- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Sustainable development: meaning and conditions
Define sustainable development as in Our Common Future, explain needs and intergenerational equity, Barbier's poverty-focused view, the three conditions for the present generation, and Herman Daly's five rules.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State the definition of sustainable development and explain its key terms.
- Explain intergenerational equity and Edward Barbier's view of sustainable development.
- List Herman Daly's five conditions for sustainable development and apply them.
Environment and economy are interdependent: development that ignores its effect on the environment will destroy the environment that sustains life. The measures of the environment ministry and pollution control boards will not succeed unless we consciously adopt a path of sustainable development. Only concern for future generations can make development last.
Definition
Sustainable development is development that meets the needs of the present generation without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.
This definition was emphasised by the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED) and comes from the report Our Common Future of the Brundtland Commission. Sustainable development should allow all future generations a potential average quality of life at least as high as that enjoyed by the current generation. The two catch phrases are needs and future generations. The word needs links the idea to the distribution of resources: the report explains sustainable development as meeting the basic needs of all and extending to all the opportunity to satisfy their aspirations for a better life. Meeting everyone's needs requires redistributing resources, so it is a moral issue.
Barbier's view: focus on the poor
Edward Barbier defined sustainable development as directly concerned with raising the material standard of living of the poor at the grassroots, measurable through income, real income, educational services, health care, sanitation and water supply. It aims to reduce absolute poverty by providing lasting and secure livelihoods that minimise resource depletion, environmental degradation, cultural disruption and social instability. In this sense it meets the basic needs of all, especially the poor majority, for employment, food, energy, water and housing, and ensures growth of agriculture, manufacturing, power and services to meet those needs.
Intergenerational equity
The Brundtland Commission stresses protecting future generations, in line with environmentalists who say we have a moral obligation to hand over the planet in good order: the present generation should leave the next a stock of quality of life assets no less than what it inherited. This fairness between generations is called intergenerational equity. The present generation can promote development compatible with three conditions:
- Conservation of natural assets.
- Preservation of the regenerative capacity of the world's natural ecological system.
- Avoiding added costs or risks on future generations.
Herman Daly's five conditions
Herman Daly's conditions for sustainable development
-
Limit population
- Keep human population within the carrying capacity
- Carrying capacity is like a ship's Plimsoll line (load limit mark)
-
Efficient technology
- Technological progress should be input efficient, not input consuming
-
Renewable resources
- Rate of extraction should not exceed rate of regeneration
-
Non-renewable resources
- Rate of depletion should not exceed rate of creation of renewable substitutes
-
Correct pollution
- Inefficiencies arising from pollution should be corrected
The Plimsoll line is the mark on a ship's hull showing its maximum safe load. The textbook's point: the economy has no such visible line, so human activity can grow beyond the earth's carrying capacity without warning, moving away from sustainable development. The textbook also notes that in 2015 the UN set out 17 Sustainable Development Goals to be achieved by 2030.
Worked example 1: Daly's rule for non-renewables
Illustrative numbers (made up): a state uses coal that supplies 1,000 units of energy a year, and coal reserves will run out at this rate. Each year it adds solar capacity supplying 30 units. Coal depletion (in energy terms) = 1,000 units a year; creation of renewable substitutes = 30 units a year. Since 1,000 > 30, Daly's fourth condition is not met. To meet it, the state would need to cut coal use or add renewable capacity until the energy from new substitutes keeps pace with the energy depleted. If it reduced coal use to 400 units and added 400 units of renewable capacity a year, depletion would no longer exceed substitution.
Worked example 2: leaving assets no less than inherited
Illustrative numbers (made up): a village inherited 500 hectares of healthy forest and a pond supplying 200 families. Over 20 years it clears 120 hectares and silts the pond so it now serves 140 families. Forest left = 500 − 120 = 380 hectares (24 per cent less); water families served = 140 (30 per cent fewer). The village has failed intergenerational equity. If it replants 120 hectares and desilts the pond, it would pass on at least what it inherited.
Key takeaways: sustainable development meets present needs without compromising future generations' ability to meet theirs (UNCED; Our Common Future of the Brundtland Commission). Needs links it to fair distribution, making it a moral issue. Barbier stresses raising the living standards of the poor with secure livelihoods. Intergenerational equity means leaving quality of life assets no less than we inherited, through conservation, preserving regenerative capacity and not burdening the future. Daly's five conditions: limit population to carrying capacity, input-efficient technology, extraction of renewables within regeneration, depletion of non-renewables within creation of renewable substitutes, and correction of pollution.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which report gave the widely used definition of sustainable development?
- Our Common Future
- The Wealth of Nations
- The Karve Committee report
- The Economic Survey
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says the seminal report Our Common Future (of the Brundtland Commission) gave the definition, which was emphasised by UNCED.
-
2. Edward Barbier's definition of sustainable development is directly concerned with:
- maximising GDP growth only
- raising the material standard of living of the poor at the grassroots
- protecting only wildlife
- increasing exports
Show answer
Answer: B. Barbier defined sustainable development as directly concerned with increasing the material standard of living of the poor at the grassroots level, measurable through income, education, health, sanitation and water.
-
3. According to Herman Daly, renewable resources should be extracted so that:
- extraction exceeds regeneration
- extraction stops completely
- the rate of extraction does not exceed the rate of regeneration
- only the rich can use them
Show answer
Answer: C. Daly's third condition is that renewable resources be extracted on a sustainable basis: the rate of extraction should not exceed the rate of regeneration.
-
4. Assertion (A): Meeting the needs of all is described as a moral issue. Reason (R): Meeting the needs of all requires redistributing resources.
- A is false, but R is true
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter says the concept of needs is linked to distribution of resources: meeting the needs of all requires redistributing resources and is hence a moral issue. R explains A.
-
5. Illustrative data (made up): a country depletes oil worth 600 energy units a year and creates renewable substitutes worth 150 units a year. By Daly's rule, by how much does depletion exceed substitution?
- 750 units
- 450 units
- 150 units
- 4 units
Show answer
Answer: B. Excess = 600 − 150 = 450 units a year. Daly's rule requires depletion of non-renewables not to exceed the creation of renewable substitutes, so it is not met.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.