- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Impact of globalisation in India and the struggle for fair globalisation
Assess who has gained and who has lost from globalisation in India, from consumers and big companies to small producers and workers, and what fair globalisation would require.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain how globalisation has benefited consumers, MNCs, some Indian companies and IT services.
- Explain why small producers and workers have faced difficulties, with examples.
- Describe what the government and people can do for fair globalisation.
Globalisation of the Indian economy has come a long way. Has it helped people? The chapter's answer is that the impact has not been uniform: some have gained a great deal and others have lost. This lesson weighs the evidence.
Who has benefited
- Consumers, particularly well-off people in cities, have a greater choice, better quality and lower prices for many products, and enjoy higher standards of living than before.
- MNCs have increased their investment in India, in industries such as cell phones, automobiles, electronics, soft drinks, fast food and urban services such as banking, which have many well-off buyers. New jobs have been created in these industries, and local companies supplying them with raw materials have prospered.
- Several top Indian companies have benefited from competition by investing in new technology and raising production standards; some gained from collaborations with foreign companies. Some have even become multinationals themselves; the textbook names companies such as Tata Motors (automobiles), Infosys (IT) and Asian Paints (paints).
- Service companies, especially in IT, have new opportunities: call centres, data entry, accounting, administrative and engineering services are now done in India and exported to developed countries.
Steps to attract foreign investment
The central and state governments have taken special steps to attract foreign companies. Special Economic Zones (SEZs) are industrial zones meant to have world-class facilities such as electricity, water, roads, transport, storage, and recreational and educational facilities. According to the textbook, companies setting up in SEZs do not have to pay taxes for an initial period of five years. The government has also allowed flexibility in labour laws: instead of hiring workers on a regular basis, companies can hire them for short periods when work is heavy, which lowers their labour costs. Some people have opposed SEZs, showing again that development for one group may harm another.
Small producers: compete or perish
For many small producers and workers, globalisation has posed major challenges. Industries such as batteries, capacitors, plastics, toys, tyres, dairy products and vegetable oil saw small manufacturers hit hard by competition; several units shut down and workers lost jobs. This matters because small and medium industries employ the largest number of workers in India after agriculture.
Worked example 1: a small producer's story
Case (summarised from the textbook): Ravi started a small company in Hosur, Tamil Nadu, in 1992 making capacitors, used in televisions and other appliances. It grew to 20 workers. After the government removed restrictions on imports of capacitors under a WTO agreement in 2001, his main buyers, television companies, either became assemblers for MNC brands or imported capacitors at about half his price. Ravi's output fell to less than half and he had only seven workers left; many similar units closed. What would help him? According to studies cited in the chapter, small producers need (a) better roads, power, water, raw materials, marketing and information networks; (b) modern technology; and (c) timely credit at reasonable interest. These are largely areas where the government must act, since MNCs are unlikely to invest in them for small producers.
Competition and uncertain employment
Globalisation and competition have changed workers' lives. Most employers now prefer to employ workers flexibly, so jobs are no longer secure. In the garment export industry, large MNCs in Europe and America look for the cheapest goods. To win orders, Indian exporters cut costs, and since raw material costs cannot be cut, they cut labour costs: hiring temporary rather than permanent workers, demanding very long hours and night shifts in peak seasons, and paying low wages. The MNCs make large profits while workers are denied a fair share of the benefits.
Worked example 2: reading a source
Source (summarised): A garment worker who once had a permanent job with health insurance, provident fund and double-rate overtime lost it when her factory closed. Years later she works far from home, seven days a week, as a temporary worker earning less than half her old wage, with no benefits. Question: What does this show? Answer: Conditions in the organised sector have come to resemble the unorganised sector; workers no longer get the protection and benefits they once had, even as their employers' export business grows.
Uneven impact of globalisation
-
Gained
- Well-off urban consumers
- MNCs and their suppliers
- Large Indian companies and IT services
- People with education, skill and wealth
-
Lost or struggled
- Small producers facing cheaper imports
- Workers in flexible, insecure jobs
- Many in the unorganised sector
The struggle for fair globalisation
Fair globalisation would create opportunities for all and ensure that the benefits of globalisation are shared better.
The government can play a major role. Its policies must protect the interests of all the people, not only the rich and powerful. It can ensure that labour laws are properly implemented so workers get their rights; support small producers until they are strong enough to compete; use trade and investment barriers if necessary; negotiate at the WTO for fairer rules; and align with other developing countries with similar interests against the domination of developed countries. People too can act: in recent years, campaigns and representation by people's organisations have influenced important decisions on trade and investment at the WTO.
Making globalisation fair
-
Government
- Enforce labour laws
- Support small producers
- Use barriers if needed
- Negotiate fairer WTO rules
- Ally with other developing countries
-
People
- Campaigns and organisations
- Representation on trade decisions
Key takeaways: Globalisation has benefited well-off consumers, MNCs, large Indian companies and IT services, and governments have tried to attract foreign investment through SEZs and flexible labour rules. But many small producers have been hurt by competition and many workers now have insecure jobs. People with education, skill and wealth have gained most. Fair globalisation needs government policies that protect everyone and collective action by people.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which group has gained most clearly from globalisation, according to the chapter?
- Well-off consumers in urban areas
- Small producers of capacitors
- Temporary garment workers
- Small toy makers
Show answer
Answer: A. Well-off urban consumers enjoy greater choice, better quality and lower prices. Small producers and many workers have faced difficulties.
-
2. What is a Special Economic Zone (SEZ)?
- A zone where foreign goods are banned
- An industrial zone with world-class facilities set up to attract investment
- A protected forest area
- A zone where only small industries may operate
Show answer
Answer: B. SEZs are industrial zones meant to offer electricity, water, roads, transport and other facilities, with incentives, to attract foreign companies.
-
3. How does flexibility in labour laws help companies?
- It requires them to hire workers permanently
- It doubles workers' wages
- It lets them hire workers for short periods when needed, reducing labour costs
- It bans overtime
Show answer
Answer: C. Flexible hiring means companies need not pay workers for the whole year or provide permanent benefits, which lowers their costs, but makes jobs insecure.
-
4. A small capacitor maker loses most of his orders after import restrictions are removed and cheaper imported capacitors arrive. Which measure would most directly help such producers compete?
- Removing all roads
- Banning exports
- Higher taxes on small producers
- Timely credit at reasonable interest and modern technology
Show answer
Answer: D. Studies cited in the chapter say small producers need better infrastructure, modernised technology and timely, affordable credit to compete.
-
5. Assertion (A): The impact of globalisation in India has not been uniform. Reason (R): People with education, skill and wealth have made the best use of new opportunities, while many small producers and workers have suffered.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: B. Because benefits went mainly to the educated, skilled and wealthy while others lost out (R), the impact has been uneven (A).
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.