- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
The four qualities of a good essay
Understand and apply unity, coherence, relevance and proportion, the four marks of a good essay, by spotting and repairing faults in original paragraphs.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define an essay as the unit does.
- Explain unity, coherence, relevance and proportion.
- Spot a paragraph that breaks one of the four qualities.
- Repair such a paragraph.
The unit defines an essay simply: a composition on one subject that has more than one paragraph. It then lists four characteristics that separate a good essay from a loose collection of sentences.
| Quality | Meaning | Question to ask yourself |
|---|---|---|
| Unity | Every part deals with the main subject and is clearly linked to it | Does each paragraph serve the title? |
| Coherence | A logical sequence of thought between ideas, sentences and paragraphs | Does each idea lead naturally to the next? |
| Relevance | Unimportant information is left out | Would the essay lose anything without this? |
| Proportion | More space for more important ideas | Is my longest paragraph on my most important point? |
Easily confused: unity and relevance
-
Unity
- About the whole essay and the links between its parts
- Breaks when a paragraph wanders to another subject
-
Relevance
- About individual details
- Breaks when a fact is true and on topic but unimportant
Worked example 1: a break in unity
Essay title: The Benefits of Cycling to School. A paragraph (written for this lesson): Cycling keeps students fit and costs nothing once a bicycle is bought. The Tour de France is the most famous cycle race in the world and lasts about three weeks. Working: the second sentence is about professional racing, not about cycling to school. It breaks unity. Repair: replace it with a sentence on the subject, e.g. It also gives students a few minutes of fresh air before a long day indoors.
Worked example 2: a break in coherence
Paragraph (written for this lesson): Finally, more cycles would mean fewer cars at the gate. Many students live within three kilometres of school. First, the school could build a safe cycle stand. Working: Finally comes first and First comes last, and the fact about distance is not linked to anything. Reorder: Many students live within three kilometres of school, close enough to cycle. First, the school could build a safe cycle stand. Finally, more cycles would mean fewer cars at the gate. Now the ideas move from situation to action to result.
Relevance and proportion in practice
Relevance is about trimming. In an essay on cycling to school, the colour of your own bicycle is on topic but unimportant: cut it. Proportion is about balance. If safety is your main concern, it deserves a full paragraph, not a single line squeezed between two long paragraphs on minor points. A useful habit is to note, at the planning stage, roughly how many sentences each point will get.
Checking a draft for the four qualities
- Unity Cross out anything off the subject.
- Relevance Cut details that add nothing.
- Coherence Reorder and add linkers.
- Proportion Give the main points the most space.
Unity: stay on the subject. Coherence: ideas in logical order. Relevance: leave out the unimportant. Proportion: most space for the most important.
Key takeaways: an essay is a multi-paragraph composition on one subject. Check every draft for unity (all on the subject), coherence (logical order and links), relevance (nothing unimportant) and proportion (space matched to importance).
Check your understanding
-
1. How does the unit define an essay?
- Any single paragraph
- A list of points
- A composition on a particular subject with more than one paragraph
- A letter to a friend
Show answer
Answer: C. The unit calls an essay a composition on one subject consisting of more than one paragraph.
-
2. An essay on saving electricity includes a paragraph on the life of a famous inventor. Which quality is broken?
- Proportion
- Unity
- Punctuation
- Spelling
Show answer
Answer: B. The paragraph is about another subject and is not linked to saving electricity, so it breaks unity.
-
3. Which quality is broken if an essay's most important point gets one line while a minor point gets a whole page?
- Proportion
- Coherence
- Relevance
- Unity
Show answer
Answer: A. Proportion means giving more space to important ideas. Here the balance is reversed.
-
4. A paragraph starts with 'Finally' and ends with 'First'. Which quality needs attention?
- Unity
- Relevance
- Proportion
- Coherence
Show answer
Answer: D. The logical sequence of thought is broken; reordering the sentences restores coherence.
-
5. In an essay on cycling to school, which detail is the best example of something irrelevant?
- Cycling keeps students fit
- A safe cycle stand is needed
- My bicycle is blue
- Cycling reduces traffic at the gate
Show answer
Answer: C. The colour of a bicycle is on topic but unimportant, so leaving it out improves relevance.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.