• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Scarcity, alternative uses and the problem of choice

Explain why unlimited wants and limited resources force choice, why scarcity is the root of all economic problems, and how alternative uses of resources create the problem of what to produce.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the statement 'we cannot get something for nothing'.
  • State why scarcity is the root of all economic problems and give everyday signs of it.
  • Show how resources with alternative uses lead to the problem of choice.

If you had a magic lamp that granted every wish, you would never need to choose. The chapter uses the old story of Aladdin to make this point: real people have the same unlimited wants as Aladdin but no genie. That gap between wants and means is where economics begins.

Unlimited wants, limited means

Our wants are unlimited: once one is satisfied, another appears. But the income and resources we have to satisfy them are limited. Your pocket money is the textbook's example: with more of it you could buy almost everything you wanted, but because it is limited you must choose only those things you want the most. This need to choose is a basic teaching of economics.

A related idea is that prices matter. A person with a given income chooses which things, and in what quantities, to buy at the current prices (the prices being charged now). If current prices rise, the same income buys less, and the choice becomes harder.

Scarcity: the root of economic problems

Scarcity means that the things which satisfy our wants are limited in availability compared with the wants. The book calls scarcity the root of all economic problems: had there been no scarcity, there would be no economic problem and no need to study economics.

  • Long queues at railway booking counters.
  • Crowded buses and trains.
  • Shortage of essential commodities.
  • A rush for tickets when a new film is released.

Each of these is a sign (a manifestation) of scarcity: more people want something than there is of it.

Resources have alternative uses

Producers also face scarcity. At any point of time, the resources in agriculture, such as land, labour, water and fertiliser, are given (fixed in amount). Each of them can be used in more than one way: the same land and labour that grow food crops could grow non-food crops such as rubber, cotton or jute. Because resources are limited and have alternative uses, society must decide which commodities to produce with them. This is the problem of choice.

From scarcity to choice

  1. Unlimited wants People always want more goods and services.
  2. Limited resources Income, land, labour, water and other resources are fixed at any time.
  3. Alternative uses Each resource can produce several different things.
  4. Problem of choice Consumers choose what to buy; producers and society choose what to produce.

Scarcity is the root of all economic problems: wants are unlimited, while the resources that satisfy them are limited and have alternative uses, so every person and every society must choose.

Worked example 1: choosing with limited pocket money

Illustrative data: Ritika (made up) gets ₹500 a month. This month she wants a storybook (₹250), a film ticket (₹200), snacks (₹150), a mobile recharge (₹199) and a pen set (₹100).

Want (illustrative)Price (₹)
Storybook250
Film ticket200
Snacks150
Mobile recharge199
Pen set100
Total of all wants899

Step 1, total cost of all wants: 250 + 200 + 150 + 199 + 100 = ₹899. Step 2, compare with income: 899 − 500 = ₹399 more than she has. Step 3, choose: she ranks her wants and picks the storybook, snacks and pen set: 250 + 150 + 100 = ₹500, exactly her pocket money. The film ticket and recharge stay unfulfilled. Check: 500 + 200 + 199 = 899, so the chosen and unchosen items together equal the total. The lesson: limited means force her to drop ₹399 worth of wants.

Worked example 2: when the current price rises

Now suppose the storybook's price rises from ₹250 to ₹300 while her pocket money stays ₹500. Her old choice costs 300 + 150 + 100 = ₹550, which is ₹50 more than she has. Step 1: she must give something up. Step 2: if she drops the pen set, she spends 300 + 150 = ₹450 and has ₹50 left. Answer: a rise in current prices, with income unchanged, shrinks what she can buy, so she satisfies fewer wants. This is exactly the textbook's question: what happens if current prices go up?

Worked example 3: land with alternative uses

Illustrative: a farmer has 10 hectares. Each hectare can grow either rice or cotton, not both in the same season. If he puts 6 hectares under rice, only 10 − 6 = 4 hectares remain for cotton. Every extra hectare of rice means one hectare less of cotton. Because land is limited and has alternative uses, more of one crop means less of another, and he must choose.

Key takeaways: wants are unlimited but income and resources are limited, so we cannot get something for nothing. Scarcity, seen in queues and shortages, is the root of all economic problems. Resources like land, labour and water are limited and have alternative uses, which creates the problem of choice for consumers, producers and society.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the chapter, the root of all economic problems is:

    1. unemployment
    2. scarcity
    3. inflation
    4. population
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter states that scarcity is the root of all economic problems; without scarcity there would be no economic problem to study.

  2. 2. Which of these is NOT given as a sign of scarcity?

    1. Long queues at a railway booking counter
    2. Crowded buses and trains
    3. A shopkeeper having more stock than buyers want
    4. A rush for tickets to a new film
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Queues, crowded transport and a rush for tickets all show more demand than supply, which is scarcity. Unsold stock shows the opposite: more is available than people want.

  3. 3. Illustrative: Aman has ₹300 and wants items costing ₹120, ₹90 and ₹150. By how much do his wants exceed his money?

    1. ₹60
    2. ₹30
    3. ₹90
    4. ₹360
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Total wants = 120 + 90 + 150 = ₹360. Excess over money = 360 − 300 = ₹60. ₹360 is the total, not the shortfall.

  4. 4. Land that grows food crops could instead grow rubber, cotton or jute. This shows that resources:

    1. are unlimited
    2. have only one use
    3. are always wasted
    4. have alternative uses
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The same land and labour can be put to several uses, which is what 'alternative uses' means. Since they are also limited, society must choose among these uses.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Aladdin in the story never faced an economic problem. Reason (R): His wants were satisfied whenever he rubbed the lamp, so for him there was no scarcity.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A is true and R explains it: an economic problem arises from scarcity. Since the genie met every want, Aladdin faced no scarcity and so had nothing to choose between.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery