• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Sectors in India: production, employment and underemployment

See how the tertiary sector has become the largest producing sector in India, why employment has not shifted in the same way, and what disguised unemployment means.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why the tertiary sector has grown in importance in India.
  • Explain why the primary sector remains the largest employer.
  • Define underemployment (disguised unemployment) with rural and urban examples.

Has India followed the same path as the developed countries? The textbook compares production and employment in the three sectors for two years forty years apart, 1977-78 and 2017-18. Production grew in all three sectors, but the story of jobs is very different. This lesson explains both.

Rising importance of the tertiary sector in production

Between 1977-78 and 2017-18, production rose in all three sectors but rose most in the tertiary sector. By 2017-18 the tertiary sector had become the largest producing sector in India, replacing the primary sector. The textbook gives four reasons:

  1. Basic services are needed everywhere: hospitals, schools, post offices, police stations, courts, village offices, municipal bodies, defence, transport, banks and insurance. In a developing country the government must take responsibility for providing these.
  2. Growth of agriculture and industry increases demand for transport, trade and storage.
  3. Rising incomes make some people demand more services such as eating out, tourism, shopping, private hospitals, private schools and professional training, especially in big cities.
  4. New services based on information and communication technology have become important and are growing rapidly.

But not all of the service sector is growing equally. At one end are a limited number of services employing highly skilled and educated workers. At the other end are very many workers such as small shopkeepers, repair persons and transport workers who barely earn a living and do this work only because they have no other options. So only a part of the sector is growing in importance.

Employment has not shifted

A remarkable fact about India is that while the shares of the three sectors in production changed, a similar shift did not happen in employment. The primary sector is still the largest employer. The reason is that not enough jobs were created in the secondary and tertiary sectors. According to the textbook, industrial output rose more than nine times over the period but industrial employment only about three times; service production rose about fourteen times but service employment about five times. As a result, more than half of the country's workers are in the primary sector, mainly agriculture, producing only about one-sixth of GVA (according to the textbook).

India: production versus employment

  • Production
    • Rose in all three sectors
    • Rose most in the tertiary sector
    • Tertiary is now the largest producer
  • Employment
    • Did not shift in the same way
    • Primary is still the largest employer
    • Too few jobs created in industry and services

Underemployment or disguised unemployment

If so many people work in agriculture and produce relatively little, there are more people in agriculture than necessary. Even if some move out, production will not fall. This is underemployment: people appear to be working, but all of them work less than their potential.

Disguised unemployment: more people are engaged in a piece of work than are needed, so everyone seems busy but each is working below potential; if some leave, total output does not fall.

Worked example 1: a rural case

Situation (made up): Ramesh's family of six owns two hectares of rain-fed land growing bajra and moong. All six work on it throughout the year because there is nowhere else to work. Test: A nearby brick kiln hires two of them. Does farm output fall? No, because four people can easily do the work. Conclusion: Two of the six were disguisedly unemployed. Now the family earns wages from the kiln and the same harvest, so its income rises.

Worked example 2: an urban case

In cities, thousands of casual workers such as painters, plumbers and repair persons search for work every day and often find none. Street vendors may spend the whole day pushing a cart yet earn very little. They do this because they have no better opportunities. They are counted as working, but they are working below their capacity: this too is underemployment, in the service sector.

FeatureOpen unemploymentDisguised unemployment
VisibilityClearly visible: the person has no jobHidden: the person seems to be working
Effect of removing workersNot applicableOutput does not fall
Typical exampleA graduate searching for a job in a cityExtra family members on a small farm

Key takeaways: In India the tertiary sector has become the largest producer, though only part of it offers good jobs. Employment did not shift: the primary sector remains the largest employer because too few jobs were created elsewhere. This leaves many people underemployed, a hidden form of unemployment found in villages and towns.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which sector had become the largest producing sector in India by 2017-18, according to the textbook?

    1. Primary
    2. Secondary
    3. Tertiary
    4. None; all were equal
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Production rose most in the tertiary sector between 1977-78 and 2017-18, so it replaced the primary sector as the largest producing sector.

  2. 2. Underemployment occurs when people:

    1. Do not want to work
    2. Are not paid at all
    3. Work in a lazy manner
    4. Work less than what they are capable of
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Underemployed people appear to be working, but the work is divided among more people than needed, so each works below potential.

  3. 3. Why has the primary sector remained the largest employer in India even though its share in production has fallen?

    1. Not enough jobs were created in the secondary and tertiary sectors
    2. Agriculture pays the highest wages
    3. Factories employ more people than they need
    4. The government bans people from leaving agriculture
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Output in industry and services grew much faster than employment in them, so people could not move out of agriculture in large numbers.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Rising incomes have increased the demand for services such as tourism and private schools. Reason (R): Every part of the service sector offers well-paid, skilled jobs.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R explains A
    2. A is true but R is false
    3. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A
    4. A is false but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A is one of the textbook's reasons for growth in services. R is false: many service workers, such as small shopkeepers and casual repair workers, barely earn a living.

  5. 5. A family of five works on a small plot that three people could manage. Two members take jobs in a nearby factory. What happens?

    1. Farm output falls sharply
    2. The factory closes
    3. The family loses its land
    4. Family income rises and farm output stays the same
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The two were disguisedly unemployed; their leaving does not reduce farm output, and their wages add to family income.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → How to create more employment

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery