• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Characters and the meaning of the narrator's choice

Describe the narrator, her mother, Mrs Dorling and her daughter with evidence, and explain why the narrator decides to forget the address.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe each character with qualities and evidence.
  • Contrast the mother's trust with Mrs Dorling's behaviour.
  • Explain the narrator's reasons for leaving her belongings behind.
  • Answer the question of why she wants to forget the address.
CharacterQualitiesEvidence (in our own words)
The narrator (Mrs S's daughter)Observant, restrained, sensitive, finally resoluteNotices missing objects at once; speaks little; her voice sounds strange to her in the room; decides firmly to forget
Her mother, Mrs STrusting, generous, proudBelieves Mrs Dorling is saving her things; thinks asking for a promise would be an insult; looks reprovingly at her doubtful daughter
Mrs DorlingOpportunistic, greedy, coldTakes the family's valuables during the war; wears the cardigan; will not let the daughter in or offer anything
Mrs Dorling's daughterInnocent, casualUses the antique things carelessly; laughs; does not know their history or even that the spoons are silver

The mother and Mrs Dorling

Trust and its betrayal

  • The mother
    • Sees Mrs Dorling as a friend risking danger
    • Refuses to doubt her
    • Gives freely
  • Mrs Dorling
    • Appears suddenly after years
    • Insists on taking things 'to save them'
    • Keeps them and denies the survivor

The mother is moved by what she sees as Mrs Dorling's courage, since carrying a Jewish family's possessions could be dangerous under the occupation. The daughter, even then, has doubts. After the war, the cardigan and the closed door show that the doubts were right. Minco never states that Mrs Dorling is a thief; she lets her actions speak.

The second visit: known and unknown

Inside, the narrator feels she is in a room she both knows and does not know. The objects are her family's: the woollen table-cloth with its unrepaired burn mark, the white teapot with a gold border on the lid, the still-life painting whose apple she loved as a child, the plates from the wall, the silver cutlery. But they are arranged without taste, in a stuffy, unfamiliar room. When she tells the girl a story about not knowing, as a child, that the family's everyday cutlery was silver, the girl goes to check her own drawer: the narrator hears the jingle of spoons and forks, her mother's spoons, as she leaves.

Why she decides to forget the address

  • Objects lose their value out of context: things tied to the warm, familiar life of the past lose their meaning when seen, cut off from that life, in strange surroundings.
  • There is no place for them now: she lives in a small rented room with scraps of black-out paper still at the windows and a drawer that holds only a few pieces of cutlery.
  • Remembering hurts: she has many things to forget, and of all of them this address will be the easiest to let go.
  • She chooses to move on: rather than fight for things, she keeps her memories and starts again.

Worked example 1: a short-answer question

Question: why did the narrator want to forget the address? Working: give the main reason (objects lose value when separated from the life they belonged to), then a supporting reason (no space in her new life) and her attitude (moving on). Answer (in about 50 words): She realised that her mother's things had lost their value once they were cut off from the family life they belonged to. Seen in Mrs Dorling's tasteless room, they only caused pain. She had no room for them in her small rented room, so she chose to keep her memories and move on.

Worked example 2: character from a single detail

Question: what does the girl's careless use of the antique plates suggest? Working: she says they once ate off them because she wanted to, but found them nothing special. She does not know their history. Answer: the girl is innocent; she does not know these things were taken from another family, and to her they are ordinary objects. Her innocence makes the narrator's loss feel even sharper.

Things belong to the life they were part of; cut off from it, they lose their worth.

Key takeaways: the trusting mother, the grasping Mrs Dorling and her innocent daughter surround a restrained, observant narrator. Her decision to forget the address shows that memories, not objects, hold the value of a lost life.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Why does the narrator's mother refuse to make an agreement with Mrs Dorling about the things?

    1. She plans to give them away
    2. She does not own them
    3. She thinks it would be an insult, given the risk Mrs Dorling is taking
    4. She has already sold them
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The mother says talking like that would simply be an insult, and she admires the risk she believes Mrs Dorling is running.

  2. 2. Which object helps the narrator recognise the table-cloth as her family's?

    1. A gold border
    2. A burn mark on its edge that was never repaired
    3. An apple pattern
    4. A Hanukkah candle-holder
    Show answer

    Answer: B. She remembers that somewhere on the edge there should be a burn mark that had never been repaired, and finds it.

  3. 3. How does Mrs Dorling's daughter treat the family's possessions?

    1. With great care and respect
    2. She tries to return them
    3. She hides them
    4. Casually, as ordinary things, without knowing their history
    Show answer

    Answer: D. She mentions eating off the wall plates and says they were nothing special; she does not even know the spoons are silver.

  4. 4. Which is NOT a reason the narrator gives for forgetting the address?

    1. Objects lose value when separated from the life they belonged to
    2. Her small rented room has no space for them
    3. She plans to sue Mrs Dorling instead
    4. Forgetting the address will be easy compared with other things
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The story never mentions legal action. The other three reasons appear in her final thoughts.

  5. 5. What best describes the narrator's state of mind inside the room on her second visit?

    1. Joyful and relaxed
    2. Shocked and oppressed: the room is known and yet strange
    3. Bored
    4. Angry and shouting
    Show answer

    Answer: B. She is horrified and oppressed; her own voice sounds strange to her, and she scarcely dares to look around.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery