Revision notes

Chapter 3 Private, Public and Global Enterprises: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Private sector, public sector and departmental undertakings

The Indian economy

  • Public sector
    • Departmental undertakings
    • Statutory corporations
    • Government companies
  • Private sector
    • Sole proprietorship
    • Partnership
    • Joint Hindu family business
    • Cooperative society
    • Company (private or public)
  • Global enterprises
    • Multinational corporations operating in many countries

Departmental undertakings

  • Merits
    • Effective parliamentary control
    • High degree of public accountability
    • Revenue goes directly to the treasury
    • Most suitable where national security is concerned
  • Limitations
    • Lack of flexibility
    • Delays: no independent decisions without ministry approval
    • Over-cautious bureaucrats miss business opportunities
    • Red tape
    • Political interference
    • Insensitive to consumer needs

A departmental undertaking is a public enterprise run as a department of a ministry: financed by the budget, audited like the government, staffed by civil servants and directly controlled by the minister.

Key takeaways: India is a mixed economy with private, public and global enterprises; the 1991 policy opened the economy to disinvestment, private freedom and foreign investment; public enterprises take three forms; the departmental undertaking is the oldest form, budget-financed, civil-servant run and directly controlled by a ministry, accountable but inflexible.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Statutory corporations and government companies

Statutory corporations

  • Merits
    • Independence and operational flexibility
    • Little government interference in financial matters
    • Frames its own policies within the Act
    • Power of government with initiative of private enterprise
  • Limitations
    • Flexibility less in practice; many rules
    • Government and political interference in major decisions
    • Corruption where dealing with the public
    • Government-appointed advisors curb freedom and cause delay

Government company: a company under the Companies Act in which the central and/or state governments hold at least 51 per cent of the paid-up capital, including subsidiaries of such a company.

Government companies
MeritsLimitations
Formed by meeting Companies Act requirements; no separate Act of Parliament neededWhere government is the only shareholder, Companies Act provisions have little relevance
Separate legal entity from the governmentEvades constitutional responsibility; not directly answerable to Parliament
Autonomy in management decisions based on business prudenceManagement rests with the government as sole shareholder, defeating the purpose of the company form
Can control the market and curb unhealthy practices by selling at reasonable prices-
The three forms compared (drawn from the chapter)
BasisDepartmental undertakingStatutory corporationGovernment company
Created byMinistry decision, as a departmentSpecial Act of ParliamentRegistration under the Companies Act
Legal entityNot separateBody corporateSeparate legal entity
FinanceGovernment budgetIndependently financedGovernment and private shareholders; capital market
EmployeesGovernment servantsAs per its Act; not civil servantsAs per its Memorandum and Articles
AuditLike other government activitiesNot government audit proceduresAuditor appointed by Central Government

Key takeaways: a statutory corporation is created by a Special Act, wholly state-owned, financially independent and flexible in theory; a government company is registered under the Companies Act, 2013 with at least 51 per cent of paid-up capital held by governments, has a separate legal entity and autonomy, but may in practice be run like a department and is not directly answerable to Parliament.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Changing role of the public sector

Roles of the public sector after Independence

  • Development of infrastructure Transport, communication, fuel, energy, basic and heavy industries
  • Regional balance Locating enterprises in backward areas
  • Economies of scale Large units such as power plants, natural gas, petroleum, telephones
  • Check over concentration of economic power Benefits shared by many employees, not a few industrial houses
  • Import substitution Heavy engineering for self-reliance; export promotion

Since 1991 the public sector is expected to compete, not merely to be protected: fewer reserved areas, disinvestment, the same treatment of sick units as private ones, and MoUs that trade autonomy for accountability.

Key takeaways: after Independence the public sector built infrastructure, promoted regional balance, captured economies of scale, checked concentration of economic power and substituted imports; since 1991 reserved areas shrank from 17 to 8 and then 3, selected PSUs were disinvested, sick PSUs went to BIFR with a National Renewal Fund for workers, and MoUs gave autonomy in return for accountability.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Global enterprises (multinational corporations)

A global enterprise is a giant corporation, headquartered in its home country, that produces and markets many products through branches, subsidiaries and affiliates in several countries.

Features of a global enterprise

  • Finance
    • Huge capital resources
    • Credibility in capital markets
  • Technology
    • Advanced technology
    • Product innovation through R&D
  • Market
    • Aggressive marketing strategies
    • Expansion of market territory
  • Organisation
    • Foreign collaboration with local firms
    • Centralised policy control from home country
How global enterprises differ (general comparison based on the chapter)
BasisDomestic private companyGlobal enterprise
Area of operationMainly one countrySeveral countries through branches and subsidiaries
Sources of fundsMainly home marketMany countries; international banks and capital markets
Research and developmentOften limitedSophisticated R&D departments
ControlWithin the countryPolicy from headquarters in home country

Key takeaways: global enterprises are giant corporations operating through networks in many countries; their features are huge capital, foreign collaboration, advanced technology, product innovation, effective marketing, expansion of market territory and centralised policy control from the home country; collaboration brings resources and technology but can bring restrictive clauses and concentration of power.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Joint ventures and public private partnership

A joint venture is the pooling of resources and expertise by two or more businesses to achieve a particular goal, with risks and rewards shared.

Types of joint venture

  • Contractual joint venture
    • No new jointly owned entity is created
    • Only an agreement to work together
    • Parties do not share ownership but exercise some control
    • Each brings inputs; relationship is long-term
    • Example in the book: a franchisee relationship
  • Equity-based joint venture
    • A separate entity jointly owned by the parties, or one party joins ownership of an existing entity
    • Shared ownership and management
    • Shared capital investment and financing
    • Profits and losses shared as agreed
    • Entity may be a company, partnership, trust, LLP and so on
BenefitExplanation
Increased resources and capacityPooled financial and human resources help the venture grow faster and face market challenges
Access to new markets and distribution networksA foreign partner gains the Indian market and its established retail outlets instead of building its own
Access to technologyAdvanced techniques save the time and cost of developing one's own technology and reduce costs
InnovationEspecially foreign partners bring new ideas and products for demanding markets
Low cost of productionInternational partners gain from India's lower raw material and labour costs and skilled professionals
Established brand nameOne party uses the other's goodwill and distribution, saving the cost of building a brand

A design-and-build PPP project (model from the book)

  1. Need identified Government entity decides a public facility is needed
  2. Contract Private party contracted to design and build it
  3. Public finance and ownership Facility financed and owned by the public sector
  4. Risk transfer Design and construction risk carried by the private party
  5. Operation Public sector keeps operating responsibility

Key takeaways: a joint venture pools resources and expertise, sharing risks and rewards; a contractual JV creates no new entity, an equity JV creates or shares ownership of one; benefits include resources, markets, technology, innovation, low cost and an established brand; PPP divides tasks and risks between government and private partners, with government ensuring social obligations and private partners bringing efficiency.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery