- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
The print revolution: a new reading public, religious debate and fear of print
Understand how print created a new reading public that blended oral and reading cultures, how it fuelled religious debate and the Reformation, and why authorities feared it.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain how print created a new reading public and blurred oral and reading cultures.
- Explain the role of print in Martin Luther's Reformation.
- Explain why some people feared print and how the Roman Catholic Church responded.
The print revolution was not just a new way of making books. It transformed people's lives, changing their relationship with information, knowledge, institutions and authority. This lesson looks at three of those changes.
A new reading public
Printing reduced the cost of books: less time and labour went into each copy, and multiple copies were easy to produce. Books flooded the market and reached an ever-growing readership. Before print, reading was restricted to elites; common people lived in an oral culture, hearing sacred texts read aloud, ballads recited and folk tales told, and sharing stories collectively. Now a reading public came into being where there had been a hearing public.
The transition was not simple, because literacy in most European countries was low until the twentieth century. Publishers had to reach people who could not read. So they printed popular ballads and folk tales, profusely illustrated, which were sung and recited at village gatherings and in town taverns. Oral culture entered print, and printed material was passed on orally. The line between oral and reading cultures blurred, and the hearing and reading publics intermingled.
How oral and print cultures mixed
- Folk tales and ballads printed
- Printed books read aloud at gatherings
- Listeners who cannot read enjoy them
- Demand for more popular printed material
Then back to step 1: Folk tales and ballads printed
Print created a reading public, but because many could not read, printed ballads and tales were read aloud, so oral culture and print culture blended.
Religious debates
Print made wide circulation of ideas possible and opened a new world of debate. Even those who disagreed with established authorities could print and circulate their views and persuade others to think and act differently. In 1517 the religious reformer Martin Luther wrote the Ninety Five Theses, criticising many practices and rituals of the Roman Catholic Church; a printed copy was posted on a church door in Wittenberg, challenging the Church to debate. His writings were reproduced in vast numbers and read widely, leading to a division within the Church and the beginning of the Protestant Reformation. According to the textbook, Luther's translation of the New Testament sold 5,000 copies within a few weeks. Grateful to print, Luther called it the ultimate and greatest gift of God. Many scholars think print created a new intellectual atmosphere that helped spread the ideas of the Reformation.
The fear of print
Not everyone welcomed the printed book. Religious authorities, monarchs and many writers feared that without control over what was printed and read, rebellious and irreligious thoughts might spread and the authority of "valuable" literature would be destroyed. The Catholic scholar Erasmus, who criticised excesses of Catholicism but kept his distance from Luther, wrote in 1508 that swarms of new books were creating a glut harmful to scholarship, and that printers filled the world with ignorant, scandalous, irreligious and seditious books, so that even valuable publications lost their value.
Print also encouraged individual interpretations of faith even among little-educated people. In the sixteenth century Menocchio, a miller in Italy, read books available locally and reinterpreted the Bible's message, forming a view of God and Creation that enraged the Church. During the Inquisition, a Roman Catholic court that identified and punished heretics, he was hauled up twice and finally executed. Troubled by such effects, the Church imposed severe controls on publishers and booksellers and from 1558 maintained an Index of Prohibited Books.
Responses to print in sixteenth-century Europe
-
Welcomed print
- Martin Luther: a gift of God
- Readers who wanted new ideas
- Reformers spreading their views
-
Feared print
- Erasmus: a glut of harmful books
- Roman Catholic Church: heresy (Menocchio)
- Index of Prohibited Books from 1558
Worked example 1: cause and effect
Question: Why was Martin Luther in favour of print? Answer: Print let his Ninety Five Theses and his translation of the New Testament be reproduced quickly in vast numbers and read across Europe. Without print, his criticism of the Church would have reached only a few people. Print turned his challenge into a mass movement, the Protestant Reformation.
Worked example 2: why an Index of Prohibited Books?
Question: Why did the Roman Catholic Church begin an Index of Prohibited Books in 1558? Answer: Print let ordinary readers like Menocchio form their own interpretations of faith, and reformers spread criticism of the Church. To protect its authority to decide what should be believed, the Church controlled publishers and booksellers and listed books that Catholics were forbidden to read.
Key takeaways: Print lowered the cost of books and created a reading public, while printed ballads and tales read aloud blended oral and reading cultures. Print spread Luther's Ninety Five Theses (1517) and helped launch the Protestant Reformation. Fear that print would spread rebellious and irreligious ideas led critics like Erasmus to attack it and the Catholic Church to punish heretics and keep an Index of Prohibited Books from 1558.
Check your understanding
-
1. How did publishers reach people who could not read in early modern Europe?
- They stopped printing books
- They sold books only to elites
- They printed only in Latin
- They printed illustrated ballads and folk tales that were sung and recited at gatherings
Show answer
Answer: D. Illustrated ballads and folk tales were read aloud in villages and taverns, so even non-readers enjoyed printed material.
-
2. In 1517, Martin Luther wrote:
- The Ninety Five Theses
- The Index of Prohibited Books
- The Adages
- The Diamond Sutra
Show answer
Answer: A. Luther's Ninety Five Theses criticised Roman Catholic practices; printed widely, they began the Protestant Reformation.
-
3. What was Erasmus's view of printed books?
- He thought all books were valuable
- He feared a glut of books, many of them ignorant, scandalous or seditious, that would make valuable works lose their value
- He wanted more religious books printed
- He invented the printing press
Show answer
Answer: B. In Adages (1508) Erasmus expressed deep anxiety that printers were filling the world with harmful books.
-
4. Why was the miller Menocchio executed?
- For printing money
- For supporting Erasmus
- For forming views of God and Creation from his reading that the Roman Catholic Church considered heretical
- For burning books
Show answer
Answer: C. His reinterpretation of the Bible enraged the Church; during the Inquisition he was tried twice and executed.
-
5. Assertion (A): The line between oral and reading cultures blurred after the print revolution. Reason (R): Printed material was read aloud to those who could not read, and oral tales entered print.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is false but R is true
- A is true but R is false
Show answer
Answer: A. Because printed works were heard as well as read, and oral stories were printed (R), the hearing and reading publics intermingled (A).
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.