- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Hari Singh and Anil: character, change and the power of trust
Write character sketches of the thief and Anil with evidence, trace how the thief's view of education changes, and explain the themes of trust, education and redemption.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe Hari Singh and Anil with qualities and evidence.
- Trace how the thief's attitude to education changes during the story.
- Explain why Anil does not hand the thief to the police.
- Discuss the story's themes and its quiet, ironic narration.
The story has only two characters who matter, and they are opposites: a clever, suspicious boy who trusts nobody and a careless, generous man who trusts everyone. The meeting of these two is the heart of the story.
The two main characters
Thief and employer
-
Hari Singh (the thief)
- Clever and observant: studies people's faces
- Uses flattery and an appealing smile
- Lies easily: false name, claims he can cook
- Lonely: believes friends are trouble
- Has a conscience that wakes up
- Changes for the better
-
Anil (the writer)
- Kind and easy-going
- Trusting: gives the boy a key
- Careless with money
- Generous: teaches him to cook and write
- Forgiving: says nothing about the theft
- Wise: changes the boy through trust
How the thief's view of education changes
| Stage | What he thinks | What it shows |
|---|---|---|
| At first | Writing like an educated man will open the way to great achievements (he is thinking of bigger thefts and cons). | Education is a tool for a cleverer kind of crime. |
| In the rain at night | Sentences could bring more than a few hundred rupees; stealing is easy and so is being caught; becoming a clever, respected man is different. | Education now means respect and a new life. |
| At the end | He smiles at Anil without effort when Anil says they will start writing sentences. | His smile is now genuine: he has chosen the honest path. |
Why does Anil not call the police?
Anil sees the damp note and understands everything, but he also sees that the boy chose to return the money. Calling the police would punish a boy who has already corrected himself; forgiveness gives him a reason to stay honest. Anil's response is to pay him regularly from now on and start the writing lessons. Most employers would have reported the theft or at least dismissed the boy. Anil is different because he values people over money, and perhaps because, as a struggling writer whose own income comes and goes, he understands hardship.
Themes
- Trust can reform a person. Anil's open trust makes stealing from him hard and makes returning the money possible.
- Education as freedom. The boy sees that reading and writing can make him respected in a way crime never will.
- Conscience and redemption. The hesitation at the train is his conscience at work, even before he understands it.
- Silent forgiveness. Anil corrects the boy without a single word of blame.
The writer's craft
Bond uses first-person narration so that we see the thief's reasoning, which is often comic and ironic: he says robbing a careless man is no fun because the man may not even notice. The weather mirrors his mood: moonlight during the theft, then cold, drizzle and heavy rain as his confidence washes away. The ending is understated: Anil's knowledge is shown through a wet note, not stated in words, and the boy's natural smile tells us he has changed.
Worked example 1: a character question
Question: How does Anil's response differ from what a typical employer would do? Working: think of what most employers would do (report, dismiss, distrust) and what Anil does (key, lessons, forgiveness, wages). Model answer: Most employers would have called the police or thrown the boy out. Anil trusted him with a key, taught him to cook and write, ignored small cheating on the shopping and, even after the theft, forgave him silently and began paying him. He believed in reforming the boy rather than punishing him.
Worked example 2: reading the narrator's thoughts
Question: What does the thief predict about the faces of people who are robbed? Working: list his observations: the greedy man shows fear, the rich man anger, the poor man acceptance; Anil, he thinks, would show only a little sadness, for the lost trust rather than the money. Answer: he expects Anil to be sad not about the money but about being betrayed, which shows he already understands Anil's goodness.
Anil's trust is the real teacher in this story: it teaches honesty without a word.
Key takeaways: the thief is clever, lonely and capable of change; Anil is trusting, generous and wise. The themes are trust, education, conscience and forgiveness, told with irony and an understated ending.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which quality of Anil is shown when he gives the boy a key to the room?
- Suspicion
- Greed
- Trust
- Anger
Show answer
Answer: C. Giving a key lets the boy come and go freely. The boy himself says Anil was the most trusting person he had ever met.
-
2. At the beginning, why does the thief want to learn to write?
- He thinks it will help him achieve much more, as an 'educated' crook.
- He wants to become a writer like Anil.
- He needs it to buy a train ticket.
- He wants to write a letter to his family.
Show answer
Answer: A. Early on he only sees education as a way to be cleverer and achieve more; later he sees it as the path to being a respected man.
-
3. What does the boy think Anil's face would show when he found the money gone?
- Fear
- Anger
- Acceptance
- A touch of sadness at lost trust
Show answer
Answer: D. He says the greedy show fear, the rich anger and the poor acceptance, but Anil would show only sadness, for the loss of trust rather than money.
-
4. Why is the ending of the story called 'understated'?
- Anil shouts at the boy loudly.
- Anil's knowledge is shown through a wet note and silence, not through words.
- The story ends with the boy in jail.
- The writer explains the moral in a long paragraph.
Show answer
Answer: B. Bond lets details speak: the damp note shows Anil knows, and his silence shows forgiveness. Nothing is said aloud.
-
5. How does the weather reflect the boy's feelings after the theft?
- Bright sunshine shows his joy.
- A calm night shows his peace.
- Cold rain matches his discomfort and growing doubt.
- Strong heat shows his anger.
Show answer
Answer: C. Drizzle turns into heavy rain while he sits alone with nowhere to go; the discomfort mirrors his unease and leads to reflection.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.