is available to herbivores and decomposers. Secondary productivity is the rate at which consumers form new organic matter.
Do not confuse productivity with standing crop, which is the mass of living material present per unit area at a given moment. Standing crop is a stock; productivity is a flow. A meadow cut every month can have a small standing crop but high productivity.
Decomposition in five steps
Dead plant and animal matter (detritus) is broken down by detritivores and microbes in steps: fragmentation (earthworms break it into small pieces), leaching (soluble nutrients seep into the soil), catabolism (bacterial and fungal enzymes break it into simpler inorganic substances), humification (a dark, slow-to-decay layer called humus forms) and mineralisation (humus is slowly broken down, releasing inorganic nutrients). Decomposition is fast when the detritus is rich in nitrogen and water-soluble sugars and the soil is warm, moist and aerated. It is slow when the detritus is rich in lignin and chitin, and in cold or waterlogged (oxygen-poor) soil.
Worked example 1: moving up four levels
Producers in a pond fix 20,000 kJ. Using the 10 per cent law, how much energy reaches the tertiary consumers? T1 = 20,000 kJ, T2 = 2,000 kJ, T3 = 200 kJ, T4 = 20 kJ. The shortcut: every step divides by 10, and tertiary consumers are three steps above producers, so divide by 10^3. Reverse question: to give 5 kJ to tertiary consumers, producers must fix 5 × 10^3 = 5,000 kJ.
Worked example 2: GPP, NPP and transfer efficiency
A grassland has GPP = 2,400 kJ per square metre per year and plant respiration of 600 kJ. NPP = 2,400 − 600 = 1,800 kJ. If herbivore production is 180 kJ, the transfer efficiency from producers (net) to herbivores is 180 ÷ 1,800 × 100 = 10 per cent. As a fraction of GPP it is only 180 ÷ 2,400 = 7.5 per cent. Read carefully which base the question uses; examiners often place both answers among the options.
Worked example 3: unequal efficiencies
Producers fix 50,000 kJ. Efficiency is 10 per cent from T1 to T2 but 20 per cent from T2 to T3. T2 = 5,000 kJ and T3 = 20 per cent of 5,000 = 1,000 kJ. Apply each efficiency to the level just below it, one step at a time.
Energy at level n = energy at producers × (efficiency)^(n − 1). NPP = GPP − R. Productivity is a rate; standing crop is an amount at one moment.
Key takeaways
Energy flows one way and shrinks by about nine-tenths at each step, so count steps and divide by powers of 10. Herbivores live on NPP, not GPP. Lignin, chitin, cold and waterlogging slow decomposition; nitrogen, sugars, warmth, moisture and air speed it up.
Check your understanding
-
1. Producers in an ecosystem fix 50,000 J. Using the 10 per cent law, how much energy is available to secondary consumers?
- 5,000 J
- 500 J
- 50 J
- 5 J
Show answer
Answer: B. Secondary consumers are T3, two steps above producers: 50,000 ÷ 10 ÷ 10 = 500 J. 5,000 J is the herbivore level.
-
2. A forest has GPP of 1,500 kJ per square metre per year and plant respiration of 400 kJ. What is its NPP?
- 1,900 kJ per square metre per year
- 400 kJ per square metre per year
- 375 kJ per square metre per year
- 1,100 kJ per square metre per year
Show answer
Answer: D. NPP = GPP − R = 1,500 − 400 = 1,100. Adding instead of subtracting gives the trap answer 1,900.
-
3. Which statement about energy in an ecosystem is correct?
- Energy flows in one direction, while nutrients are recycled
- Decomposers recycle energy back to the producers
- Higher trophic levels hold more energy than lower ones
- The 10 per cent law means 10 per cent of energy is lost at each step
Show answer
Answer: A. Energy is lost as heat at each transfer and never returns to producers; decomposers recycle nutrients only. About 90 per cent, not 10 per cent, is lost at each step.
-
4. A tertiary consumer population needs 30 kJ. Under the 10 per cent law, what is the minimum energy producers must fix?
- 3,000 kJ
- 3,00,000 kJ
- 30,000 kJ
- 9,000 kJ
Show answer
Answer: C. Tertiary consumers are T4, three steps above producers: 30 × 10^3 = 30,000 kJ.
-
5. Which detritus will decompose most slowly?
- Leaf litter rich in nitrogen and water-soluble sugars
- Soft herbaceous litter in warm, moist, well-aerated soil
- Animal dung in warm and humid conditions
- Woody litter rich in lignin lying in cold, waterlogged soil
Show answer
Answer: D. Lignin resists breakdown, and cold, oxygen-poor (waterlogged) soil slows microbial activity. The other three combine easily decomposed material with favourable conditions.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.