- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Writing about the story: long answers, a diary entry and a discussion
Plan and write a 100-120 word answer on the story's message, write a diary entry in a character's voice, and argue a point in a discussion on pampering children and pets.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Plan a long answer with a clear point, evidence and a message.
- Write a diary entry in the voice of a character.
- Speak or write for and against a question raised by the story.
Questions on a supplementary reader often ask for a longer answer about a character's choice, the story's message or what you would have done. The method is the same each time: point, evidence, explanation, message. The model answers below are original.
Planning a long answer
PEEM: a plan for a 100-120 word answer
- Point Answer the question directly in one sentence.
- Evidence Give two events or details from the story in your own words.
- Explanation Say why those details prove your point.
- Message End with the value or lesson the story teaches.
Worked example 1: a long answer
Question: What would you have done in the narrator's place? Model answer (about 110 words): In Mr Herriot's place I would also have taken Tricki away, because his life was in danger. The dog was too fat to walk properly, had stopped eating and was vomiting, and his owner had already failed to follow a strict diet at home. Like Herriot, I would have chosen fasting, plain food and exercise rather than medicine, since the cause was overeating. However, I might have explained the cure honestly to Mrs Pumphrey at the end, gently, so that she would not repeat her mistake. The story teaches that real care needs both kindness and firmness.
Why it works: the first sentence answers the question; two pieces of evidence follow; the writer adds a reasoned difference of opinion; the last line states the message.
Diary entry: format
- Place and date at the top left, then the time if useful (for example, 9:30 p.m.).
- 'Dear Diary' is optional; write in the first person and mainly in the past tense for events.
- Express feelings and thoughts, not just events. Keep it about 100-120 words.
- Sign off with the writer's name.
Worked example 2: a diary entry as Mrs Pumphrey
(An original model, written in the character's voice.) Thursday, 9 p.m. Dear Diary, The house is so quiet without Tricki. Mr Herriot took him away this morning wrapped in a blanket, and I could not stop crying. His little beds and coats lie unused, and I keep listening for his bark. I rang the surgery five times today; the vet says he is out of danger and convalescing. Convalescing! I must send fresh eggs tomorrow, and perhaps some good wine to strengthen his blood. Perhaps I was too soft with him. I promise myself I will be firmer when he comes home. Good night. - Mrs Pumphrey
Notice the character's voice: worry, love and a hint of the comic misunderstanding (the wine), plus a moment of self-reflection that fits her character.
Discussion: pampering children and pets
Is pampering harmful?
-
For: it can harm
- Unlimited sweets damage health
- Children may not learn self-control
- Pets lose natural activity
- Love without limits can become neglect of real needs
-
Against: it is not always harmful
- Affection builds security and confidence
- Small treats on special days are harmless
- Every family's limits differ
- The fault lies in excess, not in love
In a discussion, take a clear stand, give two reasons with examples, respond politely to the other side ("I understand that... but...") and close with a summary. For a debate, greet the chair and audience, state the motion and your side, and keep to the time limit.
Feelings for a diary, reasons for a debate, evidence for a long answer: match the content to the task.
Key takeaways: plan long answers with point, evidence, explanation and message; write diary entries in the first person with feelings; in discussion, balance your view and answer the other side politely.
Check your understanding
-
1. In the PEEM plan, what should the last sentence of a long answer usually give?
- The author's date of birth
- The message or lesson of the story
- A new event not in the story
- A list of difficult words
Show answer
Answer: B. PEEM ends with the Message: the value the story teaches, which rounds off the answer.
-
2. Which of these is most important in a diary entry?
- A formal subject line
- The receiver's address
- The writer's feelings and thoughts in the first person
- A headline in capital letters
Show answer
Answer: C. A diary is personal writing: first person, feelings and reflections. Subject lines and addresses belong to letters; headlines to reports.
-
3. A student writes: 'Mrs Pumphrey was foolish.' What would make this a stronger answer?
- Adding evidence, such as her giving Tricki cream cakes despite the vet's warning
- Writing the sentence in capital letters
- Repeating the sentence twice
- Adding the names of other books by the author
Show answer
Answer: A. A quality needs evidence. Mentioning that she ignored the vet's advice and kept feeding sweets proves the point.
-
4. Which sentence is a polite way to respond to an opponent in a discussion?
- You are completely wrong and silly.
- Nobody agrees with you.
- Let me finish; you don't know anything.
- I understand your point, but excess, not love, causes harm.
Show answer
Answer: D. Acknowledging the other view and then giving your reason is the polite, effective way to respond.
-
5. Which detail best fits a diary entry written by the vet after Tricki returned home?
- Dear Sir, I am writing to complain...
- I almost laughed when she called it a triumph of surgery, but I kept a straight face.
- NOTICE: All dogs must be vaccinated.
- Breaking news: dog cured in record time.
Show answer
Answer: B. It is personal, in the first person and shows the vet's feelings and humour. The others are a letter, a notice and a news headline.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.