- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Arguments for and against social responsibility, and its reality
Explain the eight arguments for and four arguments against social responsibility, and the seven forces that have made business concerned with social responsibility in reality.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the arguments in favour of social responsibility.
- Explain the arguments against social responsibility.
- Explain the forces that make businesses accept social responsibility in practice.
Should a business run only for its owners' profit, or should it also serve customers, employees, suppliers, government and the community? The textbook treats this as an ethical question about what is right, notes that people disagree, and sets out the arguments on both sides before describing what actually happens.
Arguments for social responsibility
- Justification for existence and growth: business exists to satisfy human needs; profit is an outcome of service, and growth comes only through continued service.
- Long-term interest of the firm: if workers, consumers, shareholders and officials feel a firm is not serving them, they withdraw cooperation; serving society improves image and long-run profit.
- Avoidance of government regulation: voluntary responsibility reduces the need for new laws that limit freedom.
- Maintenance of society: laws cannot cover every case; people who feel cheated may turn to anti-social acts that harm business too.
- Availability of resources with business: business has capital and managerial talent that can help solve social problems.
- Converting problems into opportunities: business has a history of turning risky situations into profitable ones and can do so with social problems.
- Better environment for doing business: a society with fewer problems is a better place to do business.
- Holding business responsible for social problems: business has created or worsened some problems (pollution, unsafe workplaces, corruption, discrimination), so it has a moral duty to help solve them.
Arguments against social responsibility
- Violation of profit maximisation: business exists for profit; it serves society best by being efficient and cutting costs.
- Burden on consumers: costly measures such as pollution control may be passed on as higher prices.
- Lack of social skills: business people lack the understanding and training to solve social problems; specialised agencies should do it.
- Lack of broad public support: the public does not like business interfering in social programmes, so such efforts lack confidence and cooperation.
The debate in brief
-
For
- Justifies existence and growth
- Long-term interest and image
- Avoids regulation
- Maintains society
- Business has resources
- Problems into opportunities
- Better business environment
- Business caused some problems
-
Against
- Violates profit maximisation
- Burden on consumers
- Lack of social skills
- Lack of broad public support
Reality of social responsibility
The textbook observes that business people now increasingly recognise social obligations besides profit. Part of this is mere lip service, but firms do realise that in a democratic society people can demand responsible conduct. Seven forces have pushed business in this direction:
Forces behind social responsibility
- Threat of public regulation Welfare states regulate irresponsible firms
- Pressure of labour movement Educated, organised labour ended 'hire and fire'
- Impact of consumer consciousness 'Let the buyer beware' replaced by 'customer is king'
- New social standards for business Business is legitimate only if it also serves social needs
- Development of business education More people aware of the social purpose of business
- Social and business interest linked They are complementary, not contradictory
- Professional managerial class Managers aim to satisfy many interest groups, not profit alone
Together these forces have made business a socio-economic activity: an economic institution that must reconcile its short- and long-term interests with the demands of society, and an organ of society that must justify its continuance by meeting its responsibilities.
Business must justify itself economically, but as an organ of society it must also justify its continuance by fulfilling its social responsibilities.
Worked example 1: name the argument
Which argument does each statement (made up) use? (a) 'If we ignore the village's water shortage, workers will leave and our factory will suffer.' (b) 'Our pollution-control plant will raise prices, so consumers pay for our responsibility.' (c) 'Let us act on safety voluntarily before a strict new law is passed.' Answer: (a) for: better environment for doing business (also long-term interest); (b) against: burden on consumers; (c) for: avoidance of government regulation.
Worked example 2: identify the force
A made-up company used to treat buyers carelessly. After customers began comparing products online, filing complaints and switching brands, it set up a fast complaint system and clear labelling. Reasoning: the change came from consumers' awareness of their rights and power, the force the textbook calls impact of consumer consciousness, where 'customer is king' replaces 'let the buyer beware'.
Key takeaways: arguments for social responsibility include justification for existence, long-term interest, avoiding regulation, maintaining society, resources of business, turning problems into opportunities, a better business environment and business's own role in causing problems; arguments against are profit maximisation, burden on consumers, lack of social skills and lack of public support; in reality, regulation, labour, consumers, social standards, education, shared interests and professional managers have made business a socio-economic activity.
Check your understanding
-
1. The argument that business should solve pollution and unsafe workplaces because it helped create them is:
- burden on consumers
- lack of social skills
- holding business responsible for social problems
- violation of profit maximisation
Show answer
Answer: C. Since business created or perpetuated some social problems, it has a moral obligation to help solve them.
-
2. Which is an argument AGAINST social responsibility?
- Lack of broad public support
- Availability of resources with business
- Maintenance of society
- Long-term interest of the firm
Show answer
Answer: A. Lack of broad public support is one of the four arguments against; the others are arguments in favour.
-
3. The replacement of 'caveat emptor' by 'customer is king' is linked to which force?
- Threat of public regulation
- Development of business education
- Pressure of labour movement
- Impact of consumer consciousness
Show answer
Answer: D. Education, mass media and competition made consumers aware of their power, so firms became customer-oriented.
-
4. Case: A made-up firm's managers, trained in a management institute, try to balance the interests of workers, customers, suppliers and shareholders rather than just profit. Which force does this reflect?
- Pressure of labour movement
- Development of a professional, managerial class
- Threat of public regulation
- Burden on consumers
Show answer
Answer: B. Professional managers, unlike earlier owner-managers, aim to satisfy many interest groups.
-
5. Assertion (A): Voluntary social responsibility can help business avoid government regulation. Reason (R): Business people lack the skills to solve social problems.
- Both A and R are true and R explains A
- Both A and R are true but R does not explain A
- A is false but R is true
- A is true but R is false
Show answer
Answer: B. Both are arguments in the textbook, but R is an argument against social responsibility and does not explain A, which rests on reducing the need for new laws.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.