• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Consistency, conservatism, materiality and objectivity

Apply the consistency, conservatism (prudence), materiality and objectivity concepts to valuation and reporting decisions, with worked examples on stock valuation and small items.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain consistency and when a change in policy is allowed.
  • Apply conservatism: provide for losses, do not anticipate profits, value stock at the lower of cost and market value.
  • Explain materiality and objectivity and link objectivity to historical cost.

The last four concepts guide the accountant's judgement. They decide whether this year's figures can be compared with last year's, how to deal with uncertainty, how much detail small items deserve, and how to keep personal opinion out of the books.

Consistency concept

Statements are useful only if they allow inter-period and inter-firm comparisons. This is possible only when accounting policies and practices are uniform and consistent over time. If a firm used one depreciation or stock valuation method last year and another this year, the two profits would not be comparable. Consistency eliminates personal bias and makes results comparable. It does not prohibit change: a required change in policy is allowed, but it must be fully disclosed with its probable effect on results.

Conservatism (prudence) concept

Conservatism is the policy of playing safe: income is worked out cautiously so that profits are not overstated. Overstated profit could lead to dividends paid out of capital, which reduces the capital of the enterprise. The rule is: do not anticipate profits, but provide for all possible losses, even remote ones. Examples in the book: valuing closing stock at cost or market value, whichever is lower; creating a provision for doubtful debts and for discount on debtors; writing off intangible assets such as goodwill and patents. It reflects a cautious attitude and protects creditors against an unwanted distribution of assets. But a deliberate understatement of assets creates hidden profits called secret reserves, which should be discouraged.

Worked example 1: lower of cost and market value

Illustrative closing stock of Meadow Mills on 31 March:

Meadow Mills: stock at the lower of cost and market value (made-up figures)
ItemCost (₹)Market value (₹)Value taken (₹)Reason
Cotton bales84,00076,00076,000Market below cost: provide for the loss
Dyes30,00037,50030,000Market above cost: gain not yet realised
Thread18,00018,00018,000Equal
Total1,32,0001,31,5001,24,000Item-by-item lower value

Working: take the lower figure for each item: 76,000 + 30,000 + 18,000 = ₹1,24,000. The fall in value of cotton (84,000 − 76,000 = ₹8,000) is provided for now; the rise in dyes (₹7,500) is ignored until the dyes are sold.

Materiality concept

Accounting should focus on material facts; effort should not be wasted on facts immaterial to determining income. A fact is material if its knowledge would reasonably influence the decision of an informed user. Materiality depends on the nature of the item and the amount involved. A change in depreciation method, a large expansion of capacity, or a liability likely to arise soon are material and must be disclosed. When the amount is very small, strict adherence to principles is not required: erasers, pencils and scales are treated as an expense of the year in which they are bought, whether used up or not, instead of being shown as an asset.

Objectivity concept

Transactions should be recorded objectively, free from the bias of accountants and others. This is possible when each transaction is supported by verifiable documents or vouchers: a cash receipt for a cash purchase, an invoice and delivery challan for a credit purchase, a receipt for a machine. One reason for using historical cost is that it can be verified, whereas market value is hard to know until the asset is sold and differs from person to person and place to place.

Judgement concepts side by side

  • Consistency
    • Same methods year after year
    • Change only with disclosure
    • Makes results comparable
  • Conservatism
    • Provide for all losses
    • Ignore unrealised gains
    • Avoid deliberate understatement
  • Materiality
    • Report what would affect decisions
    • Small items treated simply
    • Depends on nature and amount
  • Objectivity
    • Records backed by vouchers
    • Free from personal bias
    • Supports historical cost

Worked example 2: name the concept

Made-up situations at Hilltop Traders: (a) it buys a box of staplers for ₹350 and treats the whole amount as an expense; (b) it expects that ₹12,000 of its debtors may not pay and makes a provision; (c) it has used the same method of depreciation for five years; (d) it records land at the amount shown in the sale deed, not at a valuer's estimate. Working: (a) the amount is too small to influence any decision, so materiality; (b) providing for an expected loss is conservatism; (c) using the same method every year is consistency; (d) a verifiable document rather than an opinion is objectivity.

Consistency: same policies each period, changes disclosed. Conservatism: anticipate no profit, provide for every loss. Materiality: report what would change a decision. Objectivity: record what documents can prove.

Key takeaways: consistency allows comparison and permits disclosed changes. Conservatism values stock at the lower of cost and market value and provides for doubtful debts, but must not create secret reserves. Materiality depends on nature and amount. Objectivity requires vouchers and explains why historical cost is used.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Illustrative closing stock: cost ₹50,000, market value ₹46,000. Under conservatism it is valued at:

    1. ₹46,000
    2. ₹48,000
    3. ₹50,000
    4. ₹96,000
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Stock is valued at cost or market value, whichever is lower: ₹46,000. The expected loss of ₹4,000 is provided for now.

  2. 2. Treating the cost of pencils and erasers as an expense of the year in which they are bought follows the:

    1. consistency concept
    2. materiality concept
    3. dual aspect concept
    4. going concern concept
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The amount is too small to affect users' decisions, so strict treatment as an asset is not needed; this is materiality.

  3. 3. Which statement about the consistency concept is correct?

    1. It forbids any change in accounting policy
    2. It requires a firm to use the same methods as every other firm
    3. It allows a needed change in policy if the change and its effect are disclosed
    4. It applies only to cash transactions
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Consistency does not prohibit change; necessary changes are allowed when they are fully disclosed with their probable effect.

  4. 4. Case: A trader records a newly bought building at what his friend thinks it is worth, though the purchase deed shows a lower price. Which concept is violated?

    1. Materiality
    2. Matching
    3. Accounting period
    4. Objectivity
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Recording must be free from bias and based on verifiable documents. An opinion of value is not verifiable; the deed price is.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Deliberately undervaluing assets is encouraged by conservatism. Reason (R): Conservatism requires that all possible losses be provided for.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A is false: deliberate understatement creates secret reserves and should be discouraged. R is true: conservatism provides for all possible losses.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery