- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Problems of MSMEs
Explain the problems MSMEs face: finance, raw materials, managerial skills, marketing, quality, capacity utilisation and global competition, and the special problems of small exporters.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the seven problems of MSMEs listed in the textbook.
- Explain the problems small exporters face.
- Link each problem to its cause in the small size of the enterprise.
For all their strengths, MSMEs often fail to reach their potential. Compared with large industries, they are at a disadvantage in the scale of operations, finance, use of modern technology and buying raw materials. The textbook adds remote locations with poor infrastructure, lack of managerial talent, poor quality and traditional technology. Small exporters also face a lack of data on foreign markets and of market intelligence, exchange rate fluctuations, quality standards and difficulty getting pre-shipment finance.
Seven problems
- Finance: units start with little capital and lack the creditworthiness to raise money from capital markets, so they depend on local sources and are often exploited by moneylenders. Working capital runs short because of delayed payments from buyers or capital locked in unsold stock. Banks ask for collateral, guarantees and margin money that many cannot provide.
- Raw materials: if materials are scarce they must accept lower quality or pay high prices; their bargaining power is low because they buy small quantities; they cannot risk bulk buying because they lack storage. General scarcity of metals and chemicals hits them hardest.
- Managerial skills: usually run by one person who may lack some skills, for example strong in technology but weak in marketing; no time for every function; cannot afford professional managers.
- Marketing: often their weakest area; they depend on middlemen who may pay low prices late; direct marketing needs infrastructure they lack.
- Quality: many cut costs and prices instead of keeping quality standards; they lack resources for quality research and expertise to upgrade technology; quality is their weakest point in global markets.
- Capacity utilisation: lack of marketing skill or demand means working below capacity, raising operating cost per unit and gradually leading to sickness and closure.
- Global competition: competition from medium and large firms and from giant multinationals.
How small problems feed each other
- Little capital Weak creditworthiness; dependence on moneylenders
- Small purchases Low bargaining power; costly or poor raw materials
- Weak marketing Dependence on middlemen; late, low payments
- Shortage of working capital Unsold stock and delayed dues
- Low capacity use Higher unit cost; risk of sickness
Then back to step 1: Little capital
MSME problems: finance, raw materials, managerial skills, marketing, quality, capacity utilisation and global competition, most of them rooted in small size.
Worked example 1: capacity utilisation and unit cost
Illustrative figures: a made-up unit, Pearl Plastics, has fixed costs of ₹6,00,000 a month and a variable cost of ₹20 per bucket, with capacity of 30,000 buckets a month. Working: at full capacity, fixed cost per bucket = 6,00,000 ÷ 30,000 = ₹20, so cost per bucket = 20 + 20 = ₹40. At 15,000 buckets (50% use), fixed cost per bucket = 6,00,000 ÷ 15,000 = ₹40, so cost per bucket = 40 + 20 = ₹60. Working below capacity raised unit cost by half, which is how low capacity utilisation slowly leads to sickness.
Worked example 2: diagnose the problem
Identify the main problem in each made-up case: (a) a skilled toolmaker produces excellent dies but cannot find buyers and sells through an agent who pays after four months; (b) a small soap maker buys oil in tiny lots at a higher price than big companies pay; (c) a carpet unit's export order is rejected because it did not meet the buyer's quality standard. Answer: (a) marketing (and the managerial gap between technical and marketing skill), leading also to a working-capital squeeze; (b) raw materials, due to low bargaining power; (c) quality, its weakest point in global markets.
Why size matters: small versus large firms
-
Small firm
- Little capital, weak credit standing
- Buys in small lots at higher prices
- One person handles every function
- Relies on middlemen to sell
- Hard to afford quality research
-
Large firm
- Access to capital markets and bank credit
- Bulk buying with bargaining power
- Specialist managers for each function
- Own distribution network
- Funds for research and technology
Key takeaways: MSMEs suffer from inadequate finance and working capital, costly or scarce raw materials, one-person management, weak marketing and dependence on middlemen, poor quality, under-use of capacity and competition from large firms and multinationals; small exporters also lack market data and pre-shipment finance and face exchange-rate risk.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why do banks often refuse loans to small units, according to the textbook?
- Banks do not lend to businesses
- Small units cannot provide adequate collateral, guarantees and margin money
- Small units do not need finance
- Interest rates are fixed by the units
Show answer
Answer: B. Banks do not lend without adequate collateral, guarantees and margin money, which many small units cannot provide.
-
2. MSMEs have low bargaining power in buying raw materials mainly because they:
- buy in small quantities
- buy only imported goods
- are government owned
- pay in advance
Show answer
Answer: A. Small purchase quantities give them little bargaining power, and they cannot risk bulk buying without storage.
-
3. Illustrative: fixed costs of ₹4,00,000 a month, variable cost ₹10 per unit. At 20,000 units the total cost per unit is:
- ₹10
- ₹20
- ₹40
- ₹30
Show answer
Answer: D. Fixed cost per unit = 4,00,000 ÷ 20,000 = ₹20; total = 20 + 10 = ₹30 per unit.
-
4. Case: A made-up small electronics unit has a brilliant engineer-owner who has no time or skill for sales, accounts and hiring, and cannot afford managers. The problem is:
- raw materials
- global competition
- lack of managerial skills
- capacity utilisation only
Show answer
Answer: C. One-person management often lacks all-round managerial skills, and small units cannot afford professional managers.
-
5. Which problem is specific to small exporting units, as listed in the textbook?
- Lack of market intelligence and adequate data on foreign markets
- Too much capital
- Over-qualified managers
- Excess bargaining power
Show answer
Answer: A. Small exporters face lack of data on foreign markets, lack of market intelligence, exchange-rate fluctuations, quality standards and pre-shipment finance.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.