- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Energy budgets and protein quality
Solve multi-step energy problems, plan the grams of each nutrient for a target diet, and explain essential amino acids and complementary proteins.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Advanced nutrition questions rarely ask for a single energy value. They give a total and ask for a missing nutrient, give percentages and ask for grams, or compare two foods. They also test whether you understand why some proteins are 'better' than others. This lesson brings both together, assuming you already know the energy values of 4, 4 and 9 kcal per gram for carbohydrate, protein and fat.
Three equations that cover most problems
- Energy from a nutrient = grams × energy value (4 for carbohydrate and protein, 9 for fat).
- Grams of a nutrient = energy from it ÷ energy value.
- Share of energy = energy from that nutrient ÷ total energy × 100.
Two shortcuts save time. First, to swap fat for carbohydrate at equal energy, multiply by 9/4 = 2.25 (or divide, the other way). Second, replacing x grams of carbohydrate or protein with x grams of fat raises the energy by 5x kcal, because each gram changes from 4 to 9. If you need joules, 1 kcal is about 4.2 kJ, so fat gives about 37 kJ per gram and carbohydrate about 17 kJ.
Worked example 1: the missing nutrient
A 100 g food gives 400 kcal and contains 10 g protein and 20 g fat; the rest of the energy is from carbohydrate. Find the carbohydrate. Protein: 10 × 4 = 40 kcal. Fat: 20 × 9 = 180 kcal. Energy left = 400 − 40 − 180 = 180 kcal. Carbohydrate = 180 ÷ 4 = 45 g. Check: 45 + 10 + 20 = 75 g of energy nutrients, leaving 25 g for water, fibre and minerals, which is reasonable.
Worked example 2: from percentages to grams
A diet of 2400 kcal should take 55% of its energy from carbohydrate, 15% from protein and 30% from fat. Find the grams of each. Carbohydrate energy = 0.55 × 2400 = 1320 kcal, so 1320 ÷ 4 = 330 g. Protein energy = 0.15 × 2400 = 360 kcal, so 360 ÷ 4 = 90 g. Fat energy = 0.30 × 2400 = 720 kcal, so 720 ÷ 9 = 80 g. Check: 1320 + 360 + 720 = 2400. The typical wrong option divides fat energy by 4 and gets 180 g.
Protein quality and essential amino acids
Proteins are chains of amino acids. The body can make some amino acids from others, but the essential amino acids cannot be made in sufficient amounts and must come from food. A protein's quality depends on whether it supplies all of them in useful proportions. Animal proteins such as milk and egg usually do. Plant proteins are often short of one: cereals are relatively low in lysine, and pulses are relatively low in the sulphur-containing amino acid methionine.
This is the science behind traditional pairings such as rice with dal or roti with chana. The cereal supplies the methionine the pulse lacks, and the pulse supplies the lysine the cereal lacks, so the mixture has better quality than either alone. This is called protein complementation. Combining two cereals, or two pulses, does not fix the shortfall because both members lack the same amino acid. In the same way, the body needs two essential fatty acids, linoleic acid and alpha-linolenic acid, from food because it cannot make them.
Grams = energy ÷ (4 or 9). Fat for carbohydrate at equal energy: × 2.25. Cereal + pulse = complete protein: cereals lack lysine, pulses lack methionine.
Key takeaways
- Write the three equations once and use them in every energy problem.
- Subtract known energies first when a nutrient is missing; divide by the right factor last.
- Essential amino acids and essential fatty acids must come from the diet.
- Complementation works only when the two foods lack different amino acids.
The next lesson goes inside the cell to see what vitamins actually do, which is where many advanced statement questions come from.
Check your understanding
-
1. A 100 g food gives 350 kcal and contains 8 g protein and 10 g fat; the rest of the energy is from carbohydrate. How much carbohydrate does it contain?
- 62 g
- 48 g
- 65 g
- 57 g
Show answer
Answer: D. Protein 8 × 4 = 32 kcal; fat 10 × 9 = 90 kcal. Remaining 350 − 32 − 90 = 228 kcal. Carbohydrate = 228 ÷ 4 = 57 g.
-
2. A diet of 1800 kcal should take 25% of its energy from fat. How many grams of fat is that?
- 50 g
- 112.5 g
- 75 g
- 45 g
Show answer
Answer: A. Fat energy = 0.25 × 1800 = 450 kcal. Grams = 450 ÷ 9 = 50 g. 112.5 g would wrongly divide by 4.
-
3. Why does eating rice with dal give better protein quality than either alone?
- Dal supplies vitamin C that is missing from rice
- The cereal is relatively low in lysine and the pulse relatively low in methionine, so each makes up the other's shortfall
- Rice supplies every essential amino acid and dal only adds fat
- Combining them raises the energy value of protein to 9 kcal per gram
Show answer
Answer: B. Protein complementation: cereals are short of lysine, pulses of methionine. Together they supply both essential amino acids in better proportion.
-
4. What makes an amino acid 'essential'?
- It is needed only during childhood
- It is found only in animal proteins
- The body cannot make it in sufficient amounts, so it must come from food
- It always contains sulphur
Show answer
Answer: C. Essential means it must be supplied by the diet. Many essential amino acids are found in plant foods, and only some contain sulphur.
-
5. In a recipe, 12 g of carbohydrate is replaced by 12 g of fat. How does the energy change?
- It rises by 48 kcal
- It rises by 108 kcal
- It falls by 60 kcal
- It rises by 60 kcal
Show answer
Answer: D. Each gram changes from 4 to 9 kcal, a rise of 5 kcal. 12 × 5 = 60 kcal more. Directly: 12 × 9 − 12 × 4 = 108 − 48 = 60.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.