• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Hand labour and steam power: the life of workers in Britain

Understand why many British industrialists preferred hand labour to machines, and what life was like for workers, including seasonal work, unemployment and opposition to the Spinning Jenny.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why industrialists in Victorian Britain often preferred hand labour.
  • Describe the conditions of workers: finding jobs, seasonal work, wages and unemployment.
  • Explain why workers opposed new machines such as the Spinning Jenny.

If machines raised productivity, why did British industrialists not mechanise everything? The answer lies in the labour market, in the seasons and in what customers wanted. This lesson also looks at what industrialisation meant for workers.

Why hand labour?

  1. Plenty of labour, low wages. In Victorian Britain, poor peasants and vagrants moved to cities in large numbers looking for work. With plenty of labour, wages were low, so industrialists did not want machines that replaced workers and needed large capital investment.
  2. Seasonal demand. Gas works and breweries were busiest in the cold months; bookbinders and printers needed extra hands before Christmas; ships were repaired in winter. Where production fluctuated with the season, industrialists preferred to hire hand labour for the season.
  3. Variety and skill. Machines produced uniform, standardised goods for a mass market, but demand was often for intricate designs and specific shapes. According to the textbook, mid-nineteenth-century Britain produced 500 varieties of hammers and 45 kinds of axes, which needed human skill.
  4. Class taste. The upper classes, aristocrats and the bourgeoisie, preferred handmade goods, which symbolised refinement and class: better finished, individually produced and carefully designed. Machine-made goods were for export to the colonies.

Where labour was scarce, as in nineteenth-century America, industrialists were keen on mechanical power to reduce the need for workers. Britain had no such problem.

Britain and America: the choice of technology

  • Britain
    • Abundant labour, low wages
    • Hand labour preferred in many industries
    • Handmade goods valued by the rich
  • America
    • Labour shortage
    • Keen on mechanical power
    • Machines to save human labour

Industrialists chose technology according to conditions: where labour was plentiful and cheap, demand seasonal or for varied designs, hand labour was preferred; where labour was scarce, machines were favoured.

Life of the workers

As news of jobs spread, hundreds tramped to the cities. Getting a job depended on networks of friends and relatives: someone with a contact in a factory found work faster. Others waited for weeks, sleeping under bridges or in night shelters, either Night Refuges run by private individuals or Casual Wards maintained by the Poor Law authorities. The textbook quotes a man who walked to London in 1881 with two friends, ran out of money on the third day, slept under a haystack and in a shed, and finally got a job at a gas works only because a friend spoke to the foreman.

Seasonality meant long periods without work: after the busy season the poor were on the streets again. Some returned to the countryside; most looked for odd jobs, which were hard to find until the mid-nineteenth century. Wages rose somewhat in the early nineteenth century, but averages hide variations between trades and from year to year. When prices rose sharply during the long Napoleonic War, the real value of wages fell, since the same wages bought fewer things. Income also depended on the number of days of work. According to the textbook, even at the best of times until the mid-nineteenth century about 10 per cent of the urban population were extremely poor, and in slumps such as the 1830s unemployment rose to between 35 and 75 per cent in different regions.

Worked example 1: wage rate versus income

Made-up figures: Worker A earns 3 shillings a day and works 200 days a year: 3 × 200 = 600 shillings. Worker B earns 2.5 shillings a day but works 300 days: 2.5 × 300 = 750 shillings. Although A's daily wage is higher, B earns more in the year. Conclusion: the period of employment matters as much as the wage rate, which is why average wage figures tell us little about workers' welfare.

Fear of machines: the Spinning Jenny

Fear of unemployment made workers hostile to new technology. The Spinning Jenny, devised by James Hargreaves in 1764, let one worker turn a single wheel and set several spindles in motion, spinning several threads at once. It speeded up spinning and reduced the demand for labour. In the woollen industry, women who survived by hand spinning attacked the new machines; the conflict continued for a long time. A magistrate's report of 1790, quoted in the textbook, describes colliers and their wives, who had lost work to spinning engines, threatening to destroy a newly introduced machine.

Why workers attacked the Spinning Jenny

  1. Jenny introduced One worker runs many spindles
  2. Less labour needed Hand spinners lose work
  3. Fear of unemployment Especially among women spinners
  4. Attacks on machines Long conflict over the jenny

More work after the 1840s

After the 1840s, building activity in cities opened up more jobs: roads were widened, railway stations built, lines extended, tunnels dug, drains and sewers laid and rivers embanked. According to the textbook, the number of workers in the transport industry doubled in the 1840s and doubled again in the next 30 years.

Worked example 2: a merchant's reply

Task: Imagine a merchant explaining why he will not buy a new machine. Sample answer: "Labour here is plentiful and cheap, and my work is busiest only in winter, so I hire hands for the season. My customers want many different designs that your machine cannot make, and the wealthy prefer handmade goods. Your machine is costly, breaks down often and repairs are expensive. I shall wait." This sums up the chapter's reasons for preferring hand labour.

Key takeaways: In Victorian Britain, abundant cheap labour, seasonal demand, the need for varied designs and upper-class taste for handmade goods led many industrialists to prefer hand labour; labour-short America mechanised more. Workers faced uncertain jobs that depended on connections, seasonal unemployment and falling real wages, and they resisted machines like the Spinning Jenny. City building after the 1840s created more work.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Why did many industrialists in Victorian Britain prefer hand labour to machines?

    1. Labour was scarce and costly
    2. Machines were free
    3. Labour was plentiful and wages low, so there was no need for costly machines that replaced workers
    4. The government required hand labour
    Show answer

    Answer: C. With abundant labour and low wages, industrialists had no labour shortage and avoided large capital investment in machines.

  2. 2. In which kind of industry did employers especially prefer seasonal hand labour?

    1. Industries with steady demand all year
    2. Only in agriculture
    3. Industries with no workers
    4. Industries where production fluctuated with the season, like gas works and breweries
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Where demand peaked in certain seasons, employers hired hands for the season rather than investing in machines.

  3. 3. Who devised the Spinning Jenny, and when?

    1. James Hargreaves, 1764
    2. James Watt, 1781
    3. Richard Arkwright, 1730
    4. Henry Ford, 1914
    Show answer

    Answer: A. James Hargreaves devised the Spinning Jenny in 1764; Watt patented his improved steam engine in 1781.

  4. 4. Why did women hand spinners in the woollen industry attack the Spinning Jenny?

    1. It made spinning slower
    2. It reduced the demand for labour, threatening their livelihood
    3. It was too expensive for factories
    4. It produced coloured yarn
    Show answer

    Answer: B. One worker could run many spindles, so fewer spinners were needed; women who lived by hand spinning feared unemployment.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Average wage figures tell us little about the welfare of nineteenth-century British workers. Reason (R): Real wages fell when prices rose, and income depended on the number of days of work as well as the wage rate.

    1. A is false but R is true
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true but R is false
    4. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Because rising prices cut what wages could buy and periods without work reduced income (R), average wage rates do not show how well workers lived (A).

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery