- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Climate change: evidence from the past and its causes
Use geological, geomorphological, biological and historical evidence to show that climate has always changed, recall the key periods the textbook names, and explain the astronomical, volcanic and human causes of change.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- List the kinds of evidence that show past changes of climate.
- Recall the main past climatic episodes the textbook describes, for India and the world.
- Explain sunspots, Milankovitch oscillations, volcanism and greenhouse gases as causes of climate change.
The climates described so far are those of today. The type of climate we now experience has probably prevailed for about the last 10,000 years, with minor and occasionally wide fluctuations. Over the earth's long history, however, climate has changed many times. Change in climate is a natural and continuous process.
How we know climate has changed
Evidence of past climates
- Geological records Show alternating glacial and inter-glacial periods.
- Landforms Features in high altitudes and high latitudes show advances and retreats of glaciers.
- Glacial lake sediments Layers reveal warm and cold periods.
- Tree rings Give clues about wet and dry periods.
- Historical records Describe the vagaries of climate: crop yields and failures, floods, migrations.
- Archaeological findings Show changing conditions where people lived, as in Rajasthan.
Climate change in India
India too has seen alternating wet and dry periods. Archaeological findings show that the Rajasthan desert had a wet and cool climate around 8,000 BC. The period 3,000-1,700 BC had higher rainfall, and from about 2,000-1,700 BC the region was a centre of the Harappan civilisation. Dry conditions have intensified since then.
The geological past
- The earth was warm about 500-300 million years ago, through the Cambrian, Ordovician and Silurian periods.
- In the Pleistocene epoch, glacial and inter-glacial periods alternated. The last major peak glacial period was about 18,000 years ago.
- The present inter-glacial period began about 10,000 years ago.
Climate in the recent past (as the textbook records it)
| Period | Episode |
|---|---|
| 10th-11th centuries | Warm and dry conditions in Europe, when the Vikings settled in Greenland |
| 1550 to about 1850 | The Little Ice Age in Europe |
| About 1885-1940 | World temperature showed an upward trend |
| After 1940 | The rate of temperature increase slowed down |
| 1930s | Severe drought in the south-western Great Plains of the USA: the dust bowl |
| 1967-1977 | Devastating drought in the Sahel, south of the Sahara |
| 1990s | Described by the textbook as the warmest decade of the 20th century, with some of the worst floods |
Causes of climate change
The causes can be grouped into astronomical and terrestrial causes, and human activity adds an important one.
- Sunspots (astronomical): sunspots are dark, cooler patches on the sun that increase and decrease in a cycle. According to some meteorologists, more sunspots go with cooler, wetter weather and more storms, and fewer sunspots with warmer, drier conditions. The textbook stresses that these findings are not statistically significant.
- Milankovitch oscillations (astronomical): cycles in the earth's orbital characteristics around the sun, the wobbling of the earth and changes in its axial tilt. These alter the insolation received and may affect climate.
- Volcanism (terrestrial): an eruption throws large amounts of aerosols into the atmosphere, where they stay for a considerable time and reduce the sun's radiation reaching the surface. After the eruptions of Mount Pinatubo and El Chichón, the earth's average temperature fell somewhat for some years.
- Greenhouse gases (human, anthropogenic): the most important human effect is the increasing concentration of greenhouse gases, which is likely to cause global warming (Lesson 5).
Natural and human causes of climate change
-
Natural causes
- Sunspot cycles in solar output
- Milankovitch oscillations of orbit, wobble and tilt
- Volcanic aerosols reducing insolation
-
Human (anthropogenic) cause
- Rising greenhouse gas concentration
- Fossil fuel burning and deforestation add CO2
- Likely to cause global warming
Climate change is natural and continuous: glacial and inter-glacial periods, wet and dry phases. Its causes include sunspots, Milankovitch oscillations and volcanic aerosols, and now, most importantly, the human addition of greenhouse gases.
Worked example 1: reading the timeline
How long after the last peak glacial period did the present inter-glacial begin? Working: peak glacial about 18,000 years ago; inter-glacial began about 10,000 years ago; 18,000 − 10,000 = about 8,000 years. How long did the Little Ice Age last? 1850 − 1550 = about 300 years.
Worked example 2: a source-based question
A made-up field report says: 'Pollen and lake mud near a dry lake in western Rajasthan show grasses and water plants in deep layers but desert plants near the surface.' What does this suggest? Reasoning: deep layers are older; water plants there mean a wetter past, while desert plants near the top mean drier recent conditions. This matches the textbook's account of a wet, cool Rajasthan around 8,000 BC and of drying since about 1,700 BC.
Worked example 3: why might a volcano cool the earth?
Link this to the heat budget (Chapter 8). Working: (1) aerosols from a large eruption stay in the atmosphere for a long time; (2) they reflect and absorb part of the incoming insolation, so less reaches the surface; (3) the surface receives less energy and the average temperature falls for some years, as after Pinatubo and El Chichón. Once the aerosols settle out, the effect fades.
Key takeaways: evidence from rocks, glacial landforms, lake sediments, tree rings, history and archaeology shows that climate changes naturally and continuously. Rajasthan was wet around 8,000 BC and had higher rainfall in 3,000-1,700 BC, the Harappan period; the earth was warm 500-300 million years ago, the last peak glacial was about 18,000 years ago and the present inter-glacial began about 10,000 years ago. Causes include sunspots (not statistically proven), Milankovitch oscillations, volcanic aerosols and, above all now, rising greenhouse gases.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the textbook, the last major peak glacial period was about:
- 10,000 years ago
- 18,000 years ago
- 300 million years ago
- 1,700 years ago
Show answer
Answer: B. The last major peak glacial of the Pleistocene was about 18,000 years ago; the present inter-glacial began about 10,000 years ago.
-
2. Which kind of evidence gives clues about past wet and dry periods year by year?
- Tree rings
- Sunspots
- Isobars
- Ocean salinity
Show answer
Answer: A. The rings in trees provide clues about wet and dry periods; glacial lake sediments reveal warm and cold periods.
-
3. Milankovitch oscillations refer to:
- cycles of sunspots on the sun's surface
- sudden volcanic eruptions
- cycles in the earth's orbit, its wobble and changes in its axial tilt
- changes in ocean salinity
Show answer
Answer: C. Milankovitch oscillations are cycles in the earth's orbital characteristics, its wobbling and changes in axial tilt, which alter the insolation received.
-
4. Assertion (A): A large volcanic eruption can lower the earth's average temperature for some years. Reason (R): Volcanic aerosols remain in the atmosphere and reduce the solar radiation reaching the surface.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: aerosols stay aloft for a considerable time and cut the insolation reaching the surface, as seen after the Pinatubo and El Chichón eruptions.
-
5. Read the case: A student claims, 'Sunspots have been proven to cause cool, wet, stormy weather.' Based on the textbook, the best response is:
- Correct; the link is statistically certain
- Wrong; fewer sunspots cause ice ages
- Wrong; sunspots have no connection with the sun's output
- Some meteorologists suggest such a link, but the findings are not statistically significant
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook reports that some meteorologists link more sunspots with cooler, wetter, stormier weather, but it states that these findings are not statistically significant, so 'proven' overstates the case.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.