- Foundation
- About 20 min
- 5 practice questions
Errors in the BRS and reconciliation with an amended cash book
Adjust a bank reconciliation statement for errors by the firm or the bank, and use the practical method of first amending the cash book, then reconciling only the timing items.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Decide how errors in the cash book or the passbook affect the reconciliation.
- Prepare a BRS that includes both timing items and errors.
- Amend the cash book for items not yet recorded and reconcile the amended balance with the passbook.
Not every difference is a matter of time. Sometimes the firm or the bank makes a mistake: a wrong amount, an entry in the wrong column, a wrong total, or another customer's transaction posted to our account. The chapter notes that, in practice, the reconciliation is prepared after adjusting the cash book balance. This lesson shows both treatments.
Handling errors
For each error, ask how it has affected the balance of the record in which it was made, compared with what it should be. Then ask: does that make the passbook higher or lower than the cash book? Starting from the cash book, add if the passbook is relatively higher, deduct if it is relatively lower.
| Error (illustrative types) | Effect | Starting from cash book |
|---|---|---|
| Cheque issued recorded at a smaller amount in the cash book | Cash book balance too high | Deduct the difference |
| Cheque issued recorded at a larger amount in the cash book | Cash book balance too low | Add the difference |
| Receipts side of bank column overcast (total too high) | Cash book balance too high | Deduct |
| Payments side of bank column undercast (total too low) | Cash book balance too high | Deduct |
| Bank receipt entered in cash column instead of bank column | Bank column too low | Add |
| Outgoing cheque recorded twice in cash book | Cash book balance too low | Add |
| Bank wrongly debits our account | Passbook too low | Deduct |
| Bank wrongly credits our account | Passbook too high | Add |
Worked example 1: a BRS with errors
All names and figures are made up. On 30 April Ivory Prints' cash book shows a debit bank balance of ₹28,600. Differences found: (a) a cheque of ₹4,750 issued was recorded as ₹4,570; (b) a cheque of ₹2,300 received and deposited was entered in the cash column instead of the bank column; (c) the receipts side of the bank column was overcast by ₹500; (d) the bank debited the firm with another customer's cheque of ₹1,200; (e) the bank credited the firm with another customer's deposit of ₹800.
| No. | Particulars | Plus (₹) | Minus (₹) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Balance as per cash book (debit) | 28,600 | |
| 2 | Cheque received, entered in cash column instead of bank column, but deposited | 2,300 | |
| 3 | Another customer's deposit wrongly credited to our account by the bank | 800 | |
| 4 | Cheque of 4,750 issued, recorded as 4,570 in cash book | 180 | |
| 5 | Receipts side of bank column overcast | 500 | |
| 6 | Cheque of another customer wrongly debited by the bank | 1,200 | |
| 7 | Balance as per passbook (credit) | 29,820 | |
| Total | 31,700 | 31,700 |
Working: (a) only ₹4,570 was deducted instead of ₹4,750, so the cash book is ₹180 too high: deduct. (b) the bank has the ₹2,300 but the bank column does not: add. (c) overcasting made the cash book ₹500 too high: deduct. (d) the passbook is ₹1,200 too low: deduct. (e) the passbook is ₹800 too high: add. Passbook = 28,600 + 2,300 + 800 − 180 − 500 − 1,200 = ₹29,820.
The amended cash book method
Reconciling with an amended cash book
- Compare cash book and statement List every item of difference
- Amend the cash book Record items known only to the bank (charges, interest, dividends, direct deposits, dishonours, standing payments) and correct the firm's own errors
- Find the correct cash book balance This is the figure for the balance sheet
- Prepare the BRS Start from the amended balance; only unpresented and uncollected cheques and bank errors remain
This method gives the correct bank balance for the financial statements, because items the bank has rightly recorded are brought into the firm's books, and only genuine timing differences (and bank errors) remain in the statement.
Worked example 2: Jasmine Foods
All names and figures are made up. On 30 September the bank column of Jasmine Foods' cash book shows a debit balance of ₹52,000. The statement shows: cheques of ₹14,000 issued not presented; cheques of ₹9,500 deposited not collected; bank charges ₹300; interest credited ₹700; dividend collected ₹2,800; a cheque of ₹3,600 from Prem Sons dishonoured; insurance premium ₹2,100 paid by the bank. Only the first two are timing items the firm has already recorded; the rest must be entered in the cash book.
| Date | Particulars (Dr) | J.F. | Amount (₹) | Date | Particulars (Cr) | J.F. | Amount (₹) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 30 | Balance b/d | 52,000 | Sep 30 | Bank Charges | 300 | ||
| Sep 30 | Interest | 700 | Sep 30 | Prem Sons (dishonoured cheque) | 3,600 | ||
| Sep 30 | Dividend | 2,800 | Sep 30 | Insurance Premium | 2,100 | ||
| Sep 30 | Balance c/d | 49,500 | |||||
| Total | 55,500 | Total | 55,500 |
Amended balance = (52,000 + 700 + 2,800) − (300 + 3,600 + 2,100) = 55,500 − 6,000 = ₹49,500.
| No. | Particulars | Plus (₹) | Minus (₹) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Amended balance as per cash book (debit) | 49,500 | |
| 2 | Cheques issued but not presented for payment | 14,000 | |
| 3 | Cheques deposited but not yet collected | 9,500 | |
| 4 | Balance as per passbook (credit) | 54,000 | |
| Total | 63,500 | 63,500 |
Working: 49,500 + 14,000 − 9,500 = ₹54,000 as per passbook. Check against a single statement from the original balance: 52,000 + 14,000 + 700 + 2,800 − 9,500 − 300 − 3,600 − 2,100 = ₹54,000. Both methods agree.
Amend first, reconcile second: put into the cash book everything the bank has correctly recorded and correct the firm's own errors; then reconcile the amended balance using only unpresented and uncollected cheques and any bank errors.
Key takeaways: treat each error by its effect on the balance of the record where it occurred. In practice the cash book is amended first for items known only to the bank and for the firm's errors, giving the correct bank balance; the BRS then explains the remaining timing items and bank errors.
Check your understanding
-
1. Starting from the cash book balance, a cheque of ₹2,600 issued but recorded in the cash book as ₹2,060 is treated as:
- add ₹540
- deduct ₹540
- add ₹2,600
- deduct ₹2,060
Show answer
Answer: B. Only ₹2,060 was deducted instead of ₹2,600, so the cash book balance is ₹540 too high; deduct ₹540 to reach the passbook.
-
2. The bank wrongly credited the firm's account with ₹1,500 belonging to another customer. Starting from the cash book:
- ignore it
- deduct ₹1,500
- add ₹1,500
- deduct ₹3,000
Show answer
Answer: C. The passbook is ₹1,500 higher than it should be relative to the cash book, so add ₹1,500 when moving from the cash book to the passbook.
-
3. Illustrative: cash book balance ₹40,000; bank charges ₹250 and interest credited ₹900 are not in the cash book. The amended cash book balance is:
- ₹40,000
- ₹39,350
- ₹41,150
- ₹40,650
Show answer
Answer: D. Amended balance = 40,000 + 900 − 250 = ₹40,650.
-
4. Case: After amending the cash book, which item still appears in the bank reconciliation statement?
- Bank charges
- Dividend collected by the bank
- Cheques issued but not yet presented
- Insurance premium paid on standing instructions
Show answer
Answer: C. Bank-only items are entered in the amended cash book. Cheques issued but not presented are already in the cash book and remain a timing difference for the BRS.
-
5. Assertion (A): The amended cash book balance is the bank balance shown in the balance sheet. Reason (R): It includes all items correctly recorded by the bank and corrects the firm's own errors.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: once bank-only items and the firm's errors are adjusted, the cash book shows the correct bank balance of the firm.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.