- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Private sector, public sector and departmental undertakings
Explain India's mixed economy, the private and public sectors and the industrial policies of 1948, 1956 and 1991, and study the departmental undertaking: features, merits and limitations.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Distinguish the private sector from the public sector in a mixed economy.
- Name the three forms of public enterprise.
- Explain the features, merits and limitations of departmental undertakings.
In any Indian town you will find a sole trader's shop, a partnership of doctors, a company-run supermarket, a railway station run by the government and perhaps a showroom of a foreign brand. Businesses owned privately, by the government and by enterprises spread across many countries all operate side by side. This chapter explains each kind.
Private sector and public sector
India has a mixed economy, in which both privately owned and government-owned enterprises are allowed to operate. The private sector consists of businesses owned by individuals or groups: sole proprietorship, partnership, joint Hindu family business, cooperative and company. The public sector consists of organisations owned and managed by the central or a state government, partly or wholly; they may be part of a ministry or created by a Special Act of Parliament.
The Indian economy
-
Public sector
- Departmental undertakings
- Statutory corporations
- Government companies
-
Private sector
- Sole proprietorship
- Partnership
- Joint Hindu family business
- Cooperative society
- Company (private or public)
-
Global enterprises
- Multinational corporations operating in many countries
Industrial policies, as the textbook outlines them
- Industrial Policy Resolution, 1948: set out the approach to industrial development and defined the roles of the private and public sectors.
- Industrial Policy Resolution, 1956: laid down objectives for the public sector to speed up growth and industrialisation, gave it great importance, but stressed the mutual dependence of the two sectors.
- Industrial policy, 1991: radically different: disinvestment in the public sector, more freedom for the private sector and an invitation to foreign direct investment, which brought multinational corporations into India.
Forms of public enterprise
Public enterprises are owned by the public and accountable to the public through Parliament. They are marked by public ownership, use of public funds and public accountability. Depending on the nature of operations and relationship with the government, a public enterprise may take one of three forms: departmental undertaking, statutory corporation or government company.
Departmental undertakings
This is the oldest and most traditional form. The enterprise is set up as a department of a ministry and is treated as part or an extension of it; it is not an independent legal entity. The textbook's examples are the railways and the post and telegraph department.
- Funded directly from the Government Treasury by annual appropriation from the budget; revenue is paid back into the treasury.
- Subject to the same accounting and audit controls as other government activities.
- Employees are government servants, headed by IAS officers and civil servants transferable between ministries.
- A major subdivision of a government department under direct control of the ministry, and accountable to it.
Departmental undertakings
-
Merits
- Effective parliamentary control
- High degree of public accountability
- Revenue goes directly to the treasury
- Most suitable where national security is concerned
-
Limitations
- Lack of flexibility
- Delays: no independent decisions without ministry approval
- Over-cautious bureaucrats miss business opportunities
- Red tape
- Political interference
- Insensitive to consumer needs
A departmental undertaking is a public enterprise run as a department of a ministry: financed by the budget, audited like the government, staffed by civil servants and directly controlled by the minister.
Worked example 1: which sector?
Classify (made-up names): (a) Lakshmi Textiles, a partnership; (b) a city water department run by a state ministry; (c) a cooperative milk union; (d) a company owned by investors in five countries with branches in India. Answer: (a) private sector; (b) public sector, departmental undertaking; (c) private sector, cooperative; (d) global enterprise.
Worked example 2: matching form to need
A government plans a new unit to make sensitive defence equipment, where secrecy and tight control matter more than speed. Reasoning: a departmental undertaking keeps the unit under direct control and supervision of the ministry, which the textbook says makes it most suitable where national security is concerned. Its slowness and lack of flexibility matter less here than control.
Key takeaways: India is a mixed economy with private, public and global enterprises; the 1991 policy opened the economy to disinvestment, private freedom and foreign investment; public enterprises take three forms; the departmental undertaking is the oldest form, budget-financed, civil-servant run and directly controlled by a ministry, accountable but inflexible.
Check your understanding
-
1. The oldest and most traditional form of organising a public enterprise is the:
- government company
- statutory corporation
- departmental undertaking
- joint venture
Show answer
Answer: C. The departmental undertaking is established as a department of the ministry and is the oldest form.
-
2. The revenue of a departmental undertaking is:
- paid into the Government Treasury
- kept by the undertaking
- distributed to employees
- paid to shareholders
Show answer
Answer: A. Departmental undertakings are financed by annual appropriation from the budget, and their revenue is paid back into the treasury.
-
3. Which industrial policy invited foreign direct investment and allowed greater freedom to the private sector, as described in the textbook?
- 1948
- 1956
- 1991
- 1951
Show answer
Answer: C. The 1991 policy was radically different: it moved towards disinvestment, gave more freedom to the private sector and invited foreign direct investment.
-
4. Assertion (A): Departmental undertakings often miss business opportunities. Reason (R): The over-cautious approach of bureaucrats does not allow risky ventures.
- A is true but R is false
- Both A and R are true and R explains A
- A is false but R is true
- Both A and R are false
Show answer
Answer: B. Civil servants heading these units tend to be conservative and need ministry approval, so risky opportunities are passed up. R explains A.
-
5. Case: The made-up state of Teststate runs its bus service as a wing of its Transport Ministry, staffed by government servants and funded from the state budget. Which limitation is it most likely to face?
- Shareholders' interference
- Lack of public accountability
- Delays because decisions need ministry approval
- Inability to raise funds from the treasury
Show answer
Answer: C. Departmental undertakings cannot take independent decisions without the ministry, causing delays and red tape; they are, if anything, highly accountable.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.