• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Adventure: Professor Gaitonde's two days in another India

Follow Jayant Narlikar's science-fiction story in order: Professor Gaitonde's journey to a Bombay still under British rule, his discovery in the library, the scene at Azad Maidan and his return, and explain the chapter's key expressions.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Say who wrote the story and what kind of story it is.
  • Retell the main events of the extract in order.
  • Compare the India Gaitonde knows with the India he visits.
  • Explain expressions such as blow-by-blow account, morale booster, relegated, political acumen, de facto, astute, doctored accounts and gave vent to.

The Adventure is an adapted extract from a longer science-fiction story by Jayant Narlikar, the distinguished Indian astrophysicist who also wrote popular science and fiction in Marathi and English. The story is an alternate history: it asks what India would be like if one battle had ended differently, and then uses real scientific ideas to explain how a man might pass between two such worlds.

Characters

CharacterWho they are
Professor Gangadharpant GaitondeA well-known historian from Pune, a regular president of public meetings
Rajendra DeshpandeA scientist friend who explains the experience at the end
Khan SahibA businessman from Peshawar whom Gaitonde meets on the train
Vinay GaitondeThe professor's son, who works in Bombay in the real world

What happens in the extract (our summary)

Before the extract opens, the professor has been in a collision with a truck while thinking about catastrophe theory, and has found himself in a strangely different world. He takes a fast train from Pune to Bombay. At a station called Sarhad, permits are checked: the British Raj begins there. In Bombay he sees East India House, the headquarters of a still-flourishing East India Company, and English shops and banks; his son cannot be found at his office. At the Asiatic Society library in the Town Hall he reads his own five-volume history and finds the turning point: in this world the Marathas won the Battle of Panipat. Victory boosted Maratha power; the East India Company was kept to small pockets; India later became a democracy that allowed the British to keep only Bombay on a lease. A Bakhar (a chronicle) records that a bullet narrowly missed the young Vishwasrao. That evening at Azad Maidan, Gaitonde sees a lecture with an empty chair, sits in it, insists on speaking, and is pelted and mobbed by an audience that has abolished chairpersons. He vanishes in the crowd and is found next morning, back in his own world. He tells Rajendra, and shows a page torn from the Bakhar as evidence.

The order of events

  1. Collision Thinking about catastrophe theory, Gaitonde is hit by a truck (before the extract).
  2. Train to Bombay Permits at Sarhad; Khan Sahib describes a different India.
  3. Bombay East India House, British shops; his son is not found.
  4. Library His own history book shows the Marathas won at Panipat.
  5. Azad Maidan He occupies the empty chair, is mobbed and disappears.
  6. Return Found back in his own world; he shows Rajendra the torn page.
  7. Explanation Rajendra uses catastrophe theory and quantum theory to explain it.

Two Indias compared

The real world and the alternate world

  • India as Gaitonde knew it
    • The Marathas lost at Panipat (1761)
    • Vishwasrao was killed by a bullet
    • The British ruled India
    • The East India Company was wound up after 1857
  • India he visited
    • The Marathas won at Panipat
    • The bullet missed Vishwasrao
    • India stayed independent and became a democracy
    • The Company survived; Britain kept only Bombay, on a lease

Expressions to infer

Meanings explained in our own words.
ExpressionMeaning in context
blow-by-blow accounta detailed description of every stage of an event
morale boostersomething that raises confidence and spirit
relegated topushed down to a less important position
political acumensharp judgement in politics
de factoin fact, in reality (even if not officially)
astuteclever and shrewd
doctored accountsversions of events that have been changed or exaggerated
gave vent toexpressed strongly

Worked example 1: true or false?

Statements: (1) the story is an account of real events: false, it is science fiction; (2) it hinges on a particular historical event: true, the Battle of Panipat; (3) Rajendra Deshpande was a historian: false, he is a scientist, while Gaitonde is the historian; (4) all the places are imaginary: false, Pune, Bombay, Azad Maidan and Panipat are real; (5) the story tries to relate history to science: true.

Worked example 2: comparing the two countries

Question: what did Gaitonde notice when he compared the two Indias? Answer: the India he visited had never been enslaved by a foreign power; it stood on its own feet, had self-respect, had set up its own science centres and became a democracy, allowing the British only a trading outpost in Bombay.

One bullet that missed changed a battle; one battle changed a country. That is the premise of The Adventure.

Key takeaways: The Adventure is a science-fiction alternate history by Jayant Narlikar. Gaitonde spends two days in an India where the Marathas won at Panipat, finds the turning point in his own book, is mobbed at Azad Maidan and returns with a torn page as evidence.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What kind of story is The Adventure?

    1. A true account of a historian's life
    2. A science-fiction story about an alternate history
    3. A travel guide to Mumbai
    4. A biography of Vishwasrao
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The story imagines a different India after a changed battle and uses scientific theories to explain the experience; it is science fiction.

  2. 2. What did Gaitonde find at the library that explained the different world?

    1. That the Mughals had never ruled
    2. That the British had won at Plassey
    3. That the East India Company was never formed
    4. That the Marathas had won the Battle of Panipat
    Show answer

    Answer: D. His own history volume showed that in this world the Marathas won the Battle of Panipat, which changed everything after it.

  3. 3. Why was Gaitonde surprised to see East India House?

    1. History books said the Company was wound up after 1857.
    2. It was painted red.
    3. His son worked there.
    4. It was a library.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. In his world, the East India Company had been wound up soon after 1857, yet here it was flourishing.

  4. 4. What does 'relegated to the background' mean?

    1. Promoted to leader
    2. Sent abroad
    3. Pushed into a less important position
    4. Made famous
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Dadasaheb, the trouble-maker, was relegated: he lost importance and eventually retired from politics.

  5. 5. Which statement is true?

    1. Rajendra Deshpande is a historian.
    2. All the places in the story are imaginary.
    3. The story relates history to science.
    4. The story describes real events.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The story connects a historical event with scientific theories. Rajendra is a scientist, the places are real, and the events are fiction.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery