- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Jobless growth, casualisation and informalisation
Compare growth of employment and GDP and explain jobless growth, trace the shift in sectors and status since 1972-73 and casualisation, and distinguish formal and informal sectors and their workers.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain jobless growth using the relationship between GDP growth and employment growth.
- Describe the changes in the sectoral and status distribution of the workforce and explain casualisation.
- Define formal and informal sectors and explain the problems of informal workers.
Planned development aimed to expand both output and employment. This lesson asks how far employment kept pace with output, and what kind of jobs were created.
Growth of employment and GDP
According to the textbook, during 1951-2023 India's GDP grew positively and faster than employment, though GDP growth fluctuated. Employment grew at not more than 2 per cent a year most of the time. In the late 1990s employment growth declined to levels seen in the early stages of planning, and the gap between GDP growth and employment growth widened. In other words, the economy produced more goods and services without generating matching employment. Scholars call this jobless growth.
Worked example 1: output per worker in jobless growth
Illustrative numbers (made up): an economy produces output worth ₹100 lakh crore with 40 crore workers. Over five years output grows 7 per cent a year and employment 1 per cent a year. Output after 5 years ≈ 100 × 1.07 to the power 5 ≈ 100 × 1.403 ≈ ₹140.3 lakh crore. Workers ≈ 40 × 1.01 to the power 5 ≈ 40 × 1.051 ≈ 42.0 crore. Output grew about 40 per cent but jobs only about 5 per cent: about 2 crore new jobs while output rose by about ₹40 lakh crore. This is what a wide gap between GDP and employment growth looks like.
Changing structure of employment
| Item | 1972-73 | 1993-94 | 2011-12 | 2023-24 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Primary sector | 74.3 | 64 | 48.9 | 46.1 |
| Secondary sector | 10.9 | 16 | 24.3 | 24.1 |
| Services | 14.8 | 20 | 26.8 | 29.8 |
| Self-employed | 61.4 | 54.6 | 52.0 | 58.4 |
| Regular salaried employees | 15.4 | 13.6 | 18.0 | 21.7 |
| Casual wage labourers | 23.2 | 31.8 | 30.0 | 19.9 |
Two trends emerge. First, a substantial shift from farm to non-farm work: the primary sector's share fell from about 74 per cent to about 46 per cent, while the secondary sector rose from about 11 to 24 per cent and services from about 15 to 30 per cent. Second, over long stretches of this period people moved from self-employment and regular salaried jobs to casual wage work; scholars call this casualisation of the workforce, and it makes workers highly vulnerable. The textbook also points to a moderate rise in regular salaried employment and in self-employment in recent years, and asks students to think about why the secondary sector has stagnated.
Formal and informal sectors
Development planning hoped that industrialisation would move surplus farm workers into industry with better living standards. Yet economists argue that the quality of employment has been deteriorating: many workers get no maternity benefit, provident fund, gratuity or pension even after 10-20 years of work. To study this, the workforce is divided into formal (organised) and informal (unorganised) sectors.
Formal sector establishments are all public sector establishments and those private sector establishments that employ 10 or more hired workers; their workers are formal sector workers. All other enterprises and their workers form the informal sector.
Formal versus informal sector
-
Formal sector
- All public sector establishments
- Private establishments with 10 or more hired workers
- Social security benefits
- Higher earnings; protected by labour laws; trade unions
-
Informal sector
- Farmers, agricultural labourers, small enterprise owners and their workers
- Self-employed without hired workers
- Non-farm casual workers with several employers, such as headload workers
- No regular income, no protection, outdated technology, no accounts
According to the textbook, in 2019-20 there were about 535 million workers, of whom about 59 million were in the formal sector, about 11 per cent (59 ÷ 535 × 100); the remaining 89 per cent were informal. The book also notes that the public sector is the major employer in the formal sector. Informal workers are dismissed without compensation, and many live in slums. Since the late 1970s, developing countries including India have paid more attention to the informal sector because formal employment is not growing; owing partly to the efforts of the International Labour Organisation (ILO), the Indian government has begun modernising informal enterprises and providing social security to informal workers.
The textbook's case of Ahmedabad shows informalisation in action. The city's prosperity rested on more than 60 textile mills employing about 1,50,000 workers with secure jobs, living wages, social security and a strong trade union. When mills closed over about ten years from the early 1980s, large numbers of permanent and non-permanent workers lost their jobs and were pushed into the informal sector and into poverty, with serious social consequences for their families.
Worked example 2: formal or informal?
Apply the definition to made-up cases. (1) A worker in a hotel with 7 hired workers and 3 family workers: hired workers = 7, fewer than 10, so informal. (2) A teacher in a private school with 25 teachers: formal. (3) A police constable: public sector, so formal. (4) A cycle-rickshaw puller working alone: informal. (5) The owner of a textile shop employing 9 workers: informal. (6) A driver in a private bus company with 20 hired staff: formal. Result: 3 formal, 3 informal. The key test is public sector, or 10 or more hired workers.
Key takeaways: according to the textbook, GDP grew faster than employment over 1951-2023, and employment growth was mostly at or below 2 per cent, widening into jobless growth. The workforce has shifted from the primary sector (about 74 to 46 per cent) towards secondary and service sectors, and over long periods from self-employment and regular jobs to casual work (casualisation). The formal sector covers public establishments and private ones with 10 or more hired workers; according to the textbook, only about 11 per cent of workers were formal in 2019-20. Informal workers lack regular income, protection and social security, as the Ahmedabad case shows.
Check your understanding
-
1. What do scholars mean by jobless growth?
- Employment growing faster than GDP
- The economy producing more goods and services without generating matching employment
- A fall in GDP with rising employment
- Growth only in the formal sector
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter calls the widening gap between GDP growth and employment growth, producing more goods and services without generating employment, jobless growth.
-
2. According to the chapter's definition, which of these is a formal sector establishment?
- A private shop with 6 hired workers
- A family farm with no hired workers
- A private factory with 15 hired workers
- A self-employed street vendor
Show answer
Answer: C. Formal sector establishments are all public sector establishments and private establishments employing 10 or more hired workers. Only the factory with 15 hired workers qualifies among these.
-
3. Illustrative data (made up): a state has 80 lakh workers, of whom 9.6 lakh are in the formal sector. What percentage is informal?
- 12 per cent
- 88 per cent
- 90.4 per cent
- 70.4 per cent
Show answer
Answer: B. Formal share = 9.6 ÷ 80 × 100 = 12 per cent. Informal share = 100 − 12 = 88 per cent.
-
4. Assertion (A): Casualisation makes workers highly vulnerable. Reason (R): Casualisation is the movement of workers from self-employment and regular salaried jobs to casual wage work, which offers no assurance of continued work.
- A is true, but R is false
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is false, but R is true
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter defines casualisation as the move from self-employment and regular jobs to casual wage work, and says it makes workers highly vulnerable; casual work lacks security. R explains A.
-
5. According to the textbook's Table 6.3, what happened to the primary sector's share of the workforce between 1972-73 and 2023-24?
- It fell from about 74 per cent to about 46 per cent
- It rose from about 46 per cent to about 74 per cent
- It stayed about the same
- It fell from about 24 per cent to about 11 per cent
Show answer
Answer: A. According to the textbook the primary sector's share fell from 74.3 per cent in 1972-73 to about 46.1 per cent in 2023-24, a substantial shift from farm to non-farm work.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.