- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
How different groups saw Civil Disobedience, and its limits
Understand why rich peasants, poor peasants, business classes, workers and women joined Civil Disobedience, and why many dalits and Muslims kept their distance, including the Poona Pact and the debate on separate electorates.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain what swaraj meant to rich peasants, poor peasants, business classes, workers and women.
- Explain the dalit demand for separate electorates and the Poona Pact of 1932.
- Explain why many Muslims were lukewarm towards the Civil Disobedience Movement.
Civil Disobedience brought many groups into the struggle, but not for the same reasons. Some joined with enthusiasm and later grew disappointed; some stayed away. This lesson looks at the participants and at the limits of the movement.
Rich peasants and poor peasants
Rich peasant communities such as the Patidars of Gujarat and the Jats of Uttar Pradesh, producers of commercial crops, were hit hard by the trade depression and falling prices. They could not pay the revenue demand, and the government refused to reduce it. They became enthusiastic supporters, organising their communities for the boycotts. For them, swaraj meant a struggle against high revenue. They were deeply disappointed when the movement was called off in 1931 without revenue being revised, and many did not rejoin in 1932.
Poorer peasants, many of them small tenants, wanted more than lower revenue: they could not pay rent to landlords and wanted unpaid rent remitted. They joined radical movements, often led by Socialists and Communists. Fearing to upset rich peasants and landlords, the Congress was unwilling to support "no rent" campaigns in most places, so its relationship with poor peasants remained uncertain.
Business classes
During the First World War, Indian merchants and industrialists had made huge profits. Now they opposed colonial policies that restricted business: they wanted protection against foreign imports and a rupee-sterling exchange ratio that would discourage imports. They formed the Indian Industrial and Commercial Congress in 1920 and the Federation of the Indian Chamber of Commerce and Industries (FICCI) in 1927. Led by industrialists such as Purshottamdas Thakurdas and G. D. Birla, they attacked colonial control of the economy and at first supported Civil Disobedience with money and by refusing to trade in imported goods. For them, swaraj meant an end to colonial restrictions on business. But after the Round Table Conference failed, they grew uneasy about militant activity, long disruption of business and the growing influence of socialism among younger Congress members.
Industrial workers and women
The industrial working class did not join in large numbers except in the Nagpur region; as industrialists came closer to the Congress, workers stayed aloof. Some did adopt Gandhian ideas such as boycott within their own struggles against low wages and poor conditions: railway workers struck in 1930, dockworkers in 1932, and tin-mine workers in Chotanagpur wore Gandhi caps at protest rallies. The Congress was reluctant to include workers' demands, fearing it would alienate industrialists.
Women took part on a large scale: they joined marches, made salt, picketed foreign cloth and liquor shops, and many went to jail. In cities they were mostly from high-caste families; in villages, from rich peasant households. They came to see service to the nation as a sacred duty. Yet this public role did not radically change how women's position was seen: Gandhiji believed women's duty was home and family, and for a long time the Congress was reluctant to give women positions of authority, valuing mainly their symbolic presence.
Why groups joined Civil Disobedience
-
Rich peasants
- Lower revenue demand
-
Poor peasants
- Remission of unpaid rent
-
Business classes
- Protection from imports; freedom from colonial restrictions
-
Workers (some)
- Better wages and working conditions
-
Women
- Service to the nation as a sacred duty
The limits: dalits
Not all groups were moved by the abstract idea of swaraj. The "untouchables", who from around the 1930s called themselves dalit (oppressed), had long been ignored by the Congress for fear of offending conservative high-caste Hindus (sanatanis). Gandhiji declared that swaraj would not come for a hundred years if untouchability was not removed. He called them harijan (children of God), organised satyagraha for their entry into temples and access to public wells, tanks, roads and schools, and himself cleaned toilets to dignify the work of sweepers. But many dalit leaders wanted a political solution: reserved seats in educational institutions and a separate electorate to choose dalit members of legislative councils.
Dr B. R. Ambedkar, who organised the Depressed Classes Association in 1930, clashed with Gandhiji at the second Round Table Conference by demanding separate electorates. When the British conceded this, Gandhiji began a fast unto death, believing separate electorates would slow dalits' integration into society. Ambedkar finally accepted Gandhiji's position, resulting in the Poona Pact of September 1932: the Depressed Classes (later Scheduled Castes) got reserved seats in provincial and central legislative councils, but were to be voted in by the general electorate.
Poona Pact (1932): reserved seats for the Depressed Classes in legislatures, elected by the general electorate rather than by a separate dalit electorate.
The limits: Muslims
After the Non-Cooperation-Khilafat Movement declined, many Muslims felt alienated from the Congress, which from the mid-1920s was more visibly associated with Hindu religious nationalist groups like the Hindu Mahasabha. Communal clashes deepened the distance. The Congress and the Muslim League tried to renegotiate an alliance; the key difference was over representation in future assemblies. Muhammad Ali Jinnah was willing to give up separate electorates if Muslims were assured reserved seats in the Central Assembly and representation in proportion to population in Muslim-majority provinces (Bengal and Punjab). Hopes of a settlement at the All Parties Conference in 1928 ended when M. R. Jayakar of the Hindu Mahasabha strongly opposed compromise. In 1930, Sir Muhammad Iqbal, as president of the Muslim League, stressed separate electorates as a safeguard for Muslims as a minority; many Muslims feared their culture would be submerged under a Hindu majority.
Worked example: comparing two positions
| Question | Gandhiji | Ambedkar |
|---|---|---|
| Main remedy for dalits | Social reform: end untouchability, change hearts of upper castes | Political empowerment: reserved seats and separate electorates |
| View of separate electorates | Would slow integration into society | Necessary for real representation |
| Outcome | Poona Pact: reserved seats, general electorate | Accepted the compromise in 1932 |
Key takeaways: Rich peasants wanted lower revenue, poor peasants wanted rent remitted, business classes wanted freedom from colonial restrictions, some workers joined selectively, and women participated widely without gaining authority. Many dalits sought political safeguards; the Poona Pact (1932) gave reserved seats through a general electorate. Many Muslims, alienated after the mid-1920s and worried about minority status, stayed lukewarm.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why did rich peasants like the Patidars and Jats support Civil Disobedience?
- They wanted unpaid rent remitted
- Falling prices during the Depression made the revenue demand impossible to pay, and the government refused to reduce it
- They wanted separate electorates
- They opposed boycotts
Show answer
Answer: B. As producers of commercial crops hit by falling prices, they wanted the revenue demand reduced; for them swaraj meant a struggle against high revenue.
-
2. Why did the Congress hesitate to support 'no rent' campaigns of poor peasants?
- It wanted higher rents
- Poor peasants did not want rent reduced
- It feared upsetting rich peasants and landlords
- Rents had already been abolished
Show answer
Answer: C. The Congress did not want to alienate rich peasants and landlords, so the relationship with poor peasants remained uncertain.
-
3. Which organisation did Indian industrialists form in 1927?
- The Swaraj Party
- The Oudh Kisan Sabha
- The Depressed Classes Association
- FICCI
Show answer
Answer: D. The Federation of the Indian Chamber of Commerce and Industries was formed in 1927 to organise business interests.
-
4. What did the Poona Pact of September 1932 provide?
- Reserved seats for the Depressed Classes, voted in by the general electorate
- Separate electorates for dalits
- No representation for dalits
- Abolition of legislative councils
Show answer
Answer: A. Ambedkar accepted Gandhiji's position: reserved seats in provincial and central councils, but elected by the general electorate.
-
5. Assertion (A): Large sections of Muslims were lukewarm towards the Civil Disobedience Movement. Reason (R): After the decline of the Khilafat movement, many Muslims felt alienated from the Congress, and talks on representation broke down.
- A is true but R is false
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: C. Alienation from the Congress, communal tension and the failure of the 1928 negotiations (R) created the suspicion that kept many Muslims away (A).
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.