- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Cooperative stores, supermarkets, vending machines, GST and chambers of commerce
Explain consumer cooperative stores, supermarkets and vending machines, outline the Goods and Services Tax as the textbook describes it, and explain how chambers of commerce and industry promote internal trade.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain consumer cooperative stores and supermarkets with their merits and limitations.
- Explain the main features of GST as described in the textbook, including input tax credit.
- Explain the role of chambers of commerce and industry in promoting internal trade.
Three more forms of retailing complete the picture, followed by two forces that shape internal trade as a whole: the Goods and Services Tax and the associations of business and industry.
Consumer cooperative stores
A consumer cooperative store is owned, managed and controlled by consumers to cut out middlemen. It buys in bulk directly from manufacturers or wholesalers and sells at reasonable prices; profits go as bonus to members and to reserves and welfare funds. At least 10 people form a voluntary association registered under the Cooperative Societies Act; capital comes from shares; management is democratic (one man, one vote); liability is limited; accounts are audited by the Registrar of Cooperative Societies or a person authorised by the Registrar.
Consumer cooperative stores
-
Advantages
- Easy formation
- Limited liability
- Democratic management
- Lower prices: no middlemen
- Cash sales: less working capital
- Convenient location
-
Limitations
- Lack of initiative: honorary managers
- Shortage of funds: limited membership
- Lack of patronage by members
- Lack of business training
Supermarkets
A supermarket is a large retail unit selling a wide variety of mainly food and low-priced branded goods on the basis of low price, wide variety, self-service and merchandising appeal. Goods sit on racks with clear price tags; customers pick, pay at the cash counter and carry them home. It is organised by departments but, unlike a departmental store, gives no free home delivery or credit and has no salespeople to persuade. Advantages: one roof and low cost, central location, wide selection, no bad debts, large-scale benefits. Limitations: no credit, no personal attention, mishandling of goods by customers, high overheads that weaken the low-price appeal, and huge capital needs that suit big towns rather than small ones.
Vending machines sell pre-packed, low-priced, high-turnover goods of uniform size, such as beverages, platform tickets or chocolates; the ATM applies the idea to banking. Their installation and maintenance costs are high, buyers cannot see the product or return it, and special packs are needed, but the textbook sees a promising future for them.
Goods and Services Tax (GST)
Following the idea of 'One Nation, One Tax', India implemented GST from 1 July 2017 to create a unified national market. As the textbook explains, GST is a destination-based single tax on the supply of goods and services from manufacturer to consumer; it replaced many central and state indirect taxes (the book counts 17 taxes and 23 cesses). It has two parts on supplies within a state, CGST (central) and SGST (state), while IGST applies to inter-state supplies and imports. Tax is charged at each stage of value addition, but each supplier sets off the tax already paid on inputs through input tax credit, so tax is not charged on tax (no cascading effect); the final consumer bears the tax. Rates are recommended by the GST Council of the Centre and the States. The book expects GST to ease compliance, reduce tax evasion, widen the organised sector, give consumers wider choice and create a harmonised national market.
GST: one destination-based tax on supply; CGST plus SGST within a state, IGST across states; input tax credit at every stage removes tax on tax.
Chambers of commerce and industry
Associations of business and industry, which the textbook names as ASSOCHAM, CII and FICCI, act as national guardians of trade and industry. They interact with the government to remove hindrances, ease inter-state movement of goods, bring transparency and cut bureaucratic hurdles. The book lists their interventions in: inter-state movement of goods (vehicle registration, transport policy, highways); octroi and local levies; harmonisation of sales tax and VAT; marketing of agro products; weights and measures and prevention of duplicate brands; excise duty; sound infrastructure; and labour legislation.
Worked example 1: input tax credit
Illustrative (assume a made-up uniform GST rate of 10% only for arithmetic): a manufacturer sells goods for ₹1,000 to a wholesaler, who sells them for ₹1,300 to a retailer, who sells them for ₹1,500 to a consumer. Working: manufacturer collects 10% of 1,000 = ₹100 and pays it. Wholesaler collects 10% of 1,300 = ₹130, takes credit of ₹100, pays ₹30. Retailer collects 10% of 1,500 = ₹150, takes credit of ₹130, pays ₹20. Total paid to government = 100 + 30 + 20 = ₹150, which equals 10% of the final price of ₹1,500. Each stage pays tax only on its own value addition, so there is no tax on tax.
Worked example 2: choose the retail form
Which form suits each (made-up) need? (a) A group of 40 employees in a township want quality groceries at fair prices and are willing to run the shop democratically; (b) a busy family wants to pick packaged foods, utensils and toiletries themselves at low prices in one visit; (c) a railway station wants to sell platform tickets round the clock without staff. Answer: (a) consumer cooperative store; (b) supermarket; (c) vending machine.
Key takeaways: consumer cooperative stores are democratic, limited-liability stores that cut out middlemen but lack funds, initiative and training; supermarkets offer low prices, variety and self-service without credit or personal attention; vending machines suit low-priced, uniform, fast-moving goods; GST, from 1 July 2017, is a destination-based tax with CGST, SGST and IGST and input tax credit that removes cascading; chambers of commerce such as ASSOCHAM, CII and FICCI promote internal trade by working with government on taxes, transport, infrastructure and laws.
Check your understanding
-
1. The minimum number of people needed to form a consumer cooperative store, according to the textbook, is:
- 2
- 7
- 10
- 20
Show answer
Answer: C. At least 10 people must come together and get the store registered under the Cooperative Societies Act.
-
2. Which is NOT a feature of a supermarket?
- Self-service
- Free home delivery and credit
- Cash sales
- Goods on racks with price tags
Show answer
Answer: B. Unlike departmental stores, supermarkets do not offer free home delivery or credit; they rely on self-service and cash sales.
-
3. GST on a supply of goods from one state to another is charged as:
- IGST
- CGST only
- SGST only
- octroi
Show answer
Answer: A. IGST is payable on inter-state supplies; CGST and SGST apply to supplies within a state.
-
4. Illustrative (assumed 10% GST): goods pass through stages priced ₹2,000, ₹2,400 and ₹3,000. With input tax credit, how much does the retailer (last stage) pay to the government?
- ₹300
- ₹240
- ₹200
- ₹60
Show answer
Answer: D. Retailer collects 10% of 3,000 = ₹300, takes credit of 10% of 2,400 = ₹240, and pays 300 - 240 = ₹60.
-
5. Assertion (A): GST avoids the cascading effect. Reason (R): Input tax credit lets each supplier set off tax paid on inputs at earlier stages.
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
- Both A and R are false
- Both A and R are true and R explains A
Show answer
Answer: D. Because tax already paid is credited at each stage, no stage pays tax on tax. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.