- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
The reforms appraised: growth, criticisms and the wider debate
Assess India's economy in the reform period using the textbook's evidence on growth, investment and reserves, examine criticisms about employment, agriculture, industry, disinvestment and fiscal policy, and weigh both views of globalisation.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the main achievements the textbook reports for the reform period.
- Explain the criticisms of reforms in employment, agriculture, industry, disinvestment and fiscal policy.
- Present the two opposing views of globalisation as the textbook frames them.
The reform process has run for more than three decades. The textbook appraises it carefully, setting out achievements and criticisms side by side and leaving students to weigh the evidence. This lesson follows the same balanced approach.
Achievements reported in the textbook
- GDP growth: in economics, growth is measured by GDP. According to the textbook's table, GDP growth rose from 5.6 per cent a year during 1980-91 to higher rates for much of the reform period; it says India saw rapid growth on a continual basis for two decades after 1991.
- Sector pattern: during the reform period agriculture's growth declined, industry's fluctuated and the service sector's rose, so GDP growth has been mainly driven by the service sector.
- Foreign investment and reserves: opening the economy led to a rapid increase in foreign direct investment and foreign exchange reserves. According to the textbook, reserves rose from about US $6 billion in 1990-91 to about US $646 billion in 2023-24, and India is one of the largest holders of reserves in the world.
- Exports: India is seen as a successful exporter of auto parts, pharmaceutical goods, engineering goods, IT software and textiles.
- Prices: rising prices have been kept under control.
Worked example 1: which sector drives growth
Illustrative numbers (made up): an economy's GDP of ₹100 lakh crore is made up of agriculture 20, industry 30 and services 50. In a year agriculture grows 2 per cent, industry 5 per cent and services 9 per cent. Increases: agriculture 0.02 × 20 = 0.4; industry 0.05 × 30 = 1.5; services 0.09 × 50 = 4.5. Total increase = 6.4, so GDP grows 6.4 per cent. Share of growth from services = 4.5 ÷ 6.4 × 100 ≈ 70 per cent. This is what it means to say growth is mainly driven by services.
Criticisms
Criticisms of the reform process
-
Growth and employment
- Growth has not generated sufficient employment
-
Agriculture
- Falling public investment in irrigation, power, roads, markets, research and extension
- Partial removal of fertiliser subsidy raised costs
- Lower import duties and lifting of import restrictions increased competition
- Shift to export cash crops pressured food grain prices
-
Industry
- Cheaper imports replaced demand for domestic goods
- Inadequate infrastructure, including power
- High non-tariff barriers in developed countries
-
Disinvestment
- PSE assets allegedly undervalued
- Proceeds used to cover revenue shortfalls rather than develop PSEs or social infrastructure
-
Fiscal policy
- Limits on public spending, especially social sectors
- Tax cuts did not raise revenue
- Lower tariffs and investor tax incentives reduced revenue
In agriculture, the textbook says reforms have not benefited the sector and its growth rate has been decelerating. Since 1991, public investment in agricultural infrastructure, which had played a crucial role in the green revolution, has fallen. Policy changes such as lower import duties on farm products, low minimum support prices and lifting of quantitative restrictions exposed farmers to international competition. The book's case of a made-up groundnut farmer in a drought-prone district shows how reduced subsidies, cuts in research and extension, and cheap imported edible oil can together push a small farmer into losses.
In industry, growth slowed because of falling demand for domestic products, due to cheaper imports and inadequate infrastructure. Developing countries are compelled to open up to goods and capital from developed countries, while still facing high non-tariff barriers in developed markets; the book's example is that India removed quota restrictions on textile and clothing exports, but the USA kept its quotas on textile imports from India and China. The book also describes how power sector reforms that ended subsidised electricity hurt powerloom weavers in Siricilla in Andhra Pradesh, whose wages depended on output, causing a crisis in their livelihood.
On disinvestment, the textbook reports that in 1991-92 the target was ₹2,500 crore and the government mobilised about ₹3,040 crore, more than the target. Critics argue that PSE assets were undervalued, causing a substantial loss, and that proceeds were used to offset revenue shortages rather than to develop PSEs or social infrastructure. On fiscal policy, reforms limited public expenditure, especially in social sectors; tax cuts did not raise revenue; lower tariffs reduced customs revenue; and tax incentives for foreign investors further reduced revenue, hurting development and welfare spending.
Worked example 2: a small farmer's margin after reform
Illustrative numbers (made up): a farmer spends ₹12,000 on a crop and harvests 2 quintals, selling at ₹8,000 a quintal. Income = 2 × 8,000 = ₹16,000; profit = 16,000 − 12,000 = ₹4,000. Now a subsidy cut raises costs by ₹2,000, to ₹14,000, and cheap imports push the price down to ₹6,500. Income = 2 × 6,500 = ₹13,000; result = 13,000 − 14,000 = −₹1,000, a loss. Both changes the textbook describes, higher costs and import competition, turn a profit into a loss.
Two views of globalisation
Globalisation: opportunity or threat?
-
An opportunity
- Greater access to global markets
- Access to high technology
- Large industries of developing countries can become global players
-
A threat
- A strategy of developed countries to expand their markets
- Compromised welfare and identity of people in poor countries
- Widened disparities among nations and people
- In India, growth concentrated in select services and high-income groups
The textbook concludes that globalisation through liberalisation and privatisation has produced positive as well as negative results. Some studies cited in the book argue that the crisis of the early 1990s grew out of deep-rooted inequalities and that the externally advised reforms aggravated them, with growth concentrated in services such as telecommunication, IT, finance, entertainment, travel, real estate and trade, rather than agriculture and industry, which support millions of livelihoods. Students should be able to state both views and the evidence for each.
The reform record is mixed: faster growth led by services, more foreign investment and reserves, and successful exports, alongside concerns about employment, agriculture, industry, disinvestment and social spending.
Key takeaways: according to the textbook, growth rose after 1991 and was driven mainly by services; foreign investment and reserves rose sharply; exports of auto parts, pharmaceuticals, engineering goods, IT software and textiles grew; and inflation was contained. Critics point to insufficient employment, falling public investment and rising costs in agriculture, industrial slowdown from cheap imports and weak infrastructure, undervalued disinvestment, and fiscal limits on social spending. Globalisation is seen by some as an opportunity and by others as a strategy of developed countries that widened disparities.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the chapter, GDP growth in the reform period has been mainly driven by which sector?
- Agriculture
- Industry
- Services
- Mining
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says agriculture's growth declined, industry's fluctuated and services' growth rose, indicating that GDP growth is mainly driven by growth in the service sector.
-
2. Which of the following is a criticism of reforms in agriculture made in the chapter?
- Public investment in agricultural infrastructure such as irrigation and research has fallen
- Fertiliser subsidy was greatly increased
- Import duties on farm products were raised
- Quantitative restrictions on farm imports were tightened
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says public investment in agricultural infrastructure (irrigation, power, roads, market linkages, research and extension) has fallen since 1991. The fertiliser subsidy was partly removed, and import duties and restrictions were reduced, not raised.
-
3. Illustrative data (made up): GDP is 100 units: agriculture 25, industry 25, services 50. They grow by 4, 4 and 6 per cent. What share of GDP growth comes from services?
- 50 per cent
- 6 per cent
- 75 per cent
- 60 per cent
Show answer
Answer: D. Increases: 0.04 × 25 = 1; 0.04 × 25 = 1; 0.06 × 50 = 3. Total increase = 5, so GDP grows 5 per cent. Services share of the growth = 3 ÷ 5 × 100 = 60 per cent, more than its 50 per cent share of GDP, because services grew fastest.
-
4. Assertion (A): Critics say disinvestment caused a substantial loss to the government. Reason (R): Critics argue that PSE assets were undervalued when sold to the private sector.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter reports critics' view that PSE assets were undervalued and sold to the private sector, which means a substantial loss to the government. R explains A.
-
5. Which statement reflects the view that globalisation is an opportunity, as presented in the chapter?
- It is a strategy of developed countries to expand their markets
- It gives greater access to global markets and high technology, and lets large industries of developing countries become important international players
- It compromises the identity of people in poor countries
- It has widened disparities among nations
Show answer
Answer: B. Scholars who see globalisation as an opportunity point to greater access to global markets, high technology and the chance for large firms of developing countries to become international players. The other options are the critics' view.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.