- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Proving √3, √5 and expressions like 2 + 3√5 irrational
Adapt the proof by contradiction to √3 and √5, and prove that sums, differences, products and quotients of a rational and an irrational number such as 2 + 3√5 are irrational.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Prove that √3, √5 or √p (p prime) is irrational using the same pattern as for √2.
- Prove that numbers like 2 + 3√5 or √2/5 are irrational by isolating the square root.
- Know which combinations are always irrational and which can be either.
The proof for √2 is a template. Change the prime and it works for √3, √5, √7 and so on. A second short template then handles expressions such as 7 − √3 or 4√5, which combine a rational number with an irrational one.
Worked example 1: prove that √5 is irrational
- Assume, to the contrary, that √5 is rational: √5 = a/b with a, b coprime integers, b ≠ 0.
- Then √5 × b = a. Squaring, 5b² = a². So 5 divides a², and since 5 is prime, 5 divides a. Write a = 5c.
- Substitute: 5b² = 25c², so b² = 5c². So 5 divides b², and therefore 5 divides b.
- Now 5 divides both a and b, which contradicts a and b being coprime.
- So the assumption was wrong, and √5 is irrational.
The same steps with 3 in place of 5 prove that √3 is irrational. The proof needs the number under the root to be prime (or at least not a perfect square); for √4 it would fail, and indeed √4 = 2 is rational.
Combining rational and irrational numbers
What happens when you combine numbers
-
Always irrational
- rational + irrational, e.g. 2 + √3
- rational − irrational, e.g. 5 − √2
- non-zero rational × irrational, e.g. 4√5
- irrational ÷ non-zero rational, e.g. √7/3
-
Can be rational or irrational
- irrational + irrational: √2 + (−√2) = 0
- irrational × irrational: √2 × √8 = 4
- but √2 + √3 and √2 × √3 = √6 are irrational
If r is rational and x is irrational, then r + x, r − x and x − r are irrational, and if r ≠ 0, r × x and x ÷ r are irrational too.
To prove such a statement for a particular number, use the same contradiction idea but with a different finish: assume the expression equals a/b, rearrange to get the square root alone on one side, and notice that the other side is a fraction of integers, so the square root would be rational.
Worked example 2: prove that 2 + 3√5 is irrational
- Assume, to the contrary, that 2 + 3√5 is rational: 2 + 3√5 = a/b with a, b integers, b ≠ 0.
- Subtract 2: 3√5 = a/b − 2 = (a − 2b)/b.
- Divide by 3: √5 = (a − 2b)/(3b).
- Since a and b are integers, a − 2b and 3b are integers and 3b ≠ 0, so the right side is rational. That would make √5 rational.
- But √5 is irrational (worked example 1). This contradiction shows that 2 + 3√5 is irrational.
Worked example 3: prove that √2/5 is irrational
Working: assume √2/5 = a/b with a, b integers, b ≠ 0. Multiply by 5: √2 = 5a/b. Since 5a and b are integers and b ≠ 0, 5a/b is rational, so √2 would be rational. That contradicts the fact that √2 is irrational. So √2/5 is irrational.
| Expression | Rearranged to isolate the root | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|
| 7 − √3 = a/b | √3 = (7b − a)/b | Irrational |
| 4√5 = a/b | √5 = a/(4b) | Irrational |
| 6 + √2 = a/b | √2 = (a − 6b)/b | Irrational |
Key takeaways: the √2 proof works for √3, √5 and the square root of any prime: assume a/b in lowest terms, show the prime divides both a and b, and reach a contradiction. For an expression mixing a rational number with √p, assume it equals a/b, isolate √p, and show √p would be rational. Two irrationals can combine to give a rational, so check each case.
Check your understanding
-
1. To prove 6 + √2 is irrational, a student assumes 6 + √2 = a/b. Which expression for √2 follows?
- (a − 6b)/b
- (a + 6b)/b
- (6b − a)/b
- a/(6b)
Show answer
Answer: A. Subtract 6 from both sides: √2 = a/b − 6 = a/b − 6b/b = (a − 6b)/b. This is a ratio of integers, so √2 would be rational, which is the contradiction.
-
2. Which of the following is a rational number?
- 2√3
- √3 + √2
- (3 + √2) + (3 − √2)
- 5 − √7
Show answer
Answer: C. (3 + √2) + (3 − √2) = 3 + 3 + √2 − √2 = 6, which is rational. 2√3 and 5 − √7 mix a rational with an irrational, so they are irrational, and √3 + √2 is also irrational.
-
3. Which statement is true?
- The product of two irrational numbers is always irrational
- √5 + 0 is rational
- The square root of every whole number is irrational
- √8 × √2 = 4, which is rational
Show answer
Answer: D. √8 × √2 = √16 = 4, a rational number, which also shows that the product of two irrationals need not be irrational. √5 + 0 = √5 is irrational, and √9 = 3 shows that not every square root is irrational.
-
4. Assertion (A): 5√3 is irrational.
Reason (R): The product of a non-zero rational number and an irrational number is irrational.- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. 5 is a non-zero rational number and √3 is irrational, so by R their product 5√3 is irrational. Both statements are true and R is exactly the reason A holds.
-
5. In proving that √5 is irrational, the step 5b² = a² is reached. Which conclusion follows, using the result about primes?
- a = 5
- 5 divides a
- 5 divides b
- b = 5a
Show answer
Answer: B. 5b² = a² shows that 5 divides a². Since 5 is prime, 5 divides a. Only after writing a = 5c and substituting does it follow that 5 divides b too.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.