• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Analogy, extended comparison and tone

Understand how a writer builds an analogy and extends it through a passage, as in the unit's example from Steinbeck, and write your own extended analogy with a clear tone.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain what an analogy is and how it can be extended.
  • Discuss how the unit's Steinbeck example uses analogy, word choice, comparison and tone.
  • Write an original extended analogy.
  • Identify the tone of a creative passage.

The unit analyses a short paragraph adapted from John Steinbeck's novel The Pearl. In it the writer compares a town to an animal: it has a nervous system, a head, shoulders and feet, a whole emotion of its own, and news passes through it faster than children or neighbours could carry it. The unit sets out the parts: the topic (a town), the analogy (an animal), striking word choice (a town with an emotion), and comparisons of speed. It calls the tone light humour with a touch of sarcasm.

What an analogy is

An analogy explains or pictures one thing by comparing it to another that is different but alike in some ways. A simple comparison stops after one sentence. An extended analogy keeps going: the writer finds more and more points of likeness, so the comparison shapes a whole paragraph. The unit notes that Steinbeck first visualises the town as an animal and then extends the primary analogy.

Building an extended analogy

  1. Choose a subject A school, a city, a family, an exam hall.
  2. Choose the comparison Something different but alike in a few ways.
  3. List likenesses Parts, behaviour, moods, speed, sounds.
  4. Extend Develop three or four likenesses in turn.
  5. Set the tone Playful, admiring, mocking or sad.

Worked example 1: a school as a beehive (written for this lesson)

At eight the school wakes like a hive. A low hum rises from the classrooms, each one a cell packed with workers bent over their tasks. The staff room is the queen's chamber, where decisions are made in private and carried out by everyone else. At the bell, the corridors swarm; no one seems to plan the movement, yet everyone arrives somewhere. And by four the hive has emptied, leaving only the honey of the day's notes and the faint buzz of a cleaner's broom.

FeatureIn the passage
TopicA school day
AnalogyA beehive
ExtensionsHum, cells, queen's chamber, swarming, honey
Word choicewakes, swarm, honey of the day's notes
ToneAffectionate, lightly humorous

Tone

Tone is the writer's attitude to the subject. The same analogy can carry different tones. A school as a hive can sound affectionate (busy, purposeful), mocking (everyone obeys without thinking), or weary (endless, mechanical work). Word choice sets the tone: buzzing with ideas is admiring; droning on is critical.

Worked example 2: change the tone

Working: keep the analogy, change the words. Mocking version (written for this lesson): The school is a hive in which nobody remembers why they are buzzing. The workers fill their cells with notes they will never read again, and at the bell they swarm towards the gate as if the honey were outside. The analogy is the same; words like nobody remembers why and never read again make the tone sarcastic, close to the light sarcasm the unit finds in Steinbeck.

One analogy, two tones

  • Affectionate
    • hum
    • workers bent over their tasks
    • honey of the day's notes
  • Mocking
    • nobody remembers why
    • notes never read again
    • as if the honey were outside

An analogy pictures one thing as another; an extended analogy keeps finding likenesses; word choice sets its tone.

Key takeaways: the unit's Steinbeck example shows topic, analogy, word choice, comparison and tone working together. To write an extended analogy, list likenesses and develop them in turn. Tone comes from word choice, so the same analogy can admire or mock.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In the paragraph the unit adapts from Steinbeck's The Pearl, what is the town compared to?

    1. A machine
    2. A river
    3. An animal
    4. A family
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The unit identifies the analogy as a comparison of the town to an animal, with a nervous system, head, shoulders and feet.

  2. 2. What does it mean to extend an analogy?

    1. To make one comparison and stop
    2. To keep developing further points of likeness through a passage
    3. To explain it in a footnote
    4. To replace it with a fact
    Show answer

    Answer: B. An extended analogy develops more and more likenesses so that the comparison shapes a whole paragraph.

  3. 3. How does the unit describe the tone of the Steinbeck paragraph?

    1. Tragic and angry
    2. Formal and scientific
    3. Fearful
    4. Light humour, a little sarcastic
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The unit calls the tone light humour, slightly sarcastic.

  4. 4. In the beehive passage written for this lesson, what is the staff room compared to?

    1. A cell
    2. The honey
    3. The queen's chamber
    4. The swarm
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The staff room is pictured as the queen's chamber, where decisions are made in private.

  5. 5. Which phrase gives the beehive analogy a mocking tone?

    1. workers bent over their tasks
    2. nobody remembers why they are buzzing
    3. a low hum rises
    4. the honey of the day's notes
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 'Nobody remembers why' suggests pointless activity, which mocks; the others are neutral or affectionate.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery