• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Problems with large dams and inter-state water disputes

Explain the ecological and social problems caused by large dams and multi-purpose projects, and describe how they lead to disputes between states.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain how damming affects river flow, sediment and aquatic life.
  • Explain why dams built to control floods have sometimes triggered floods.
  • Describe the Krishna-Godavari dispute and the Sardar Sarovar project as examples of shared water.

In recent years, multi-purpose projects and large dams have come under great scrutiny and opposition. The same structures that store water and produce power also change rivers, landscapes and lives. This lesson weighs those costs.

Effects on rivers and aquatic life

How damming changes a river

  1. River is regulated and dammed Its natural flow is changed.
  2. Poor sediment flow downstream Sediment settles at the bottom of the reservoir.
  3. Rockier stream beds Poorer habitats for the river's aquatic life.
  4. River fragmented Aquatic animals find it hard to migrate, especially to spawn.

Reservoirs created on floodplains submerge existing vegetation and soil, which then decompose over time.

Floods, silt and land

Ironically, dams built to control floods have triggered floods because of sedimentation in the reservoir, and big dams have mostly failed to control floods during excessive rainfall. Such floods destroyed life and property and caused extensive soil erosion. Sedimentation also meant that floodplains were deprived of silt, a natural fertiliser, adding to land degradation. Multi-purpose projects were also observed to have induced earthquakes and caused water-borne diseases, pests and pollution resulting from excessive water use.

Changing cropping patterns

Irrigation has changed the cropping pattern of many regions, as farmers shifted to water-intensive and commercial crops. This has serious ecological consequences such as salinisation of the soil.

Social costs

Large projects also submerge villages and farmland, which can cause large-scale displacement and loss of livelihood for local people. This is an argument against such projects, not one in their favour.

Multi-purpose projects: the two sides

  • Advantages
    • Water for areas facing scarcity
    • Irrigation for farms
    • Electricity for industries and homes
    • Flood control by regulating flow
    • Water supply, navigation, fish breeding
  • Disadvantages
    • Poor sediment flow and rockier stream beds
    • Fragmented rivers block fish migration
    • Submerged vegetation and soil
    • Floods from sedimentation; floodplains lose silt
    • Salinisation from water-intensive crops
    • Displacement and loss of livelihood

Shared rivers and disputes

Rivers flow across state boundaries, so a project in one state can reduce water downstream in another. The textbook's example is the Krishna-Godavari dispute: the governments of Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh objected to the Maharashtra government diverting more water at Koyna for a multi-purpose project, because it would reduce downstream flow in their states and harm their agriculture and industry.

Projects can also be shared. The Sardar Sarovar Dam has been built over the Narmada river in Gujarat. It is one of India's largest water resource projects and covers four states: Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat and Rajasthan. It is meant to meet water needs in drought-prone and desert areas, including desert districts of Rajasthan and a tribal hilly tract of Maharashtra; according to the textbook, much of its command area in Gujarat and all of it in Rajasthan is drought-prone.

Worked example 1: sorting arguments

Which of these is NOT an argument in favour of multi-purpose projects? (i) They bring water to areas facing scarcity. (ii) They control floods by regulating flow. (iii) They cause large-scale displacement and loss of livelihood. (iv) They generate electricity. Statements (i), (ii) and (iv) are benefits. Statement (iii) is a cost, so it is the one that is not in favour.

Worked example 2: correcting a false statement

False statement: 'Regulating and damming rivers does not affect a river's natural flow and sediment flow.' Find the mistake: the textbook says damming does affect natural flow, causing poor sediment flow and excess sedimentation in the reservoir. Corrected: 'Regulating and damming rivers affects their natural flow, causing poor sediment flow downstream and excessive sedimentation at the bottom of the reservoir.'

A dam's benefits come with costs: changed river flow, lost silt, fragmented habitats, salinised soils and displaced people. Planning must weigh both.

Key takeaways: Damming changes river flow, traps sediment, makes stream beds rockier, fragments rivers and submerges land. Dams have sometimes triggered floods, starved floodplains of silt, and been linked to earthquakes, disease and pollution. Irrigation shifted farmers to water-intensive crops, causing salinisation. Shared rivers lead to disputes, as in the Krishna-Godavari case over Koyna, and to shared projects such as Sardar Sarovar on the Narmada.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Why do dams make it difficult for aquatic fauna to migrate?

    1. Dams fragment rivers
    2. Dams increase silt on floodplains
    3. Dams make water warmer
    4. Dams remove all fish from rivers
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook says dams fragment rivers, making it difficult for aquatic animals to migrate, especially for spawning.

  2. 2. How have some dams built for flood control actually triggered floods?

    1. By releasing too little water
    2. By sedimentation in the reservoir
    3. By increasing silt on floodplains
    4. By reducing rainfall
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Sediment settles in the reservoir and reduces its capacity, so during heavy rain dams have triggered floods instead of preventing them.

  3. 3. Which states objected to Maharashtra diverting more water at Koyna, giving rise to the Krishna-Godavari dispute?

    1. Gujarat and Rajasthan
    2. Madhya Pradesh and Gujarat
    3. Tamil Nadu and Kerala
    4. Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh objected because more water diverted at Koyna would reduce downstream flow in their states.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Irrigation has led to salinisation of soil in many regions.
    Reason (R): Irrigation encouraged farmers to shift to water-intensive and commercial crops.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: the shift to water-intensive crops with heavy irrigation brought ecological consequences such as soil salinisation.

  5. 5. The Sardar Sarovar Dam is built over which river, and in which state?

    1. Krishna, in Maharashtra
    2. Mahanadi, in Odisha
    3. Narmada, in Gujarat
    4. Sutlej, in Punjab
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Sardar Sarovar Dam is on the Narmada river in Gujarat; the project covers Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat and Rajasthan.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery