• Foundation
  • About 20 min
  • 5 practice questions

Straight line and written down value methods

Find the depreciable cost from cost, residual value and useful life, calculate depreciation and its rate by the straight line and written down value methods, and compare the two.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Calculate cost, net residual value and depreciable cost of an asset.
  • Compute annual depreciation and rate under the straight line method, and depreciation under the written down value method.
  • Compare the two methods and choose the suitable one for an asset.

How much to charge each year depends on three things: the asset's cost, its estimated net residual value and its estimated useful life. How the charge is spread depends on the method. The book treats the two methods used in India, straight line and written down value, and names others (annuity, depreciation fund, insurance policy, sum of years' digits, double declining) without detail.

Factors affecting the amount

  • Cost (original or historical cost): invoice price plus everything needed to put the asset in working condition: freight, transit insurance, installation, registration, commission on purchase, and for a second-hand asset the initial repairs.
  • Net residual value (scrap or salvage value): expected sale value at the end of useful life, less disposal expenses.
  • Depreciable cost: cost − net residual value. The total depreciation over the life must equal it.
  • Estimated useful life: the economic or commercial life, usually shorter than physical life; it may be stated in years, units of output or working hours, and depends on legal limits (such as a lease period), shifts worked, maintenance, technological change and production methods.

Straight line method (fixed instalment method)

It assumes equal use of the asset each year, so a fixed, equal amount is charged every year; plotted against time, the charge is a straight line.

Straight line: Annual depreciation = (Cost − Net residual value) ÷ Useful life. Rate of depreciation = Annual depreciation ÷ Cost × 100.

Worked example 1: straight line

Illustrative: Rangoli Packaging (made up) buys a machine for ₹3,60,000, spends ₹40,000 on transport and installation, expects to use it 8 years and to sell it then for ₹45,000 with disposal costs of ₹5,000. Working: cost = 3,60,000 + 40,000 = ₹4,00,000. Net residual value = 45,000 − 5,000 = ₹40,000. Depreciable cost = ₹3,60,000. Annual depreciation = 3,60,000 ÷ 8 = ₹45,000. Rate = 45,000 ÷ 4,00,000 × 100 = 11.25%. After 8 years: 8 × 45,000 = 3,60,000, leaving the book value at ₹40,000, the residual value.

  • Advantages: simple to understand and apply; the asset can be written down to its scrap value or zero; the equal charge makes profits of different years comparable; suits assets whose life can be estimated accurately and whose use is steady, such as leasehold buildings.
  • Limitations: assumes equal usefulness every year; as repairs rise in later years, the total of depreciation and repairs keeps rising.

Written down value method (reducing balance method)

A fixed percentage is applied each year to the book value at the beginning of the year (cost less depreciation to date). The charge is highest in the first year and falls every year. The book gives a formula for the rate, R = (1 − nth root of s/c) × 100, where n is useful life, s scrap value and c cost.

Worked example 2: written down value

Illustrative: a printing press costs ₹2,50,000; depreciation 20% a year on written down value.

Written down value schedule (illustrative)
YearOpening book value (₹)Depreciation at 20% (₹)Closing book value (₹)
Year 12,50,00050,0002,00,000
Year 22,00,00040,0001,60,000
Year 31,60,00032,0001,28,000

Working: Year 1: 20% × 2,50,000 = 50,000; Year 2: 20% × 2,00,000 = 40,000; Year 3: 20% × 1,60,000 = 32,000. The value never reaches zero.

  • Advantages: realistic, since benefits fall as the asset ages; depreciation plus repairs stays roughly equal each year; accepted by income tax law; reduces loss from obsolescence because more is written off early; suits long-lived assets with rising repairs or high obsolescence.
  • Limitations: the depreciable cost can never be fully written off; a suitable rate is hard to find.

Comparing the two

Suppose repairs on the same press are ₹5,000, ₹12,000 and ₹20,000 in years 1 to 3 (made up), and compare straight line at 20% of cost (₹50,000 a year) with the written down value charges above.

Total charge to profit and loss under each method (illustrative)
YearSLM depreciation (₹)Repairs (₹)SLM total charge (₹)WDV depreciation (₹)WDV total charge (₹)
Year 150,0005,00055,00050,00055,000
Year 250,00012,00062,00040,00052,000
Year 350,00020,00070,00032,00052,000

Straight line versus written down value

  • Straight line
    • Charged on original cost
    • Same amount every year
    • Depreciation + repairs rises in later years
    • Not recognised by income tax law (as the book states)
    • Suits land and buildings, patents, trademarks
  • Written down value
    • Charged on book value at start of year
    • Amount falls every year
    • Depreciation + repairs roughly equal
    • Recognised by income tax law (as the book states)
    • Suits plant, machinery, vehicles

AS-6, as quoted in the book, requires the chosen method to be applied consistently from period to period; a change is allowed only in specific circumstances. The choice depends on the type of asset, the nature of its use and the circumstances of the business.

Key takeaways: depreciable cost = cost − net residual value. Straight line charges (cost − residual) ÷ life every year; rate = annual depreciation ÷ cost × 100. Written down value charges a fixed percentage of the opening book value, so the charge falls each year. SLM gives rising total charges with repairs; WDV keeps them roughly level.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Illustrative: cost ₹1,20,000, net residual value ₹12,000, useful life 9 years. Annual depreciation by the straight line method is:

    1. ₹13,333
    2. ₹10,800
    3. ₹14,667
    4. ₹12,000
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Annual depreciation = (1,20,000 − 12,000) ÷ 9 = 1,08,000 ÷ 9 = ₹12,000.

  2. 2. Continuing the same figures, the rate of depreciation as the book calculates it is:

    1. 9%
    2. 12%
    3. 11.11%
    4. 10%
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Rate = annual depreciation ÷ cost × 100 = 12,000 ÷ 1,20,000 × 100 = 10%.

  3. 3. Illustrative: a van costs ₹4,00,000; depreciation 15% on written down value. Depreciation for year 2 is:

    1. ₹60,000
    2. ₹45,000
    3. ₹51,000
    4. ₹3,40,000
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Year 1: 15% × 4,00,000 = 60,000, leaving 3,40,000. Year 2: 15% × 3,40,000 = ₹51,000.

  4. 4. Case: A transport firm's trucks need more repairs every year and lose value quickly to newer models. The firm wants an even yearly burden of depreciation plus repairs. Which method suits it?

    1. Straight line method
    2. Charging all cost in year one
    3. No depreciation
    4. Written down value method
    Show answer

    Answer: D. WDV charges more in early years and less later, so falling depreciation offsets rising repairs; it also suits assets with high obsolescence.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Under the written down value method, an asset's book value never becomes zero. Reason (R): Depreciation is a fixed percentage of a reducing balance.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: a percentage of a positive balance always leaves something, so the full cost is never written off.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery