• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

From two kingdoms to five: how classification changed

Trace classification from Aristotle and the two-kingdom system to Whittaker's five kingdoms, state Whittaker's criteria and compare the five kingdoms on cell type, wall, body organisation and nutrition.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe Aristotle's classification and the two-kingdom system of Linnaeus' time.
  • Explain why the two-kingdom system proved inadequate.
  • State the five kingdoms of Whittaker (1969) and his criteria for classification.
  • Compare the five kingdoms using a table of characters.

People have sorted living things for as long as there have been people, but early sorting was driven by need: what can we eat, wear or build with? This lesson follows how biologists moved from such practical grouping to systems built on cell structure, nutrition and evolutionary relationships, and why the system keeps being revised.

Early attempts

Aristotle made the earliest attempt at a more scientific basis. He used simple morphological (form and structure) characters: plants were divided into trees, shrubs and herbs, and animals into those with red blood and those without. Much later, in Linnaeus' time, a two-kingdom system placed every organism in either Plantae or Animalia.

Why two kingdoms were not enough

The two-kingdom system was simple, but it failed to separate several fundamentally different kinds of organisms. It did not distinguish prokaryotes from eukaryotes, unicellular from multicellular organisms, or photosynthetic organisms (such as green algae) from non-photosynthetic ones (such as fungi). Many organisms did not fit either kingdom. Earlier systems put bacteria, blue-green algae, fungi, mosses, ferns, gymnosperms and angiosperms all under plants, because all have a cell wall. That single shared feature lumped together prokaryotic bacteria and cyanobacteria with eukaryotes, unicellular Chlamydomonas with multicellular Spirogyra, and heterotrophic fungi (walls of chitin) with autotrophic green plants (walls of cellulose). Biologists realised that besides gross morphology they must use cell structure, nature of the wall, mode of nutrition, habitat, reproduction and evolutionary relationships.

Whittaker's five kingdoms

R.H. Whittaker (1969) proposed the five-kingdom classification: Monera, Protista, Fungi, Plantae and Animalia. His main criteria were cell structure, body organisation, mode of nutrition, reproduction and phylogenetic (evolutionary) relationships. In this system all prokaryotes went to Monera, unicellular eukaryotes to Protista, and fungi got a kingdom of their own. Protista thus brought together Chlamydomonas and Chlorella (earlier algae among plants, with cell walls) and Paramoecium and Amoeba (earlier animals, without walls). Organisms that were once in different kingdoms now sat together because the criteria changed.

Whittaker's five kingdoms

  • Monera
    • Prokaryotic
    • Bacteria
  • Protista
    • Unicellular eukaryotes
  • Fungi
    • Heterotrophic, walls of chitin
  • Plantae
    • Photosynthetic, walls of cellulose
  • Animalia
    • Multicellular heterotrophs, no cell wall
Characteristics of the five kingdoms
CharacterMoneraProtistaFungiPlantaeAnimalia
Cell typeProkaryoticEukaryoticEukaryoticEukaryoticEukaryotic
Cell wallNon-cellulosic (polysaccharide + amino acid)Present in somePresent, with chitinPresent (cellulose)Absent
Nuclear membraneAbsentPresentPresentPresentPresent
Body organisationCellularCellularMulticellular or loose tissueTissue or organTissue, organ or organ system
Mode of nutritionAutotrophic (chemosynthetic and photosynthetic) and heterotrophic (saprophytic or parasitic)Autotrophic (photosynthetic) and heterotrophicHeterotrophic (saprophytic or parasitic)Autotrophic (photosynthetic)Heterotrophic (holozoic, saprophytic etc.)

A three-domain system has also been proposed. It splits Monera into two domains and places all eukaryotic kingdoms in the third, giving in effect a six-kingdom classification. You will study it in higher classes. The broader lesson is that classification will keep changing as our understanding of characters and evolutionary relationships improves. The aim is a system that is not only morphological, physiological and reproductive, but also phylogenetic.

Worked reasoning example 1: placing a mystery organism

A single-celled organism has a nucleus bounded by a membrane, chloroplasts and a cell wall. In which kingdom does Whittaker's system place it? Reasoning: (1) A membrane-bound nucleus means it is eukaryotic, so not Monera. (2) It is single-celled, and all unicellular eukaryotes go to Protista. (3) Its chloroplasts and wall do not move it to Plantae, because Plantae members are multicellular with tissues. Answer: Protista, as with Chlamydomonas.

Worked reasoning example 2: why fungi left the plant kingdom

Give two characters that justify a separate kingdom for fungi. Reasoning from the table: (1) Nutrition: fungi are heterotrophic (saprophytic or parasitic) while plants are photosynthetic autotrophs. (2) Wall: fungal walls contain chitin while plant walls are mainly cellulose. Conclusion: once nutrition and wall chemistry were used as criteria, fungi could no longer stay with plants.

Whittaker (1969): Monera, Protista, Fungi, Plantae, Animalia. Criteria: cell structure, body organisation, nutrition, reproduction, phylogeny.

Key takeaways: Aristotle used simple morphology; the two-kingdom system could not separate prokaryotes from eukaryotes, unicellular from multicellular, or fungi from green plants. Whittaker's five kingdoms used cell structure, body organisation, nutrition, reproduction and phylogeny, and classification keeps evolving as knowledge grows.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Aristotle classified plants into:

    1. trees, shrubs and herbs
    2. algae, fungi and bacteria
    3. monocots and dicots
    4. Monera and Protista
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Aristotle used simple morphological characters and grouped plants into trees, shrubs and herbs. He divided animals into those with red blood and those without.

  2. 2. Which of the following was NOT one of Whittaker's main criteria?

    1. Cell structure
    2. Mode of nutrition
    3. Size of the organism's habitat
    4. Phylogenetic relationships
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Whittaker's main criteria were cell structure, body organisation, mode of nutrition, reproduction and phylogenetic relationships. The size of the habitat is not one of them.

  3. 3. In the five-kingdom system, Chlamydomonas and Amoeba are placed together in:

    1. Plantae
    2. Monera
    3. Animalia
    4. Protista
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Both are single-celled eukaryotes, and Whittaker placed all unicellular eukaryotes in Protista, even though Chlamydomonas has a wall and was earlier counted among algae while Amoeba was counted among animals.

  4. 4. Which kingdom has cells without a nuclear membrane?

    1. Protista
    2. Monera
    3. Fungi
    4. Plantae
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Monera contains the prokaryotes (bacteria), whose cells lack a nuclear membrane. All the other four kingdoms are eukaryotic.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): The two-kingdom classification was found inadequate. Reason (R): It placed prokaryotic and eukaryotic, and photosynthetic and non-photosynthetic, organisms in the same kingdom.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true. Grouping bacteria with plants, and fungi with green plants, ignored fundamental differences in cell type and nutrition. That failure is exactly why the system was inadequate, so R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery