• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Curiosity, failure and the will to win: what makes a scientist

Explain the lesson Ebright learned from losing a science fair, describe his experiments in order, and identify the qualities the writer says make a scientist.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain what Ebright learned from failure.
  • Describe his main projects and what each showed.
  • Name and explain the three ingredients of a scientist.
  • Write a character sketch of Ebright with evidence.

The writer ends with a recipe: a first-rate mind, curiosity and the will to win for good reasons. This lesson tests that recipe against the events of Ebright's life.

The lesson of the lost science fair

In seventh grade, Ebright entered a county science fair with slides of frog tissue under a microscope, and won nothing. He saw that the winners had done real experiments, while he had only made a neat display. The lesson: science is asking a question and testing it, not just showing things. Instead of giving up, he asked Dr Urquhart to suggest experiments, which kept him busy through high school.

His experiments and projects

Each project grew from the previous one.
StageQuestion or projectResult
Eighth gradeIs a viral disease that kills monarch caterpillars carried by a beetle?No clear result, but he showed his experiment and won.
Ninth gradeDo viceroys copy monarchs because birds avoid monarchs?A starling ate monarchs it was given; the project won first in zoology and third overall in the county.
High school, second year onwardsWhat are the small gold spots (twelve of them) on the monarch pupa for?With a fellow student, he built a device showing the spots make a hormone needed for full development.
Senior yearDo wing cells need the gold-spot hormone?Wing cells grown in a culture became normal scales only when fed the hormone; first in zoology at the international fair.
HarvardWhat is the hormone's chemical structure?He identified it with laboratory instruments; X-ray photos later gave him his theory of how cells read DNA.

The ingredients of a scientist

The making of a scientist (the writer's recipe)

  • A first-rate mind
    • top grades, straight-A student
    • graduated second in a class of 1,510 at Harvard
  • Curiosity
    • questioned what the gold spots were for
    • never lost interest after reading the monarch book
  • The will to win for good reasons
    • competitive, but to do his best work, not just for prizes
    • extra hours of debate research besides science
Supporting details are from the chapter, in my own words.

Other qualities shown: perseverance (raising thousands of monarchs), learning from failure (the science fair), openness to guidance (Dr Urquhart, Mr Weiherer) and wide interests (debating, public speaking, canoeing, photography, Model United Nations). He was not a narrow bookworm.

Becoming a scientist: books or doing?

The book asks whether becoming a scientist, economist or historian simply means reading many books. Ebright's life suggests the answer: books spark interest and give knowledge, but a scientist must also observe, question, experiment and think. His biggest steps came from doing: raising butterflies, testing birds, building a device, growing cells.

Worked example 1: a character sketch (about 100 words)

Richard Ebright is a gifted scientist made by curiosity and hard work. As a child he collected every butterfly species near his home and later raised thousands of monarchs. He learned from failure: after losing a science fair with a display, he turned to real experiments. He was persistent, working through high school on the gold spots of the monarch pupa until he discovered an unknown hormone. He was competitive in the right way, wanting to do his best rather than just win prizes. His varied interests, from debating to photography, show a balanced, energetic personality.

Worked example 2: connecting events

Question: How did high-school research on gold spots lead to a theory about cells? Working: spots produce a hormone; he identified its structure; looking at X-ray photos of a hormone's structure gave him the idea of how a cell reads DNA. Answer: his curiosity about the spots led to the hormone, the hormone to its chemical structure, and the study of that structure to his theory of cell life.

A scientist needs an excellent mind, a curious one, and a wish to win that comes from wanting to do the best work. (The writer's idea, in my words.)

Key takeaways: failure taught Ebright to experiment; each project grew from the last; the three ingredients are a fine mind, curiosity and the right kind of competitive spirit.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What did Ebright learn from losing the seventh-grade science fair?

    1. That science fairs are unfair
    2. That winners had done real experiments, not just made displays
    3. That he should stop studying frogs
    4. That he needed a better microscope
    Show answer

    Answer: B. He saw that the prize-winners had tried real experiments while he had simply made a neat display.

  2. 2. What did Ebright's ninth-grade project test?

    1. Whether viceroys copy monarchs because birds avoid eating monarchs
    2. Whether beetles carry a virus
    3. What the gold spots produce
    4. How monarchs migrate
    Show answer

    Answer: A. He tested the theory that viceroys resemble monarchs since monarchs taste bad to birds, by seeing whether birds would eat monarchs.

  3. 3. What did the gold spots on the monarch pupa turn out to do?

    1. Attract mates
    2. Frighten birds
    3. Store food
    4. Produce a hormone needed for the butterfly's full development
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Ebright and a fellow student built a device showing the spots produce a hormone necessary for full development.

  4. 4. Which is NOT one of the writer's three ingredients of a scientist?

    1. A first-rate mind
    2. Curiosity
    3. Great wealth
    4. The will to win for good reasons
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The writer names a first-rate mind, curiosity and the will to win for good reasons; money is not mentioned.

  5. 5. What did Mr Weiherer mean by saying Ebright was competitive 'but not in a bad sense'?

    1. He never entered competitions.
    2. He wanted to win only to defeat others.
    3. He aimed to do his very best work, not win just for prizes.
    4. He let others win.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. His teacher explained that Ebright wanted to win because he wanted to do his best work, for the right reasons.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery