- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
The Black Aeroplane: risk, mystery and comparing the two stories
Retell Frederick Forsyth's story of a pilot lost in a storm, explain the risk he took and the mystery of the black aeroplane, compare it with His First Flight, and practise on an original passage.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Retell the pilot's story in order.
- Explain the risk he took and why.
- Discuss possible explanations of the mysterious aeroplane.
- Compare the two flying stories.
- Answer questions on an unseen passage.
The second story, The Black Aeroplane by the British novelist Frederick Forsyth, is told in the first person by a pilot. Note that the book's contents page calls it Black Aeroplane, while the heading inside the chapter reads The Black Aeroplane. It is a short mystery with an unanswered question at the end.
What happens (in short)
On a clear moonlit night the narrator flies his old Dakota from France towards England, dreaming of breakfast and his family. Paris Control tells him to turn west, and he switches to his second and last fuel tank. Soon he sees huge storm clouds ahead. He cannot fly over them and has too little fuel to go around. He should go back to Paris, but he decides to risk it. Inside the storm everything turns black, the plane is tossed about, and his compass, instruments and radio all stop working. Then a black aeroplane without lights appears beside him; its pilot waves and signals him to follow. With fuel nearly gone, they descend, and the narrator sees a runway. He lands safely, but the other plane has vanished. A woman in the control centre laughs: no other plane was flying that night; his was the only one on the radar.
The pilot's night
- Calm flight Clear sky, moon and stars; he dreams of breakfast.
- The storm Black clouds like mountains block his way.
- The risk He flies straight in instead of returning to Paris.
- Lost Compass, instruments and radio all dead.
- The guide A black plane without lights signals him to follow.
- Safe landing A runway appears; the guide is gone.
- Mystery Radar showed no other plane that night.
The risk and the narrator
The risk was flying into a storm in an old plane with limited fuel instead of turning back. He took it because he wanted to get home: to his family, his holiday and a big English breakfast. This shows him as a skilled but impulsive man who let personal desire outweigh caution. Later he follows the stranger like an obedient child, showing his relief and helplessness, and after landing he is not sorry to leave the old Dakota, which had nearly cost him his life.
Who was the pilot of the black aeroplane?
The story deliberately does not answer. Readers suggest several possibilities: a ghost or guardian spirit; the narrator's own instinct and presence of mind, imagined as a guide under stress; or divine help. Whatever you choose, support it with evidence: the plane had no lights, it appeared and disappeared suddenly, and the radar showed nothing. An open ending invites the reader to think.
Comparing the two stories
Two stories about flying
-
His First Flight
- Third-person narration
- A young bird afraid to try
- Fear comes before the risk
- Help: the mother's trick and hunger
- Ends in joyful success
-
The Black Aeroplane
- First-person narration
- An experienced pilot takes a risk
- Fear comes after the risk
- Help: a mysterious guide
- Ends in safety and an unsolved mystery
Common ideas: both show fear and how it is overcome, both show help arriving at the crucial moment, and both end in a safe landing. One teaches that we must take the plunge to learn; the other warns that rash risks can be costly and that we sometimes owe our safety to forces we do not understand.
Practice passage (written for this lesson)
The Torch on the Ridge. Tenzin was the last trekker coming down the pass when the fog rolled in. Within minutes he could not see his own boots. The path had sharp drops on one side, and he knew that one wrong step could be his last. He stood still, heart pounding, and called out, but only the wind answered. Then, below and a little to the left, a small yellow light blinked three times. He moved towards it slowly, testing each step, and every time he stopped, the light blinked again. An hour later he reached the guesthouse. The owner said nobody had gone out with a torch that evening. Tenzin never found out who had held the light, but he never again started down a pass late in the afternoon. (A made-up story.)
Worked example: questions on the passage
- Why did Tenzin stand still? Working: he could not see and the path had steep drops. Answer: moving blindly could have made him fall, so stopping was the safe choice.
- What lesson did he learn? Working: the last sentence shows a change in behaviour. Answer: not to start a descent late in the day, when fog and darkness can trap trekkers.
- How is the passage like The Black Aeroplane? Answer: a traveller lost in poor visibility is guided to safety by an unexplained light, and no one can say who helped.
An open ending is not a missing ending: give your own explanation and support it with details from the text.
Key takeaways: the narrator risks flying into a storm out of eagerness to reach home, loses all instruments, and is guided by a mysterious black aeroplane that radar never saw. The two stories share fear, help at the crucial moment and safe landings, but differ in narrator, character and ending.
Check your understanding
-
1. What risk did the narrator take?
- Flying into the storm instead of going back to Paris
- Flying without a licence
- Landing on an unknown runway
- Switching off his radio
Show answer
Answer: A. He knew he ought to return to Paris but wanted to get home for breakfast, so he flew straight into the storm clouds.
-
2. Why could he not avoid the storm by flying around it?
- Paris Control forbade it.
- Another plane was in the way.
- He did not have enough fuel.
- His map was lost.
Show answer
Answer: C. He could not fly over the clouds and did not have enough fuel to go around them to the north or south.
-
3. Why did the woman in the control centre look at him strangely?
- He was very late.
- He had landed at the wrong airport.
- His uniform was dirty.
- He asked about another plane, but no other plane was flying and only his was on radar.
Show answer
Answer: D. His question seemed strange because, according to her radar, no other aircraft was in the sky that night.
-
4. Which is a difference between the two stories?
- One has a happy ending and the other ends in death.
- His First Flight is told in the third person; The Black Aeroplane in the first person.
- Both are told by a bird.
- Only one story involves fear.
Show answer
Answer: B. The seagull's story is narrated from outside (he, his), while the pilot tells his own story (I, my). Both end safely and both involve fear.
-
5. In the practice passage, what did Tenzin do whenever he stopped?
- He shouted for help again.
- He saw the light blink again.
- He sat down to rest for an hour.
- He turned back up the pass.
Show answer
Answer: B. The passage says that every time he stopped, the light blinked again, guiding him on.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.