• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Nature and human interaction, and the three questions of geography

Describe how nature and human beings shape each other, explain spatial organisation and integration, and use the three questions what, where and why that make geography a science.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain how nature has influenced humans and how humans have modified nature.
  • Describe spatial organisation and spatial integration through links and nodes.
  • Apply the three questions what, where and why, and explain why the third made geography scientific.

Geographical phenomena, both physical and human, are not fixed. They change all the time because an ever-changing earth interacts with ever-active human beings. This lesson looks at that interaction and at the questions geographers ask about it.

Nature and human beings as one whole

Geography studies nature and human interactions as an integrated whole. The chapter puts it in a pair of phrases: the human is an integral part of nature, and nature carries the imprints of humans. Nature has influenced food, clothing, shelter and occupations. Human beings, in turn, have come to terms with nature through two broad responses: adaptation (adjusting to conditions, such as wearing woollens in a cold region) and modification (changing the conditions, such as building a dam or irrigating a dry field).

Primitive societies depended directly on their immediate environment. Present societies have modified the natural environment by inventing and using technology, widening the area over which they operate and the resources they use. With technology, people loosened the shackles of the physical environment. Technology reduced the harshness of labour, raised labour efficiency, gave people leisure to attend to higher needs of life, and increased both the scale of production and the mobility of labour.

Two ways humans deal with nature

  • Adaptation
    • Adjust ways of life to the environment
    • Clothing suited to the weather
    • Food habits based on local crops
    • Typical of societies with simple technology
  • Modification
    • Change the environment to suit needs
    • Irrigation, dams, terraced fields
    • Air conditioners and coolers in a small space
    • Grows as technology develops

Humanised nature and naturalised humans

The chapter quotes a poet's imagined dialogue between a human being and nature (God), in which nature makes the raw materials, like soil, night and wilderness, and the human makes something useful from each, like a cup, a lamp and a garden. The point, in our words, is that people have added their own contribution by using natural resources. With technology humans moved from a stage of necessity to a stage of freedom, leaving their imprint everywhere and creating new possibilities in collaboration with nature. So today we find humanised nature and naturalised human beings, and geography studies this two-way relationship.

Spatial organisation and spatial integration

Space gets organised through transport and communication networks. Links (routes such as roads, railways and shipping lanes) and nodes (settlements of all types and sizes, from hamlets to metropolitan cities) join places into a connected whole. Over time this produces an organised space. As a social science, geography therefore studies spatial organisation and spatial integration.

How space becomes organised

  1. Scattered settlements Places exist but are weakly connected.
  2. Links develop Roads, railways and communication lines join places.
  3. Nodes grow Settlements of different sizes form a hierarchy around the links.
  4. Integrated space Goods, people and information move through an organised network.

The three sets of questions

Geography as a discipline is concerned with three sets of questions:

  1. What? Identifying the patterns of natural and cultural features found over the earth's surface.
  2. Where? Finding the distribution of natural and human/cultural features over the earth's surface.
  3. Why? Explaining the causal relationships between features, processes and phenomena.

Together, the first two questions deal with the distributional and locational aspects of features. They give an inventory of what features exist and where they are, an approach that was very popular in the colonial period. But these two questions alone did not make geography a scientific discipline. Only when the third question, why, was added did geography become a science, because it now explained patterns rather than merely listing them.

What and where give an inventory of features and their locations; why gives the explanation. The why question made geography a scientific discipline.

Geography is related to space and notes its spatial characteristics. It studies the patterns of distribution, location and concentration of phenomena, interprets them and explains them. It also notes the associations and inter-relationships between phenomena that result from the dynamic interaction between human beings and their physical environment.

The three questions applied to one place
QuestionWhat it seeksExample (made up)
What?Identify the feature or patternWhich crops are grown in a valley?
Where?Locate and map its distributionTea gardens lie on the valley's hill slopes, rice on the valley floor.
Why?Explain the causeTea needs well-drained slopes, while rice needs flat land that holds water.

Worked example 1: sorting questions

Classify each question as what, where or why: (i) Which minerals are found in a plateau region? (ii) In which parts of a state are cotton mills concentrated? (iii) Why are most large cities on rivers or coasts? Reasoning: (i) identifies features, so it is a what question; (ii) asks about distribution, so it is a where question; (iii) asks for a cause, so it is a why question. Answer: what, where, why. Only the third explains a pattern.

Worked example 2: adaptation or modification?

Decide which response each shows: (i) people in a hot desert wear loose, light-coloured clothes; (ii) farmers build a canal to irrigate dry land; (iii) a family installs a cooler in one room. Reasoning: adjusting one's way of life is adaptation, while changing the environment is modification. Answer: (i) adaptation; (ii) modification; (iii) modification, a change to climatic conditions in a restricted space, as the chapter notes for coolers and air conditioners.

Key takeaways: geography treats nature and humans as one integrated whole; humans adapt to and modify nature, and technology moved them from necessity towards freedom, giving humanised nature and naturalised humans. Links and nodes organise and integrate space. Geography asks what, where and why; the first two give an inventory, popular in the colonial period, and the why question made geography a science.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which question made geography a scientific discipline?

    1. What?
    2. Where?
    3. Why?
    4. When?
    Show answer

    Answer: C. What and where only describe features and their locations. The why question seeks causal explanations, and the chapter says geography became scientific only when this third question was added.

  2. 2. In the study of spatial organisation, settlements of different types and sizes are called:

    1. links
    2. nodes
    3. routes
    4. barriers
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Routes are links, and settlements of all types and hierarchies are nodes; together they integrate and organise space.

  3. 3. A farmer building a check dam to store rainwater for the dry season is an example of:

    1. modification of the environment
    2. adaptation to the environment
    3. areal differentiation
    4. temporal synthesis
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Building a dam changes the environment to suit human needs, which is modification. Adaptation would mean adjusting one's way of life instead.

  4. 4. Read: 'In some periods, geographers mainly prepared lists of the features of different lands and where they were located.' According to the chapter, this inventory approach was very popular during:

    1. the period of Eratosthenes
    2. the present age of GIS
    3. the age of primitive societies
    4. the colonial period
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter states that the what and where questions gave inventorised information of features and their location, an approach very popular in the colonial period.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Present societies depend less directly on their immediate physical environment than primitive societies did.
    Reason (R): Technology has helped human beings loosen the shackles of their physical environment.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the explanation of A.
    3. A is true but R is false.
    4. A is false but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Primitive societies depended directly on their surroundings. Technology let people modify the environment and use resources over a wider area, which is why present societies are less directly dependent, so R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery