- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Why biodiversity matters: ecological, economic, scientific and ethical roles
Explain the ecological, economic and scientific roles of biodiversity and the ethical argument for protecting species, and explain why more diverse ecosystems are more stable.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the ecological role of biodiversity and why diverse ecosystems are more stable.
- Explain the economic role, including agro-biodiversity, and the conflicts it can create.
- Explain the scientific and ethical reasons for protecting biodiversity.
Biodiversity has contributed in many ways to human culture, and human communities in turn have shaped the diversity of nature at the genetic, species and ecosystem levels. The textbook describes three roles of biodiversity: ecological, economic and scientific, and adds an ethical responsibility.
Roles of biodiversity
- Ecological Every species performs some function in its ecosystem; diversity brings stability.
- Economic A reservoir of resources: food, livestock, forests, fish, medicines.
- Scientific Each species offers clues to how life evolved and how ecosystems work.
- Ethical Every species has an intrinsic right to exist.
Ecological role
Species of many kinds perform some function in an ecosystem; nothing evolves and survives without a reason. Every organism, besides taking what it needs, contributes something useful to others. Species capture and store energy, produce and decompose organic material, help cycle water and nutrients, fix atmospheric gases and help regulate the climate. These functions are important both for ecosystems and for human survival.
The more diverse an ecosystem, the better the chance that its species will survive adversities and attacks, and so the more productive it is. Losing species reduces the system's ability to maintain itself. Like a species with high genetic diversity, an ecosystem with high biodiversity has a greater chance of adapting to environmental change: the more varied its species, the more stable the ecosystem is likely to be.
The more varied the species in an ecosystem, the more stable and productive it is likely to be, because more species share and back up its functions.
Economic role
For all people, biodiversity is an important resource in daily life. An important part of it is crop diversity, also called agro-biodiversity. Biodiversity is seen as a reservoir of resources for making food, pharmaceutical and cosmetic products. Important commodities it supplies include food crops, livestock, forests, fish and medicinal resources. The textbook adds a warning: this very view of biodiversity as a resource to be drawn upon is responsible for its deterioration, and it is also the source of new conflicts over rules for dividing and owning natural resources.
Scientific role
Each species can give clues to how life evolved and how it will continue to evolve. Biodiversity also helps us understand how life functions and the role each species plays in sustaining ecosystems, of which humans are also a part.
Ethical responsibility
It is our ethical responsibility to recognise that every species, like us, has an intrinsic right to exist, so it is morally wrong to cause the extinction of any species voluntarily. The level of biodiversity is a good indicator of the state of our relationships with other living species, and the idea of biodiversity is part of many human cultures.
A diverse and a simplified ecosystem
-
Diverse ecosystem
- Many species sharing each function
- Loss of one species is covered by others
- More productive
- More stable and adaptable
-
Simplified ecosystem
- Few species doing each job
- Loss of one species can break a function
- Less able to maintain itself
- More vulnerable to change and attack
Worked example 1: a pest outbreak
Two made-up farms face the same insect pest. Farm M grows a single crop variety across all its fields; Farm N grows several crops and keeps hedgerows where birds and predatory insects live. Reasoning: (1) on Farm M, every plant is equally vulnerable, and there are few natural enemies of the pest; (2) on Farm N, some crops are not attacked, and birds and predators reduce the pest; (3) so Farm N loses less. This illustrates both the ecological role (diversity gives stability) and the value of agro-biodiversity.
Worked example 2: classify the role
Name the role each statement shows. (a) A wild plant yields a compound used in a medicine. Working: a medicinal resource = economic role. (b) Earthworms and fungi break down fallen leaves and return nutrients to the soil. Working: decomposing organic matter and cycling nutrients = ecological role. (c) Comparing the bones of related species shows how a group evolved. Working: clues to evolution = scientific role. (d) A community refuses to hunt a rare bird because it believes every creature has a right to live. Working: intrinsic right to exist = ethical responsibility.
Worked example 3: a source-based reading
Read this made-up note: 'A valley lost most of its bee species after heavy pesticide use; orchard fruit yields then fell for several years.' Interpret. Working: bees perform pollination, an ecological function; losing many species removed the back-up that diversity provides; fruit yield, an economic resource, then fell. Ecological and economic roles are linked: harming one harms the other.
Key takeaways: ecologically, every species contributes something: capturing energy, cycling water and nutrients, decomposing matter, fixing gases and regulating climate; more diverse ecosystems are more productive and more stable. Economically, biodiversity supplies food crops (agro-biodiversity), livestock, forests, fish and medicines, though treating it only as a resource has caused its deterioration and new conflicts. Scientifically, species reveal how life evolved and functions. Ethically, every species has an intrinsic right to exist.
Check your understanding
-
1. Crop diversity is also called:
- agro-biodiversity
- ecosystem diversity
- exotic diversity
- species abundance
Show answer
Answer: A. An important part of biodiversity is crop diversity, which the textbook also calls agro-biodiversity.
-
2. Which is an example of the ecological role of biodiversity?
- Selling timber from a forest
- Fungi decomposing dead leaves and returning nutrients to the soil
- Using a plant to make a cosmetic
- Studying fossils in a museum
Show answer
Answer: B. Decomposing organic material and cycling nutrients are ecological functions that species perform in ecosystems.
-
3. According to the textbook, which idea has been responsible for the deterioration of biodiversity?
- Treating every species as having a right to exist
- Protecting habitats where species breed
- Viewing biodiversity as a reservoir of resources to be drawn upon
- Studying species to understand evolution
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook says the concept of biodiversity as a reservoir of biological resources to be drawn upon for food, medicines and cosmetics is responsible for its deterioration.
-
4. Assertion (A): An ecosystem with many species is more likely to survive an environmental change. Reason (R): The more varied the species in an ecosystem, the more stable it is likely to be.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: with more species sharing functions, the system can keep working when some species are harmed, so it adapts and survives better.
-
5. The statement that every species has an intrinsic right to exist reflects which reason for protecting biodiversity?
- Economic
- Scientific
- Climatic
- Ethical
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook calls it our ethical responsibility to accept that each species has an intrinsic right to exist, so voluntarily causing extinction is morally wrong.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.